Hand-Waving and Leatherface // BHVR's Slow and Ineffective Action
In fear of not being taken seriously, I have to preface this with the fact that yes, I am black. I have been the target of racism in online video games as well. That's all to say that...
Removing Leatherface's customization options does absolutely nothing to solve the issue of the rampant racist targeting of our black DBD community. If anything, this makes it harder for people to know with certainty who is unfairly targeting them now that these racists don't have a means of (stupidly) identifying themselves and what they're aiming to do in the game.
My problem here also isn't that the masks were removed. I don't play Bubba too often, nor do I have the masks in question. My problem here is that this is a hand-wavy solution to a serious issue that the DBD community has and that BHVR has yet to meaningfully address. The blatant targeting of players who belong to a specific group of people. This happened back during Pride month until the homophobes realized that there are too many people with Pride charms on and they're losing their games. Now it's happening again against the black players-- small streamers in particular getting the worst of these attacks. But with removing these cosmetics, all I see is "We hear you!" and "Cosmetics gone, problem gone!" and "No more racism!" Without actually doing anything about it.
And that always seems to be the problem; BHVR is extremely slow to act on anything. We can see it with our rampant and longstanding cheating problem and with these same players even blatantly streaming their cheating, with the same names popping up. Then, when BHVR finally takes action, it's probably (usually) not effective in actually solving these issues.
Bl*ckface is an intentional twisted satire. It's a depiction of a racist stereotype of a black person, meant to depict them as less than. Leatherface is quite literally just wearing someone else's face because he's insane. There is no attempt to stereotype. There is no attempt to see them as lesser-- as he does the same to Claudette's white and Asian peers. We can't attribute these negative meanings to everything in the game just because Racist John decided it'd be funny if something that can be vaguely seen as racist is what he wore when he targeted black players-- otherwise we'll get to people clamoring for the removal of a certain killer that can vaguely represent the imagery of a certain racist cult.
So, BHVR, this is your call to action. Why don't you start cracking down on these racists? Why don't you start monitoring their post-game chat logs? After the many many reports, and many many instances of video evidence, why aren't these people banned? Racists will continue to plague the game long after these masks are removed, and you've just made them a lot harder to identify... unless you get up and actually do something to stop these people.
Comments
-
They don't because racists and hackers buy cosmetics too. It's all about money. Removing a cosmetic that was free costs BHVR nothing and creates the illusion they've done something to combat any sort of toxicity in their community when their actions show they actually couldn't care less
1 -
Without trying to be antognistic, I just feel like this is how BHVR decides to handle sensitive or otherwise controversial things
They just typically pick the option of least resistance or don't acknowledge the problem at all (See: cheaters, still ZERO word from bhvr about it)
With regards to this cosmetic in particular, they had a few options:
- Remove Smartface only - get backlash from the community for being selective and ignoring what other people were saying (Stuff about the Jake mask and such)
- Leave the mask as is and continue to get the complaints and enable the behaviour that is being complained about
- Set out to actively ban the people doing what a mod called 'provable' things, as to not punish the whole dbd community for the actions of what I hope are a very small minority of players. Call that optimism if you want, I'd like to think I'm entitled to it.
- Just remove all the masks and never have to worry about this issue again
And as you can imagine, #4 is just the option of least resistance. Sure people will talk about it, but they probably won't complain too much esp given the context.
There's also something to be said about the precedent this sets about removing content for how it's being used in the game regardless of the context of the thing being used. I'm not here to debate that, it's just something I was thinking about while reading these threads
3 -
I feel like it's cool that your taking away a tool that is used for some bs but that doesn't solve the problem that person is still going to harass people and still cause just as much of a problem now they just don't have a cosmetic to do it. The actual problem is still there band-aid fixing everything is not the awnser.
I'm a white male so I don't get the hate like the targets do but I can still see how little effort this is and maybe my opinion doesn't matter because I don't have to deal with it thats just my 2 cents.
1 -
Personally I feel like removing the masks is a defeat against racism. As you said, there is nothing racist about the mask themselves but it's the behaviour of some people the problem. Let's work toward punishing them more, instead, let them know their racist behaviour is not welcome in this game. Otherwise they will just find other ways to be dicks to others, while everyone else lose something cool (which they even bought and had to earn, I would add). I'm disappointed by BHVR's choice of action.
1 -
I want to assure you that regardless of your race, I think your opinion matters on a subject like this, as this is something that can be viewed through the lens of a few community issues in the past (e.g. Pride charm targeting). Of course our solution wouldn’t be to remove the charms for the “safety of the community,” but to instead condemn those who are targeting people and punish them.
Exactly. I’m not saying BHVR should show how much they support their black players and chant BLM all day on socials, as that’d ultimately feel performative. Simply updating the terms of service and cracking down on these racists is the move they should go with.
0 -
Thank you for at least being a voice of reason...
0