The second iteration of 2v8 is now LIVE - find out more information here: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/kb/articles/480-2v8-developer-update
Xbox and Windows Store players may have difficulty in matchmaking due to an issue affecting their platforms. Please check https://support.xbox.com/en-CA/xbox-live-status for more information. Thank you.

Who would win in a fight? Nurse or Doctor?

Based on lore and in game abilities who would win in a fight to the death?

Comments

  • glitchboi
    glitchboi Member Posts: 6,023

    This one will be interesting.

    I'm willing to say Doc. His "stick" can crack a skull if he uses full force, and since Nurse gets stunned after blinking as well as gets a cooldown, it gives Doc a chance to get a hit in. I'm also pretty sure he'd be able to take a hit from her bonesaw.

  • Triadequinaxor
    Triadequinaxor Member Posts: 213

    nurse can blink outside the radius of shock

  • EvilJoshy
    EvilJoshy Member Posts: 5,295

    The Nurse also isn't touching the ground. Unless Doc performs a mori I don't think he can shock her.

  • Jivetalkin13
    Jivetalkin13 Member Posts: 747

    I mean when Doc uses Static Blast it gets survivors all around him, even when they are on an upper floor.

  • Alice_pbg
    Alice_pbg Member Posts: 6,556

    Since nurse is physically weak, pretty sure doc can destroy her in 1 hit. He tanks a hit, she gets her stun, he wins.

    If she could teleport at will, I would give it to her, but she can't.

  • TAG
    TAG Member Posts: 12,871

    This one is actually a hard one, but I think I lean toward Nurse? The Doc shocks can definitely slow her down, but she's already kinda crazy so I imagine the mental damage would be limited. From there, she just needs to close the distance with some blinks and seal the deal.

  • ABannedCat
    ABannedCat Member Posts: 2,529

    Lorewise, Nurse can blink without fatigue, as evident by her mori animation.

  • SMitchell8
    SMitchell8 Member Posts: 3,302

    Doctor won't lose put it that way

  • Vyne456
    Vyne456 Member Posts: 848

    Nurse blinks into a deadstop

    attacks the doctor

    Michael from GTA V: I seen some bad drivers, woo woo wooh!

  • CornHub
    CornHub Member Posts: 1,864

    Nurse. She could teleport knives inside of the Doctor.

  • Huge_Bush
    Huge_Bush Member Posts: 5,407

    Nurse. She’d just telekinetically choke The Doctor at a distance. Heck, she can probably wreck his body as if she was breaking a pallet.

  • Dwight_Fairfield
    Dwight_Fairfield Member Posts: 7,015

    Nurse. She floats in the air so she is already immune to Doctor's shock attacks. Then simply do a nice spicy blink and bury her weapon in his skull.

  • MadLordJack
    MadLordJack Member Posts: 8,814

    It depends on how Doctor's shock functions. If it's purely ground-or-touch based, then Nurse's ability to blink would be overpowering, and she has mild telekinesis as well. If, however, she is affected by his static blast, then he stands a decent chance to catch her. Still, Nurse will probably win.

  • PureDoctorMain
    PureDoctorMain Member Posts: 341
    edited September 2021

    Close range Doc wins. One wack from the "stick", which is electrified, and she's out for the count easy. Long range though that ones rough. If doc can get a read on the blink and dodge then swing he's got it. He is incredibly smart and a master of the mind. But if the Nurse is faster a quick swipe to the neck is gonna be a deal breaker. And even if she can't get a clean hit she can just blink hit blink away. and do that till he dies of blood loss.

    This one is hard.

    Edit: it doesn't help the Nurse that Doc doesn't really care about pain. So he can keep going for a while.

  • Shroompy
    Shroompy Member Posts: 6,651

    While The Doctor is more bulky and probably wields a more dangerous weapon, The Nurse is given her powers by The Entity herself.

    How ever we dont know exactly how light burn works and what exactly triggers it, its very possible The Doctors electricity could cause light burn as there is a small flash of light when ever he shocks, and a big one when ever he blasts

  • GrimoireWeiss
    GrimoireWeiss Member Posts: 1,452

    I think Nurse wins. Watching her pallet and breakable wall breaking animations you can see besides her blinks she has a sort of telekinesis ability, so she could probably choke him from a distance.

  • LegacySmikey
    LegacySmikey Applicant, Member Posts: 616

    Nurse she's the strongest killer (well not i'm i'm using her sure) & regardless how many times doc zaps her assuming it actually hits would it really effect her anyway?

    Unless it stopped her blink I doubt it, she'd probably blink in after a blast & take him out in under a minute or two

  • Jivetalkin13
    Jivetalkin13 Member Posts: 747

    Just a reminder that Static Blast effect everyone in a dome radius, even if they are in the air.

  • Dwight_Fairfield
    Dwight_Fairfield Member Posts: 7,015

    Yeah but he only gets to use that every so often. The majority of the time he really has no power against Nurse.

  • Ludicris
    Ludicris Member Posts: 244

    Nurse.

    Nurse is undead, a ghost, phantom, of the like. Doctor is Human.

  • ukenicky
    ukenicky Member Posts: 1,352

    I wonder if Nurse could even really be affected by Doctors Shock treatment. She's already past the breaking point of insanity.

    If anything I'm more concerned about the physical parameters of these matchups. Nurse is a little delicate thing compared to Doctor. We had this same issue with Trapper vs Pig thread and if both killers are powered by the Entity for these fights then they SHOULD be evenly matched in their strength and endurance due to the Entity's blessing.

    Anyways, I want to say Nurse personally only because I feel like she probably wouldn't be affected by shock treatment at all or could blink to dodge it and then hit him. The issue is her fatigue after blinking which realistically, anyone would have enough time to land a hit on her but would ONE hit really be enough if she's empowered by the Entity?

  • Jivetalkin13
    Jivetalkin13 Member Posts: 747

    I'm trying to remain as impartial as possible, as whatever your decision is could affect who goes to the next round.

    I will say, that Nurse has her strength compensated with the telekinesis when break anything, while Doctor uses his raw strength.

    Also, even though she is off the ground. Doc's shocks can still affect survivors while they are mid vault of windows and pallets. So either it is getting to them while in the air or it's being conducted through the vaulted object. Which is remarkable now that I give it more thought, because wood is a really bad conductor.