Visit the Kill Switch Master List for more information on this and other current known issues: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/kb/articles/299-kill-switch-master-list
Get all the details on our forums: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/436478/sign-up-now-to-receive-a-recap-of-your-2024-dead-by-daylight-stats/p1?new=1
Ash,David,Bill,and Ace All Decide To Fight The Killers, Who Do They Take Down?
The 4 all challenge the Entity to stop weakening them and buffing the killers for a proper fight. The Entity agrees under curiosity. Each fight is separate and everyone heals afterward, so theres no cross battle damage. The only weapons the 4 get are rocks and heavy sticks. What killers do you think the 4 could take down? (They have to fight all 4 legion members at once btw)
Edit: I've seen some questions as to why ace is here and what these guys are supposed to have. Ace is here because of the fact he can get beaten down a lot and srill survive. For example, Ace baits out Ghost Face into attacking him, while this happens the other 3 jump GF and take him down. Plot armor is irrelevant because everyone ends up fine anyway.
Comments
-
They definitely take down 4 teenagers with knifes I mean bill killed zombies
5 -
Forget about Ace and David. David maybe takes on with the Legion while the other two rock the demon party. Just give Ash his boomstick and 3 seasons of time to get the job done
5 -
Evils got a target on his back the size of the tiger stadium, so I'm sure he'd fight the stronger ones.
0 -
Legion for sure. Ace is kinda just a dude but ash fights demons, bill fights zombies, and david fights in fight rings and the legion are basically just a bunch of teens with knives.
Probably nurse because all she's got going for her is a bone saw other than that she's a very frail lady.
Probably hag, she's not very much without the entity juice.
Oni, demo, deathslinger, pyramid head, blight, freddy, myers, bubba, billy, and huntress are all going to win every time.
The other killers are maybes because they're not very much without their magic powers but they are either pretty beefy or well trained ie. trapper(beefy) or spirit (well trained)
1 -
Question:
Are we rolling with the 'mindless killer' scenario here, or are we giving them the same sentience and personality they had before the entity snatched them?
1 -
Ace, as much as I love him, is just a suave gambler who gets into bets he probably shouldn't have.
David, a brilliant street fighter is just that, a street fighter. Strong, yes, but capable of dealing with hordes of monsters? Eh, probably not.
Bill, however, has fought zombies of varying calibers of deadliness so he absolutely has a chance to fight back.
Ash, well, Ash is Ash. You either view him as the world's greatest deadite slayer or you view him as the Chosen One, giving him infinite plot armor. Both are accurate, but if you want a serious discussion with real stakes, you have to view Ash as only the former. Problem is, if this was to actually happen ingame, Ash would kill every single killer through dumb luck, skill, and that groovy boomstick and chainsaw hand.
Add Steve and Cheryl to the mix, they're both proficient in dealing with monsters; Steve with his bat against Demogorgons and Cheryl with a slew of firearms and melee weapons against the forces of Silent Hill.
2 -
They all have the same intelligence as before the Entity took them. They keep all they're abilities though.
2 -
Everyone crapping on Ace needs to remember that he survived 5 minutes against a professional boxer who had the intent to kill. If Ash didn't have it, he'd probably have Mettle of Man.
Not saying he'd do much in a fight, but he would be a decent meat shield.
Edit: I need to read posts better, and not jump to comments.
3 -
then we need to lay out which killer would actually be down to fight, who'd prefer a different challenge and who'd just say 'screw this, i'm out'
0 -
Well, they are still in a trial so the entity might still be making them fight.
1 -
I mean, if they end up on lery's or Glenvale, someone might just decide taking a long overdue nap is the better call.
0 -
I could already imagine Ghost Face ditching lol,
1 -
someone might even start a discussion about why the entity put newspaper clippings on the bottles in the saloon
2 -
Trapper: Evan is EXTREMELY strong even without the Entity. Look at those muscles. They might be able to do it, but it will be the fight of their lives.
Wraith: While not nearly as muscular as Evan, Philip managed to take down Azarov on his own, and Azarov is described (in the old lore that you really have to dig around to find) as a large and muscular man. Sure, in that version, Philip hit him in the collarbone with a crowbar, but he's no pushover.
Hillbilly: Max's deformities might be his downfall, but he also broke down a brick wall on his own, so he's pretty strong.
Nurse: Without the Entity, I don't think Sally can even walk. She's always just floating, which isn't something that she can normally do.
Shape: Michael has (depending on the timeline) survived burning in a fire, multiple gunshots, explosions, stabbings, electrocution, etc. You can't bring down the embodiment of evil.
Hag: Without the Entity increasing her strength, I'm fairly certain even Ace could take down Lisa.
Doctor: Herman's electrokinesis appears to be from the Entity, and without that, he's not exactly muscular. He's a psychotic scientist, not a fighter. They could take him.
Huntress: Anna has taken on both the German and Russian armies ON HER OWN! Ace has luck, Bill has military training, David has muscles and Ash has experience, but none of them can handle someone who's been hunting and fighting all her life for survival. Anna wins.
Cannibal: Leatherface hasn't pulled off ANY of the survival feats that Michael has. He's done some very strong things, but nothing that Ash, David and Bill can't handle.
Nightmare: Without the Entity, Freddy's power has one limit: the infinite limits of dreams. Unless they could drag him out of the dream world, Freddy would have a field day with them.
Pig: Amanda died from a gunshot and was thrown around by someone with David's muscular stature. She stands no chance.
Clown: Kenneth was an athlete and had a reputation around his strength in the circus, but those days are far behind him.
Spirit: Rin is an onryō. There's one rule around those creatures: don't mess with an onryō.
Legion: Individually, they wouldn't be a problem, but all four at once would prove problematic for our heroes. I think they could do it, but it would rougher than many people are saying here.
Plague: Adiris literally couldn't stand anymore before the Entity reached her. Her leg was too swollen.
Ghost Face: The thing that makes Danny so dangerous is his cunning. In a one on four without the Entity's power, he's got nothing.
Demogorgon: They dead. Ash and Bill would put up a good fight, but they dead.
Oni: Kazan is a trained samurai warrior, heavily armored and an absolute giant. He could crush them with his bare hands.
Deathslinger: Caleb has a brace on his leg. Doesn't look like it will do him any favors.
Executioner: Pyramid Head is the embodiment of guilt. It's not something you can easily deal with. Sure, the Entity gave him powers he wouldn't normally have, but that doesn't change his power.
Blight: We know the serum gives Killers an unbelievable amount of strength, and Talbot's taken ALL of it. I don't think he would win, but it would be a close fight.
1 -
Decent analysis but you seem to forget who Ash is and what he's been through. If you think Anna could wipe the floor with Ace, Bill, and David, fair enough, I could see it. But it's Ash Williams we're talking about. Ash even without the boomstick/chainsaw is still the chosen one and is basically unkillable. Also, Blight taking that much serum means it wouldn't be a close fight, but as I said before, any fight with Ash is automatically skewed towards him. He's a joke character for a reason.
1 -
I hate to break it to you, but all killers, including Legion, are given incredible strength by the Entity. They are given better senses, and faster reaction times. I mean, what normal person gets hit by hundreds of pallets without feeling any effects?
So they would win against none.
Even if they could, the Entity would probably take great issue with that, and probably intervene personally.
And everyone is forgetting that Jeff is a fighter as well. He has been in his fair share of fights. That, and Ace is more of a run from his problems kind of person instead of a fighter.
1 -
Okay, I'm just gonna refer you to the first 2 sentences of the post for that one buddy.
0 -
Fine. Ace is still a runner and they forgot Jeff. : P
0 -
Thats fair, I did also explain why I picked Ace in the edit. I limited it to 4 survivors cause thats the normal amount per match, so thats why characters like Cheryl and Jeff weren't included.
0 -
Under these circumstances, they´d have a decently good chance of beating Pig, Legion, Ghostface, Bubba, Clown, Deathslinger and Billy.
They´d have a very slim chance of beating Trapper, Wraith, Huntress, Plague, Doctor
They can´t possibly beat Hag, Nurse, Spirit, Freddy, Oni, Myers, Pyramidhead and Demogorgon.
Obviously the gaps between each Killer´s power are very huge in some cases, even within "tiers". For example, Oni is so powerful he´s on a whole other level compared to the other Killers except maybe Freddy, but Demo and Myers would be just as unbeatable for them using only sticks and stones.
Evil Dead fan btw, but if we take Ash´s lore into consideration, we have to account for his opponent´s lore, too. Depending on the Version we´d have a literally unkillable Evil Incarnate Michael Myers for example. Against "magic tier" Killers like Nurse, Hag or PH sticks and stones won´t do much either.
1 -
They would have the best chance at beating the pig , ghost Face and legion because of there size comparison to the survivors
Possibly bubba and clown too
Don't know about rest because they are demonic
0 -
Idk about the others, but ash has fought Freddy before
1 -
Theyd probably beat plague, but they would get infected and die though...
0
