Creepy Killers vs Scary Killers

TheDuhJ

Did I sort this right?

Creepy Killers:

• Wraith
• Freddy
• Hag
• Pig
• Clown
• Plague
• Ghost Face
• Twins (Victor)
• Trickster

Scary Killers:

• Trapper
• Billy
• Huntress
• Nurse
• Doctor
• Myers
• Spirit
• Oni
• Legion
• Death Slinger
• Demogorgan
• Pyramid Head
• Blight
• Twins (Charlotte)

SpitefulHateful

Legion is not scary. He is cheap-ass-annyoing edgy teen who hasn't tasted a good chancla to learn some manners

papichulo

plague isnt creepy and trickster isnt creepy either

Phasmamain

Those are mine

Lexilogo

People find Freddy Kreuger creepy? The guy who did this?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6qw5YcXgQZw

Actually, even in that comments section there are apparently people who find the SOULL FOOD creepy, so I don't know, maybe I'm just accustomed to dark humor. And, to be fair, he doesn't do any shenanigans like this in DbD (and it technically isn't the same character) but I really can't seperate all of Freddy's insane hijinks from his DbD appearance.

So, I think Pig, Freddy, and Ghostface are funny Killers, not really scary or creepy. Very subjective, though.

GlamourousLeviathan

Trickster is the only killer I don't find creepy nor scary in any way and this applies to his cosmetics too.