Medkits need a rework. Generally speaking it will take you somewhere between 30-90 seconds to hit a survivor depending on how good they are, what killer you are playing, where they are on the map and the RNG of the terrain. Using a medkit takes 9-32 seconds which is stupid.

Brown kit should be self care speed with exactly 1 heal if you don't miss a check.

Yellow kit should be 25% faster with maybe 1.5 charges (you get 2 with strong addons)

There should not be a way to heal yourself faster with a kit than another survivor could heal you normally. No setup should ever give you more than 2 heals with a medkit.

Things would be different if we changed the Mori into a universal type of debuff (kind of like what VHS does). Imagine for example if killers could use a secret addon and on hit applied sloppy butcher by using the SB offering (which would replace mori). I'm not suggesting we implement an offering to replace a perk but hopefully you get the idea that a new effect could be created.

-"Eruption"

On paper the changes sounded fine but it just ends up punishing people who are not playing on coms far too much. Eruption should be a perk that if the generator is kicked and a survivor goes down then that generator cannot be interrupted from regressing for 45 seconds (and any non hex totem perk affecting regression speed such as Overcharge or CoB is applied but not ruin for example). Nobody ever wants to lose control of their character.

Before someone cries, "Skill issue!" as they usually do on this specific topic.

I don't think this is a massive issue but I do agree that it doesn't make much sense to have it anymore.

Maybe if a Survivor is sacrificed on a Scourge Hook, it'll lose its Scourged status?

Yes, because Scourge Hooks can be very powerful.

Getting rid of them while not destroying the Hook after a sacrifice seems like a good compromise

Respectfully disagree, killer basekit is pretty loaded at the moment. Unless you are working against a Sabo SWF crew you are able to get to a second hook. No need to nerf killers further.

Right, and then you're gonna say that it's a fair change because, "If someone's dead, you're already winning." As if good survivors can't still get 2 or 3 out in a 3v1, or as if the first person dead is at like 4 or 5 gens left. What if it was the only scourge hook that was in range? You just lose your perk for doing your job, like with Ruin?

Seriously, this change needs to be implemented, especially because Midwich hooks can be a nightmare to deal with. You permanently lose one hook and suddenly one side of the map can be completely dead for the rest of the trial.

I guess you missed the part where I said the gate was open. How would I have time to down and carry 3 people, who were all in close proximity to the gate, somewhere farther in the map? How does that concept even make sense? lol.

Exactly. I feel like the people who are fine with this, must not play killer very often lol. I don't understand in what world people find it okay to not be able to complete your objective for no reason other than RNG.

So turn into a 3-perk killer, off of something that is completely up to RNG, and that's a skill issue? Do y'all hear yourselves sometimes, I mean really? Skill issue this, skill issue that, but y'all don't have anything to justify why it's a skill issue. It's hooking, which you have to do. There's no skill in that per se, but there shouldn't be. And news flash, anybody can lose off of losing a hook spot, which I shouldn't have to explain.

You want to punish killers for hooking on a certain hook, but you would lose your minds if we said to survivors, "Your gen-related perks deactivate if you did too many in a certain area. Skill issue, btw." The only reason this is even up for debate is because it's already in the game, so it's accepted as normal. Not a survivor-sided, unnecessary mechanic, which it is, but normal. If destroyed hooks on death had not been a thing, and were introduced as a new mechanic, there would be mass outrage because it's an absolutely outrageous mechanic.

Slugging is a skill.

while i think bleeding out is cringe. slugging even for 10-20 seconds can really help out the killer. and its not my fault if a survivor decides not to pick them up

bleeding out and slugging are different things. one can help turn the game in ur favor the other is just BM cringe.

If a base kit unbreakable comes along, it will be changed, as the developer cannot be unaware of this used hook problem.

Even now it is an outdated system, but I hope this thread catches your attention.

Hook break is fine, the RNG hook spawn is the problem, there should be fixed hook spawn location on each map, where there is always 1 hook right next to the Gates, and 1 for every corner. Then given 1 hook per 1000m square of the map.

This is to keep killers managing hooks but not suffer from bad RNG.

This was the worst hook spawn I ever had, though hook break should stay.

SWF, in my opinion it breaks everything.

all those Badham map variants. like if i understood in the 2019 anniversary they wanted to make all maps have variants, but it clearly was scrapped. just delete them and keep 1 version like the others. waste of game space.