What counter-play do you want on her?

I think after 24 hours you cannot really judge the spirit. I get a lot of killer games where red ranks behave like infants, going for insta unhooks, getting downed beneath a hooked person and urbaning around the maps, where I ask myself how they got red ranked. And the answer is probably, because the ranking system is bulls at the moment.

As xRem said, headphones help but won't carry you, as you would get lost against any iron will. You also need to adapt to visual cues, and not only scratch marks. And the mindgames on survivor side need to be trained as well, and it is harder to do this than for killer to train spirit, as you don't always run agains spirit.

The survivor mindgames are not just running left, then walking right. It is also about timing, waiting in front of a vault letting the spirit hear you and jump through half a second before she comes out of phasing. "Being unpredictable" isn't specific like "360" or "moonwalking". It can be everything. Actually the best way to learn it is to observe someone who is capable of tricking a spirit. But that is very rare. And as spirit while learning, you are not able to see what the survivor did to just disappear.

But I really would not think I know everything after 24 hours. I started playing Pig because of a daily and a really good match, thinking "wow, that was easy, let's do another one". Got some more 4k and thought, stealth killer seems super easy, and then all of a sudden I got a match where none of my dashes hit and I barely managed to get one sacrifice. Just as example. Sure, spirit is relatively easy to learn to become a good killer, but she is not OP. The problem is more, that most survivors prefer to complain than to adapt, like they did on Legion. Also Freddy got buffed because many killers complained about "7 seconds before I may hit?!" and stuff. But I know several people that could make good use of the aura reading ability Freddy had before the rework. He was not that weak.

i think shes fine and has been fine when they finally fixed her months ago. To me, it seems like the forums for most of this year were complaints of swf, noed, and mom and its like yeah people had feelings about the spirit then, but the outcry wasnt NEARLY as bad as it is now and shes been the same since like......what Oct 2018?? But once they buffed freddy, and announced the nurse rework, its like people said "oh, if we make enough posts on the forums, we can get an easy nerf! It was as if people were just ADAPTING to the spirits power and playstyle because they had more pressing issues like DS,MOM,SWF etc.

Thats why i feel like this will be an negative domino effect because what will happen, is the survivors will complain about every aspect in the game that challenges them to think any differently than an M1 killer and eventually, all the killers will be like survivors and just be reskins

"i think shes fine"... Are you main spirit and you like to get 4k in all your games?

Edit: Sorry for the emote

People are complaining since there isn't a SIMPLE way that can become muscle memory for survivors. There are a few things, such as collision and audio that COULD be changed though.

Mechanically, Nurse is probably still the best killer in the game, but with enough practice and mind-games, the Spirit can beat her.

I also slightly disagree with @Deadeye on the matter of Freddy. Even as a console player, where he was stronger than PC. He wasn't very good, and while I only played him with Smoking Splinters I still had enough of a feel to say that his power was hot garbage. You could do NOTHING to survivors unless your power hit. Even then, they had too much warning generally. New Freddy is pretty oppressive, yeah, but he feels like he can actually do something.

off topic but uwu

Shes in my rotation of killers i play yes, and i dont 4k most games, maybe 2-3 with last one gettin hatch