Just Out of Interest, Is There Anyone Out There Who Actually Likes the Struggle Mechanic?

Fibijean
Fibijean Member Posts: 8,342
in Polls

From all the posts I've seen on the forums recently, and everyone I've talked to outside of the forums, it seems like there isn't anyone at all who likes the struggle mechanic and doesn't want it removed or changed. But as we all know, what seems to be the majority voice quite often is not, which is why I'm curious: is the struggle mechanic really universally hated?

While I'm sure some people feel very passionately about this, I've tried to keep the poll options as neutral as possible. Feel free to elaborate in the comments on why you feel the way you do, especially if you're someone who actually likes or at least doesn't mind the mechanic. I'm very interested to hear your point of view.

(Also, please note I'm talking about struggling on the hook, not wiggling on the killer's shoulder. Don't get confused.)

Just Out of Interest, Is There Anyone Out There Who Actually Likes the Struggle Mechanic? 64 votes

I like the struggle mechanic
6%
Seiko300TitanTubsangelnskyPrasie_Atua 4 votes
I don't like the struggle mechanic
67%
GibberishFibijeanYucchiPeasantNescauCheersfinitethrillsRoMainPuppybrokedownpalaceMegMain98PlanetJuke420Jacoby2041Aven_Fallenad19970ToppingPanicTheRockstarKnightJawsIsTheNextKillerAzurlynxBoosted_DwightHailoh 43 votes
I don't mind the struggle mechanic (neutral)
26%
MandyFoggyDownpourWhite_OwlGnomeuMegaWaffleDr_TrautssmappdoodaxEathen4321KeezoBabyClaudetteDetailedDetrimentPlantCollector[Deleted User]noname11223345Reborn2020NotDingus 17 votes

Comments

  • TheRockstarKnight
    TheRockstarKnight Member Posts: 2,171
    I don't like the struggle mechanic

    I have a friend who lives several states away, so when we play Survivor together she tends to experience more than her share of lag. It doesn't happen that often, but there have been more than a handful of times where she'll be pressing the struggle button and just die anyway thanks to latency.

    It's not that big of a deal, but it is annoying and the struggle mechanic itself doesn't provide anything positive to counteract this sentiment.

    I mean, what's it supposed to do? Oh joy, I get to mash a button for 30-ish seconds? Oh no, how scary it's the Entity's big spider toe?

    There are a few scary things in DBD, but the struggle mechanic is not one of them.

    At best it freaks out a brand new player the first time or two they experience it. At worst it annoys them because they're dead before they understand what's even going on. There's simply no reason for struggling as a button mash to exist and plenty of reasons for it to not exist.

    I propose Survivors struggle automatically, and hold a button down to give up.

  • Reborn2020
    Reborn2020 Member Posts: 1,138
    I don't mind the struggle mechanic (neutral)
    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1161205#Comment_1161205

    Use macro.

  • TheRockstarKnight
    TheRockstarKnight Member Posts: 2,171
    edited March 2020
    I don't like the struggle mechanic
    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1161221#Comment_1161221
    1. You clearly didn't read my comment. Pushing buttons rapidly isn't an issue for me or my friend.
    2. I'm pretty sure using macros is a bannable offense. Or at least it was at one point in time.
    3. I play on PS4.
    4. This doesn't do anything to resolve the issue of "Why does the struggle mechanic exist as a button mash anyway?", it's just a workaround. (Of which there are other, less dubious methods - like rebinding the struggle button to your mouse wheel or your joystick)
  • MegaWaffle
    MegaWaffle Member Posts: 4,172
    I don't mind the struggle mechanic (neutral)
    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/137752/just-out-of-interest-is-there-anyone-out-there-who-actually-likes-the-struggle-mechanic

    I don't hate the mechanic as you don't need to press the button very fast BUT latency can kill you even while you are pressing the button.

    I honestly think it should be changed as a QOL for controllers/keyboards and especially for those who cannot (or have limited ability) to spam the button.

  • Jacoby2041
    Jacoby2041 Member Posts: 843
    I don't like the struggle mechanic

    I hate it with a burning passion. Nothing in particular about it that makes me hate it, it's just annoying and pointless and it's just super dumb and annoying. On the bright side if a game isn't going so hot I can just die by not doing it. I wish they'd either make it a button hold or automatic. And they should do the same for wiggling while they're at it

  • Godot
    Godot Member Posts: 806
    I don't like the struggle mechanic

    Smashing a button..? Yeah, always hated that. In every single game that ever existed.

    Wish we could disable that somehow.

  • Murdle
    Murdle Member Posts: 119
    I don't like the struggle mechanic

    Always thought "what about the people with arthritis?".

    My hands personally don't hurt from MASHING the controller but it's so annoying to have to do.

    I wish I can just ?HOLD DOWN? the A button instead.

    I actually got so annoyed one day at having to do that I decided to just DC everytime strictly to avoid being on struggle.

    I only did that for a day then decided to just do this

    A... A... A... A... A...

    and not

    A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.A.

  • TitanTubs
    TitanTubs Member Posts: 43
    edited March 2020
    I like the struggle mechanic

    I don't love the struggle but I like the tension and fear it can create and that the game needs.

  • BabyClaudette
    BabyClaudette Member Posts: 109
    I don't mind the struggle mechanic (neutral)

    I don't really like the struggle mechanic because it makes my thumb hurt sometimes, but I understand why it's in the game and it makes sense why it's in the game.

  • Neot
    Neot Member Posts: 40
    I don't like the struggle mechanic

    I'd rather have skill check instead.

  • MegMain98
    MegMain98 Member Posts: 2,913
    I don't like the struggle mechanic

    I dislike it because of latency issues that can cause you to die even when you are rapidly pressing the button.

  • angelnsky
    angelnsky Member Posts: 17
    I like the struggle mechanic

    struggle mechanics is good, but the hooks are so close together now, it doesnt matter if you struggle or not.

  • White_Owl
    White_Owl Member Posts: 3,786
    edited March 2020
    I don't mind the struggle mechanic (neutral)

    I don't dislike it. I don't like it either, but I think it would be wierd having my Jake struggling for his life while I chill looking at my phone. Having to press the button makes me participate with his struggle.

  • Nescau
    Nescau Member Posts: 51
    I don't like the struggle mechanic

    Needing an extra effort to keep youself alive during the last stage before sacrifice? Fine. The struggle animation looks cool and the idea behind it is flavorful.

    Said effort consisting in mashing a button/key? NOT FINE. It is uncomfortable, but not in the tense, immersive way devs intended it to be. Mashing is just annoying and repetitive. All things considered, I voted blue because I want it changed.

  • Fibijean
    Fibijean Member Posts: 8,342
    I don't like the struggle mechanic
    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1169142#Comment_1169142

    As I stated in the OP, I'm talking about struggling on the hook, not wiggling on the killer's shoulder.

  • then4321
    then4321 Member Posts: 234
    I don't mind the struggle mechanic (neutral)
    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1161221#Comment_1161221

    Same, struggle and wiggle for me is nothing more than holding a button, effortless.

  • Joelwino
    Joelwino Member Posts: 550
    I don't like the struggle mechanic
    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1169142#Comment_1169142

    Struggling on your second hook, not wiggling off a killer's shoulders