Public yeah, because tournament level Tier lists are unrealistic. You don't go against Tournament Level Survivors every game. But yeah, my list was intended to include public games.

But sure. If we include tournament play then we can add Nurse, Spirit and J-flick Blight to S and every other Killer to D because every other Killer will lose against Tournament Survivors.

Doctor is countered by holding W and predropping pallets once he is gets even the slightest chance of using shock therapy against Survivors. You probably have to have a giga brain to get the shocks going. And even if you do, shocking Survivors around loops for 1 simple M1 takes so much time, time in which the other Survivors can rush the gens.

Oni has to M1 to get this Power, do you think that you can get those M1's fast against Tournament Survivors? I can't, because Survivors will just loop me around stuff and drop pallets early when they see me coming. He is strong in his power, but he needs to get this power.

Billy has good mobility. He maybe has some potential with Bamboozle against Tournament Survivors, but once they realize Billy has Bamboozle, they will adjust to it and play safe. Billy even with Bamboozle will become an M1 Killer when Survivors know how to loop.

Twins? They are good and certainly not bad, but not good enough to deal with Tournament Survivors.

Slinger has to low mobility. Great chase potential, but Survivors who rush gens will crush Slinger.

Demo is a good boi Killer and underrated by pretty much the whole community but he will struggle against tight loopers just like the rest of the other 20 Killers.

so i'm... scary?