When is a chapter good?

The_Daydreamer
The_Daydreamer Member Posts: 735
in General Discussions

This is really interesting. When is a chapter successful and good?

For me it is if the chapter theme is fitting/interesting, if the killer is unique, his power has a clear purpose and is mindfully balanced, if the survivor is appealing to me and if at least the perks are unique or/and useful. I don't care about how op or super strong a killer or perk is, but it has to be at least okay.

What are your thoughts? Especially now with the ptb.

Comments

  • tactic
    tactic Member Posts: 356
    edited March 2021

    Interesting theme, fun & good killer, balanced map, fun & balanced perks for both sides are all criteria

    a chapter doesn’t need to meet all these requirements however.

    Stranger Things introduced a map many don’t like and a killer with weak perks & add-ons but I still consider it successful for the 2 survivors & their perks it brought.

  • Phasmamain
    Phasmamain Member Posts: 11,531

    Mainly the killer. Darkness among us released one of the most hated killers which is probably one of the reasons Jeff is forgotten

  • MottledElm
    MottledElm Member Posts: 85

    Probably never tbh, everyone will always have something to complain about