Who to P3 next?

I usually choose to prestige killers if they either:

A - Didn't have a whole lot of decent perks to work with by level 50 (I don't usually spend a whole lot more on non-P3 characters once they're at that point). I tend to wait longer on prestiging killers who got good Bloodweb RNG with lots of perks I want to use. Especially if they wouldn't be moving to P3 yet (where I could then spam BP into 'em until I get all the perks I want).

OR

B - Are really low on add-ons or offerings that I like to use (ie, I'll usually avoid prestiging a killer with a whole lotta puddings, streamers, and anniversary cakes until I can use some of those up first).

Do any of your four options currently fit one or both of these criteria? Might make 'em a good option for prestige.

If you're going mostly based on what their Prestige cosmetics look like instead, then I'd definitely go for Clown or Ghost Face; I think their bloody outfits look better than what Wraith and Billy get (plus Wraith has a ton of great cosmetics to use instead).

That's the other one I use with his prestige usually. Looks kinda spooky imo.

This is what I usually use for ghostface. I feel like if you are super tryhard (which I am) you really want this robe or the classic ghostface robe. I have found that his default outfits give him away too much because of the floating pieces of cloth sticking out around corners when you want to stalk. And if you are not stalking as ghostface, you might as well play wraith.

That's about as good as I can come up with for Wraith prestige. Still kinda weak, but his P3 is very outdated.

I'd just go with whoever you want the cosmetic for unless you are going to be ~DUMPING~ BP into them and think the additional item rarity will make a difference over hundreds of hours.