You think Michael Myres needs a bit of a... update?

Maybe have it so that survivors don't have finite stalk, rather after stalking a single survivor for a while the evil you gain from them is reduced, like an efficiency penalty that discourages following the blind idiot all game but you can still take advantage of said idiot if needed. Perhaps have so that when you accrue a penalty on one survivor, stalking a different survivor reverts that penalty over time. So the most efficient way is to stalk around but following ole' reliable is still available as an option.