The “That killer wouldn’t fit the game” argument is dead now.

You honestly think dbd’s gameplay can capture the feeling of playing xenomorph?

I mean they can run on all surfaces so confining them to the single plain that encompasses a dbd chase would be kinda crappy.

But making play like a xenomorph should, running up and over walls etc, would just break the game.

You’d probably end up with the xeno being nothing but a killer skin with a lunge. It’d be a meh game experience.

"were super annoying about it and have left a sour taste in many mouths."

worst argument ive seen on him yet.

if its left a sour taste in your mouth, I'd say get over it. People can want things, and it did was show that people in the community would want it, which is more important considering not everyone is going to like everything so a few no's should never stop a chapter.

Does it have to capture the exact feeling?

does Demogorgon capture the feeling of the monster in Stranger Things?

i wouldn’t say so, but Demo is still a very fitting and beloved killer in general.

Freddy is another example (though he has other issues and kinda needs some reworks)

inclusion of horror icons in DbD doesn’t mean it has to be a 1:1 portrayal. Now I agree some things don’t work such as Jaws shark or Piranhas. But a Xenomorph can work just as much as Demodog works. Especially considering the Xenomorph drone can be influenced by the Entity just like they are being controlled by their Queen.

Think bigger.

They're doing a Winnie the Pooh slasher flick, right?

Lilo is the killer, right?

In a way sure. Your completely skipping the giant tentacle that comes from him. Also I wouldn't call any off the killers in dbd scary. Is pretty obvious you haven't play much if any RE because I think you would have a better understanding of wesker himself.

Yes. The cast is much too diverse at this point to say X type of killer could never be a thing.

Unfortunately you are right that they will never be able to make the xenomorph the perfect organism like its supposed to be, and just making at another "lunge" killer or some other killer clone that they've been releasing alot lately

See, I’m not even attracted to women, but just the raw energy that she gives off pulls me to her. And even tho I may not swing that way, I can and do appreciate oppai.

You tell me Wesker doesn't fit in the game yet we have stupid outfits for survivors and killers alike and some other original and licensed killers exist in the game.

I remember the stupid argument that Trickster doesn't fit in the game while overlooking his backstory and lore. What just because Trickster isn't fat and disgusting like Clown he isn't allowed to be in the game?

Same goes for Wesker - Fits just as much as any other killer in the game.

That being said - Was never against the addition of abnormal content and I'm all for Springtrap even though I doubt it happens mostly because the person you'd have to negotiate with to get the license rather than the content itself.

So. How does Suzie -an edgy teenage girl with a mask and a knife- make the cut but somehow Trickster (Kpop btw) -a sadistical serial killer, taunting his victims and having experience in torturing and killing while loving the spotlight- doesn’t? It’s not even Suzie alone but all Legion members. And even other killers - Ghostface doesnt make that much more sense either if you think more than 1 second about him and the outfit.

edit: is Trickster actually a twink? Seems way too old and muscular (yeah not bodybuilder muscular but still..) for that term imo?

He's twinky enough for me to consider him one. I've heard the "Legion doesn't fit either" argument a lot, but let me put it this way... If you were walking down the street at night and saw one of the Legion dressed in their hoody and their creepy serial killer mask, and on the other side of the street saw a rather thin man dressed in an open shirt and tacky pants, which would intimidate you the most? Even if the Trickster had his lightsaber vwoom baseball bat with him, he still looks like a strong gust would blow him over.

It's more that masks are inherently creepy, as hiding your face is often considered such and usually triggers uncertainty in peoples' minds. Well, while I disagree with your opinion, I respect it regardless.

To me Wesker doesn’t fit because of his look. If they had went with his mutated, uroboros form he would have felt more thematically appropriate. It would be like if they added Patrick Bateman in his business suit. Like, yeah - he’s a serial killer from a horror film but thematically at least put him in his blood spatter poncho. (Though I would like to see his hilarious perk names - Walking on Sunshine comes to mind)

My only issue with Trickster is the sound his bat makes. It sounds more like a wiffle ball bat than something that would actually do some damage.

Some random knight killer would be met with my best nea-entity ‘meh’.

"It's all ogre now."

I don't see how Trickster doesn't fit. For a game that has dark lore and often touches on realistic and sensitive topics, he fits in pretty fine.

Or does he not fit in to you because you think horror is just guys in masks wielding that wield bladed weapons.