God Loops and Dev Priority
Ok, the long and short of this is a question : "Why do certain 'god loops' still exist, despite how apparently easy it is to fix them?" Surely the devs can take the time to fix existing content in addition to making new content.
To clarify what I mean, there are certain loops in this game that some people call "infinites" (they're not) that can waste a huge amount of a killers' time, to the point where they essentially become safe zones survivors can run to knowing any good killer will not chase them through said zone. These loops are extremely long (long enough, in some cases, to break chase and reset bloodlust) and generally unmindgameable due to their length or position, and thus the only way for a killer to deal with them is to leave survivors be if they can make it to said loops. Them being Mindgameable is a big deal, because mindgames are the main way loopable killers mitigate the amount of time waste per loop. Mindgames function both for the killer and the survivor, and are arguable the deepest expression of mechanical skill this game has at the moment - to have that taken away is to deny both sides meaningful interaction, and condemns the killer to deal with unmitigateable time waste with no way to respond. These issues are obviously more glaring against killers who have no way to mitigate these loops (Pig, Ghostface, Wraith, etc....even Hillbilly).
I know these are not "muh infinites", so don't come after me with the dumb yarn of "B-but if you do the loop perfectly for three minutes, you can get a hit on a survivor!!". That's a stupid thing to do if you're playing killer, because three minutes will lose you the game for a single hit. Period. My point is that these loops end games, and know this, can force killers to cede chases, massively reducing the amount of pressure they can exert on survivors or certain gens depending on spawns.
I also know not to chase survivors at these loops unless they really mess up. I am not arguing about strategy to mitigate these loops that convey near complete safety, I am arguing about why they still exist. There should not be designated safe areas for survivors, especially ones that have generators in or near them. The conventional strategy should never be "That part of the map is so broken that you should implicitly know not to set foot there"
Furthermore, I know that there should be a mix of weaker and stronger loops in the game. I'm not advocating for nuking all strong loops in the game (Although I'd like it if Fractured Cowshed's numerous safe loops got nuked). Killer shack is a strong loop, it's fine and it appears on almost every map. I simply think there are massive, gaping holes in DBD's map design that can be exploited in a way unbecoming of a balanced game.
Some examples of "god loops", in my opinion, include
- The Ironworks lower floor window loop. It's quite long, not mindgameable, and can be milked three times before the entity blocks it, assuming your chase isn't broken for some arbitrary reason while looping it, in which case a pallet often spawns in the path of the loop as well as there being adjacent jungle gym tiles.
- Wretched Shop can spawn with two open windows facing each other, creating a loop that may as well be infinite, as it goes from two fast vaulting windows around the back of the shop with sometimes multiple pallets along the way or in reach. This thing may as well be infinite and there is nothing a killer can do to mitigate this on their own.
- Torment Creek has the same issue as Wretched Shop that turns the back third of the map into an absolute safe zone, even if only one window spawns on it
- Mother's House has some ridiculous window placements that can occur in the central building that only exacerbate the map's existing problems (Size, lack of cover around the central building, etc).
- Wretched Abbatoir's window spawn can range from strong to outright broken at times. Many God Window spawns.
- Lery's double window near the strong Library loop. This one can be mindgamed if the survivor is bad, but in my experience, good survivors abuse this to the point where I don't even check anymore.
- Remove Haddonfield please.
- There are definitely more that I see when I play, but these are the ones that I always look to exploit as a survivor and dread to see as a killer. Remind me of some more.
Keep in mind, these loops often can work in combination with spawned pallets and jungle gym structures that can further boost their strength.
My question, I guess to the developers is this : These loops seem quite easy to fix on their own. These loops are well known. Why have they not been addressed?
The devs have time to re-work Freddy Krueger and cook up a whole new map, killer, and two survivors for Stranger things, but they don't have time to tinker with the main buildings of a few maps? Am I really to believe that moving the Ironworks window over or stopping the Wretched Shop from spawning to adjacent windows is too much work for the developers when they have been extraordinarily productive in other areas? These problems are well known, and unlike other issues, the solutions seem relatively clear - why then, have they been left for so long?
The answer I expect is a bit disheartening. I assume they are going to leave these areas broken until some time in the long-awaited future where they finally "re-work" all the maps they have created, as they have done to Badham (which I have mixed feelings on, by the way). If this is the case, I fear that we will have to deal with (or enjoy) having areas of almost guaranteed safety in this game simply because the devs cannot bother to make minor tweaks to maps, instead promising "comprehensive reworks" to maps that perhaps will never come.
TL;DR : If the devs can pump out new killers and content consistently, why haven't they made minor mapping changes that could fix problems that have been known to exist for years?
With everyone talking about big, core issues, I think it'd be easier to ask for a change that is more easily fulfilled.
Comments
-
Laziness that's it.
7 -
This 100%
With this years focus revolving primarily on “game health,” I wish the devs would rather commit on map reworks than bring in new content at this point (along with other quality of life changes). The new Hawkins map is a show of good faith that they’re trying to make more mind game friendly areas, but it’s really urgent that the base games layout needs to be fixed to help simmer down the core problems DBD is plagued with atm.
6 -
It's not laziness. Maybe it's because they're prioritizing monetizeable content over renovating new maps, for obvious reasons, but I wouldn't demean them with an accusation of laziness.
4 -
If they take God lops away they are making survivors less wanna play cuz without God loops the game last less and there aren't that many
5 -
Its gonna be amazing when all new newbies come into this game and get looped into oblivion by t-bagging smurfs.
I wonder why this game got such low new player retention?
8 -
They aren't removing these because removing some of them would be taking away balance.
3 -
If people stop playing survivor just because they can't use those incredibly safe loops the entire match, then I don't know what to say anymore. Pallet loops that are safe are fone, as long as there aren't many of them, simply because once the pallet is down killers can destroy pallets. However, killers can not do anything against safe window loops except for running around those loops until the entity blocks of the vaults. Something like that shouldn't exist.
2 -
Haddonfield needs the same treatment Badham got.
2 -
I highly doubt replacing god loops with manageable loops would destroy "balance" for any besides people who rely on these loops heavily.
4 -
Give Haddonfield 5 map combos.
1 -
Because the devs have clearly shown that balance must be survivors side, and removing this tiles by adding a damn door would create a thunderstorm.
At the same time the priority is money, thus map redesign is not a priority.
That's also the reason why it's taking so long to fix them, the illusion if doing something but practically not enough to upset survivors
2 -
I'll take 1,000 less Survivor players over 1,000 less Killer players
1 -
Clicky-Click-Barbar-ra-Trick
Waves the magic wand.... FIXED!
Can't always get that 4K... sometimes you gotta work for it... or settle for the 3K.
2 -
"balance"
This word you say. I do not think it means what you think it means.
4 -
Killers need someone to kill.
This is a game that people choose to play. Give them a reason to quit and then how will you satisfy that bloodlust?
0 -
Take away bloodlust while they are at it too.
1 -
This would be a bad reason to allow certain structures such as the disturbed ward, wretched shop and fractured cowshed to remain the way they are. If anything, these loops allow two particular mechanics that exist which punishes players who play the actually balanced tiles and encourages them to just run to the super safe structures instead.
I don't believe that many survivors would actually quit because all fixing these structures would do is just make it so people can't hug the buildings with balanced landing and would actually need to rely on being good at mindgames in order to survive, which fixing these structures would also likely come with the removal (or a nerf) of bloodlust and possibly the entity blocker as they wouldn't be necessary anymore.
2 -
If brainlessly running around a safe loop is what makes people wanna quit the game, then they should take a knock on the head and remember that this is supposed to be a survival horror game, not a bully simulator.
7 -
Fixing those loops will have to be addressed at some point, but those entire maps are made of the generic jungle gym tiles. If they’re gonna rework them they will probably have to do a bunch of balancing work to create better loops like Badham.
In all honesty I wish they would do a quick replacement of those windows with an extremely safe pallet, so it’s a once time use deal. That way killers don’t have to deal with the frustration of it while they come up with a better solution
4 -
While i agree with this, i also want to point out that there are some extremely unsafe if not completely "dead" zones in the maps. An example can be basically the entire shelterwoods or rottenfield, all the external zones of the Swamp and some huge areas in macmillan maps.
Just removing these big safe zones would make bigger problem especially for these maps, where the only real safe zone is the main building with a lot of unsafe zones around.
Also, is not really that easy to fix loops like ironwork's. Adding a door near the window will make it extremely unsafe, but placing it too far away will still allow to take the right turn and keep looping.
1 -
Sorry, I was under the assumption that you just wanted these loops removed entirely rather than kept but made slightly less awful. In that case I agree with you, they need to be kept, but definitely reworked.
0 -
I know it's a little inconceivable but I actually do understand what balance means! Removing loops entirely from the game would just make it easier for killers to achieve victory and harder for survivors to escape, thus removing the small balance that loops add to the game.
2 -
Yes, this is what I am saying. Obviously the devs can promise us Badham tier reworks, but in the mean time even a band-aid fix like changing the window to a pallet could help mildly alleviate the issues these god loops cause.
0 -
You forgot the super loop at coal tower
0 -
I think the devs are slowly starting to fix these with the map and loop reworks. Hopefully Haddonfield will be the next reworked map and that the devs ignore the crybabies who want every map to be full of safe loops.
0 -
I don't disagree that some of these loops need adjusting. however i also feel that a lot of them are just RNG based and not map problems per say (except haddonfield that just needs some badham treatment.) Personally don't feel that some of these should be outright "removed" but simply adjusted. like as an example, the wretched shop could just have only one of those windows spawn at a time, i've seen two pallets spawn in there, one of which is really unsafe, but the window loops make the other pallet (if it spawns and rng is on your side) really strong. simply making a lock that, if one window is open, the other can't be even if the map has open positions.
0 -
Ormond is also pretty to infinite with Balanced Landing.
I personally think BHVR should do a 180 and change the direction they're taking the game.
Right now, we're moving towards:
* Stealthier killers
* Less stealthy survivors
* Anti Camping perks for Survivors
* Gen Progress-slowing perks for survivors
* Gen Defense Perks and Strategies for Killers
* Looping Strategies still the primary means of survival for Survivors
I'd rather see them nerf loops and then compensate by giving some stealth and juking ability back to survivors, then give more ways for killres to delay the game.
Just my two cents.
3 -
In my opinion, unsafe zones won't be a problem if Survivors has more ways to survive than just looping.
Get rid of the problem loops, leave existing safe zones as is, then give more options for survivors to survive even in unsafe zones. And I don't mean adding more palettes. I mean letting jukes and stealth work again.
1 -
That's why they made bamboozle and also the new demogorg perk , there are counters people just don't want to use them
1 -
Crotus Prenn, middle building is always a nightmare
1 -
A perk shouldn't the solution for the game's core problems
5 -
A perk to counter infinite is the exact same as putting some bandaid on a stab or bullet wound
You are using a perk which already is situational to try to fix a fundamentally flawed map design, so in maps say badham where there are less infinites you get to play with 3 perks, and in maps with infinites you get to play with 4. Also guess what when the survivor sees your bamboozle ? A jungle gym right beside all those main buildings in macmillan etc, the amount of time they can buy is massive.
Look at grim pantry god window, congratulations you brought bamboozle, that's 2 windows loops you've saved, now you just have to deal with 2 pallets each on either side of the 2nd floor and after that keep chasing the survivor downstairs where they have god know how many more pallets in the center swamp area
1 -
Lol what? You gotta be kidding me dude.
Perks should NEVER be the solution to a game’s core problems.
0 -
are they frustrating? yes... but if you're wasting all your time chasing a survivor through one of those then you're not doing your job right...
a survivor can not stay in an infinite loop AND contribute to the game. (some have generators, but not all, and if you let that one pop early you'll have an easier time later on.)
1 -
Me and @Masantonio run M1 killers for 3 to 5 generators on Wretched Shop.
It seriously needs a nerf to be honest. :(
0 -
I honestly don't see how any M1 killer can compete against that map, it's ridiculous.
0 -
You need four survivors to play a match
But you also need One Killer to play a match
Numbers just feel like.. if Killers are more scarce, things will go badly for the game (not to say if All the survivors just disappear, things won't go poorly)
0 -
Loops are one of the only defense mechanisms survivors have. Pallets are unreliable because half the time, other survivors slam them down and waste them all OR they don't respond to an attempt to slam it. Loops can be the only chance survivors have to escape from the killer.
As a killer, you have options: mindgame them (it CAN be done, you've just gotta commit and outgame them...certain killers make it easier, especially with aura reading add ons) or stop wasting your time trying to chase that survivor nonstop. Most of the good loops are on one side of the map, so most survivors can't run all the way across the map to access that loop unless you're weak as a killer. In that case, accept your L and move on to the next survivor.
And they frequently adjust loops and RNG in maps. It doesn't matter because even if they fixed one, killer mains will find another "unfair" reason to complain about. No matter how much they tweak the maps, people will still have something to gripe about or find another aspect to blame.
1 -
There are more God loops like the main building from Disturbed Ward, the main building from Groaning Storehouse with the God window open, the main building from Grim Pantry and the main building from Ormond.
Post edited by Rizzo on0 -
Not intill all of the maps are fixed lol
0 -
Shouldn't have to have a perk to stop a unmanageable loop from being ran :/
0 -
Survivors use perks to avoid camping, tunneling and slugging. I don't see the problem
2 -
Yea, the killer is the killer for a reason. if you get camped and your team does what they are supposed to, you will only die. Thats the reason there is second chance perks. and for the most part survivor perks are like completely balanced. same for killer. its just the maps at this point, Plus all survivor perks are meant to stall, these infinite's shouldn't be a free min and half wasted with no mindgames :/
1 -
Godlooping on tryhard tunneling killers XD exposing the sandbagging survivors 😈
0 -
For all you saying "They should do map reworks" they already said on, one of their streams that they would likely be focusing more on doing map changes to the current ones like they did with sprindwood then always putting out a new map with each dlc -bites tongue in anger because ghostface didn't get sh*t- 😂
1 -
Yeah they dont want to give up Ruin, B&C, NOED and whatever 4th random perk they decied to use lol
0 -
The two pallets should only spawn in there if the basement is in there I think. Window or no window next to it
0 -
all loops even god loops are counterble if you take them away it basically becomes killer chances you for 1min downs you and then on the hook which is like killer bullying survivors which is fun either except for killers. And if they do that then what fun is it a game instead of lasting maybe 15 to 20mins it last 5mins because all loops are ez to counter what fun is that.
1 -
Omg yeah it's literally lined up with safe pallets in a circle on both floors I hate that map
1