A killer tier list based on if they could beat batman

This. Prep time + plot armor = Batman will always pull something out of his bat glutes to win.

Indeed. "Prep time" is just a lazy writer's excuse to throw logic out the window and have Batman be the victor.

Why would Freddy be able to beat him? Batman's already familiar with a similar style of attack by Scarecrow. Not exactly the same, but still.

Yeah but Batman never dreams.

i mean, clown doesn't deserve to get clapped, since batman fights a clown every second issue and that clown is apparently always "one step ahead.." unless batman has a gas mask, clown is putting his booty down and taking a bat finger. anesthesing someone through a bottle throw that your immune to basically just means the clown needs to throw bottles at his feet and he eventually wins.

if pig has a bear trap on batmans head, she can simply activate it, as im pretty sure they were remote activated in the films at one point? thats instant death. besides even if it wasn't the pig doesn't play fair, and would be likely to just set it off for poops n giggles.

spirits literally an undead unbeatable sword weilding gal, who can teleport with minimal tracking. she'd just destroy bats bat booty.

hillbilly is stronger, and faster then bats and weilds a chainsaw, but bats is more mobile. honestly 50/50 with no prep, but only because bats can dodge.

leatherface... feel he'd also be the same as hillbilly even if he isn't quite as fast, he is still very very strong. be a bit of a bane situation

hag would destroy him with hexes n curses no question. being able to teleport faster then he can blink, and curse him to be destroyed much like her archive story.. yeah he's dead no question.

doctor has the ability to shock from a distance with "entiy magic", if bats suit isin't like, resistent to electricity, he's dead before he gets in 5 feet of doctor.

nurse is a psychotic teleporting demon spirit lady. she'd carve him up from behind before he can even react.

pretty much any killer with a supernatural or physical ability would win. clown would only win because he's pretty much a joker alternative for batman, but with added gas action. everyone else like ghostface or legion, there people he fights on the daily.

lore wise clowns gas is based on an anesthetic that knocks people out. gameplay wise its different, but its basically a functional knockout gas that he's immune to, he may be unfit, but that doesn't matter if he can just stand in a cloud that batman can't see through, enter or attack.

Even if were going off of a timer, pigs traps only last two minutes. she wouldn't leave a key for batman, that would be stupid. shes also known for rigging her traps.

Hillbilly can run faster then usain bolt, and broke through a brickwall with only his body. he may struggle to turn at high speeds, but if were talking realism, whilst a man can't turn on a dime, why would he need to run that fast in close quarters? just close the distance that batman can't run, and use his chainsaw. he's bane levels of strength, whilst being incredibly fast. batman just has to keep out of range, and outlast him. though the hill billy is also super durable, so im not sure anything but a precise battarang to the throat would do much and even then. gameplay is entirely different from the killers lore, their powers in the real world, and what they could actually do or have the potential to do.

leatherface is just a pudgy bane/batman. he's incredibly strong. and he has a chainsaw to make up for all the difference that combat experience and range would do. batman couldn't ever get close to him or bye bye head. he doesn't also react much to pain, so like...?

doctor... lightning doesn't work like that, and even if it did, madness does effect batman, as even seen in one of the latest issues against punchline using some scarecrow fear toxin with joker toxin stuff, which took him out for a while. being able to shock at a considerable range of up to 32 m or higher, make him see things that aren't there, and stop his movement. And the doctor clearly has the ability to kill with his shocks if he wants to, seeing as thats what his mori is, him burning them alive with a high amperage. i see the doctor as someone, who if out for the kill could absolutely kill any normal person, but is more interested in madness, and chaos, manipulating their minds, over actually killing them (Which is why he's useful to the entity, as that feeds of fear and hope, rather then death.) He's a master at unintentional but direct torture (Though he does it for study) but is one of the most cold, and efficent killers out there as he's not actually lost his mind. if he's going for the kill he'll get it, but he'd probably play it more like joker and attempt to toy with batman, which is the only reason he might lose.

Nurse may have to catch her breath due to pain after every blink, but shes also not really.. killable? she can be delayed, but isin't she technically dead/a spirit - going through the same realm as wraith? even so, the nurse would be far more accurate then she's shown in the game, as human accuracy over in game accuracy, so like... i think your overestimating batmans abilitys against a mostly undead or atleast spiritual corpse woman, who see's without eyes, and can teleport faster then people can move.

also forgot to add the trapper. he's a rough one, a batman even with no prep might be able to see his traps, might not, and in a one on one fight would be able to go toe to toe with him (though trapper likely wouldn't fall, due to the fact that he's very much like jason, powered up through the entity..) i equate him much to again bane, but with a machete. in a one on one, batman might be able to beat him senseless and would be a pretty even fight, but if batman steps in a trap (you stated that their all in their realms with perfect setup favoured for killer) his entire leg comes off. A bear trap in the game is nothing like a bear trap in real life. a bear trap will forceably amputate a human leg, instantly. do remember this is the guy that ended the entire macmillan estate mines, through trapping them both with explosives and other traps. higher kill count then anyone else in the cast actually. really just depends on it being a 1v1 (in which case really its 50/50, expecially since the trapper doesn't really respond to pain, having multiple metal rods sticking out of him) or if he's chasing batman into traps.

Lol @ people saying pig traps would do anything to batman. That's 1966 #########.

Freddy was beaten by bunch of kids in every movie. Why would batman struggle with him?

The only killers on that list who is even remotely a threat to Batman is Freddy, Oni, Pyramid Head and Demogorgon. However we can easily just solve this now.

• Freddy is basically Doctor Destiny on steroids but even so Batman could likely figure out how to deal with him - Likely the main actual threat here
• Oni is basically just bane but he needs blood.
• Pyramid Head cannot exist without James Sunderland
• Demogorgon pretty much is the biggest real time threat for Batman because if it's not those two engaged in a battle Batman would likely have to ensure no citizens of Gotham were attacked by this thing.

You can argue that the rest of the killers exist but the thing is most of them are just normal people with a weapon. I'd accept arguments of Nurse, Spirit, Plague and Pig but I'd still argue that all 4 basically have normal strength or equal strength to Batman. Also Pig would have to capture Batman to even be a threat since it's just Amanda Young from the saw series.

I'd say Freddy is the biggest threat because everyone needs to sleep and in Bruce's dreams he'd likely keep having nightmares about stuff in Gotham or his parents and wouldn't have his equipment. Aside from that in a one on one engagement I'd say likely Oni and even Spirit are likely the two biggest threats past that. For Oni it would be his unnatural strength and for Spirit it would be her speed.

The real question here is in the rules of engagement is it Batman or Bruce? Does he have his equipment on him or not?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TptTpwdwFwI

Pyramid head would win for sure if he was in silent hill. The town can help him by spawning tons of monsters and even of he does die, which he wont, the town can just summon him again.

Dude he kicked him in the stomach and forced him to inhale a bunch of knockout gas. It was super stupid. The crossovers always are. Google batman v hulk and you should see it.

Isn't freddy explicitly only a threat to people who fear him? And lol at whoever said batman isn't a lucid dreamer. This thread is full of people who've seen the recent movies and think they know anything.