Visit the Kill Switch Master List for more information on these and other current known issues: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/kb/articles/299-kill-switch-master-list
We encourage you to be as honest as possible in letting us know how you feel about the game. The information and answers provided are anonymous, not shared with any third-party, and will not be used for purposes other than survey analysis.
Access the survey HERE!
All Killers Battle Royale — Who Wins?
I haven’t seen one of these threads in a while. I think the last time I saw one was shortly after Spirit’s release.
If you were to put all... (checks the wiki)... twenty-three (23) Killers against each other in a free for all style battle, unbound by DBD’s mechanics and balancing, but under the rules of the Entity’s realm, and with no immortality, who would be the last one, or ones, standing?
For Killers who count as multiple characters assume that every character is in the battle at once, so all four Legion members are combative at once, and the Twins can both act at the same time.
Wiki Link to all Killers: https://deadbydaylight.fandom.com/wiki/Killers
Discuss.
Edit: words
Edit2: No immortality rule.
Comments
-
Well michael pyramid and freddy are immortal....
2 -
I don’t think Myers is immortal. Just... really, really friggin hard to kill.
But I haven’t watched the movies so I could be wrong entirely.
0 -
Assuming no one is immortal, I would say Oni for obvious reasons.
0 -
Well there is so much immortal killers and some of them already died so long time ago. So i dont think anyone can win this fight.
But i know that: first Trickster will die in that battle, after him Trapper.
2 -
The Curse of Thorn is revealed to be a mystical runic symbol based on a namesake constellation "Thorn" that could appear during the ancient feast called "Samhain" (the holiday now known as "All Hallows Eve" or simply Halloween). To prevent mass death among the tribes, one family was chosen to bear the curse. This curse would require the bearer to sacrificially murder his or her entire family, which in turn would spare their entire community from events such as plague and drought. The curse also appears to give the cursed inhuman strength and immunity from death.
0 -
Ah yeah I should have added that yeah. I’ll put that in my post, no immortality.
0 -
Idk i think david could beat up a legion member lol. They are just teenagers with knives.
0 -
LORE
lol thanks for explaining that to me. So Myers is indeed a mystically enhanced superhuman. Cool.
0 -
Michael is immortal because of curse. He cant be kill with any way, that is why he tried kill all Myers family members for generations. He is staying young and strong. And immortal.
0 -
And pyramid heads immortal because hes the personification of guilt itself so unless the killer hes facing suddenly feels sorry for the people theyve murdered he aint going anytime soon.
0 -
I hate the visual I'm getting of Bubba insta downing all the other killers in one fully charged chainsaw sprint lol
2 -
I think that the win would go for Freddy or Plague. Plague because even if she dies, everyone will die as well because of her sickness and Freddy because he is basically a god on his dream realm.
0 -
Um excuse you, but we already KNOW the answer:
4 -
Either Freddy or Pyramid Head.
First of all, both are technically immortal, and even if we ignore their immortality they still are extremely powerful.
Pyramid Head does not exists, he is a manifestation of James guilt and desire for punishment. However, under the Entity's rules, PH is probably a "real" monster, which can be harmed and, perhaps, killed.
Freddy, in the other hand, is literally a god in the Dream World. He is already powerful enough to place Dream traps, and if he breaks free of the Entity's control there is no stopping him.
0 -
David could beat up Trickster too. He is just guy with head-smasher. David can send him to hell million times.
0 -
I think Nurse has the best chance. She can blink away from everyone while they pick each other off and then blink in and kill whoever's left at the end.
0 -
Also Pyramid head only exists in another dimension so if the entity is not involved; unless the killer roams into silent hill fog or whatever....he can never even attack the other killers.
Also, some of the killers are dead or spirits; and NEVER sleep anymore, so they can't be attacked in their sleep, so if he is only in the dream world, that also takes him out of the running against several of the killers.
0 -
Freddy can ignore her power in Dream World. Also Freddy can use her weaknes in Dream World. He can give her good dream when she was still human. And then can finish her.
I think Freddy would win this fight because Freddy is God of Dream World. And he can get everyone to him world.
0 -
You are right.
Okay then, so if a "dead" killer wins, they would never have to fight against Freddy or PH. As you've said, a dead killer does not sleep, and I doubt they would randomly decide to explore Silent Hill.
0 -
I believe that Blight would win. Canonically he is the strongest killer in the game and he has strong ties with the Entity.
0 -
It doesn't matter who wins as long as Legion and Trickster get stomped.
1 -
And a million throwing knives.
In a boxing match, David wins easily.
In basically any other situation (Trickster has his bat and his knives, David has whatever), Trickster will just pelt knives at him and if David tries to rush him, Trickster will get a knock David's skull out of the park.
0 -
So glad that you posted this thread because it was getting close to 2 weeks since the last one was made.
0 -
Okay seriously what is this
0 -
There should be a match with nothing but killer mains fighting each other every other couple of games as a requirement so they can all complain to each other for the tunneling/camping of each other that they "only do as a last resort", even though it seems to be the "go to tactic" in every camping/tunneling match I have played.
0 -
Kazan wins 10/10 times. Kazan is more intelligent, stronger, and the only one trained in any formal fighting techniques. He also has two weapons and towers over most of the other killers. Kazan is intelligent enough to scope the battlefield out and wait until the competition weeds each other out by standing there menacingly and intimidating the smaller killers while being able to easily dispatch the simple minded/animalistic killers if they decide to go for him.
He is also smart enough to put two and two together and to know not to let Aidiris get anywhere near him and to wait until she is dead before engaging, because even if he kills her the plague will get him. None of the other killers are anywhere near a match for Kazan. Here is how each matchup goes.
Trapper: Defeated in a battle of wits, Kazan can likely just step in a trap with that thick ass boot of his and be fine, but pretend to be stuck and attempting to escape. Trapper approaches, sneak attack.
Wraith: Has to come out of hiding eventually, when he does he is scrawny enough for Kazan to take a hit and just grab him by the neck and snap it.
Billy: Baited into charging, Kazan dodges and cuts him down.
Nurse: Same as Wraith, she has to initiate eventually and he can tank the hit and kill her easily.
Michael: Strongest competition IMO just because of how ridiculously hard to kill Michael is. Kazan can likely just reduce him to a meaty pulp on the ground with his kanabo. Michael isn't exactly speedy or prone to dodge.
Hag: Weakest competition overall, snapped like a twig.
Doctor: Madness would likely drive Kazan into a rage, meaning doctor gets his head smashed in by a kanabo.
Huntress: Intelligence of a 7 year old, dodge the hatchets or just tank them and close the distance. Physically similar to Kazan's strength, but easily bested strategically.
Bubba: Just straight up unfair for Bubba, Kazan has reach on him and can cut his arm off in a swing.
Freddy: Third weakest, Kazan is a literal Demon at this point and I don't think he's capable of sleeping. Pedo Fredo gets smashed.
Pig: She can be as sneaky as she wants, she's too small and her weapon too ineffective stand a chance.
Clown: Obese man vs literal Samurai.
Spirit: Likely would refuse to fight her initially and possibly even ally with her after recognizing the crest on her sword. If she was crazy and attacked him though, neck snap.
Legion: Come on man you know how this goes.
Plague: Do not engage, let someone else kill her. If he has to fight her, he will do his best to avoid being infected and cut her head off. If he is infected, he better cleanse or he's dead. Only one that actually has a chance to kill him, still doesn't win.
Ghostface: No
Demopls: Literally an animal, can easily be defeated by a trained demon warrior.
Deathslinger: Congratulations you have brought the massive demon samurai closer to you and he is now angry. Snapped like a sapling.
PH: Kazan feels no remorse or guilt for any of his actions, PH literally vanishes into the ether as he is deprived of his reason for existing.
Blight: Speedy Grandpa gets his speedy spine speedily broken.
Twins: Censored
Trickster: Bruh
2 -
I like your analysis and reasoning. It took me a little bit to realise you were talking about The Oni, because I didn’t know his actual name.
Though I notice that you bypassed Executioner because Oni ‘deprives him of his reason for existing’ by having no regrets. But Pyramid Head does exist by the Entity’s rules and not his own, so he more than likely would still partake in battle.
How do you think Pyramid Head would actually fare against the Oni? Would they be evenly matched or one vastly outmatch the other?
0 -
Myers, PH and Freddy are just gonna be in an endless stalemate.
1 -
I am under the impression that Pyramid Head voluntarily entered the Entity's realm and doesn't care about the entity's rules, much like Michael. If that's true, he still uses his SH rules. If it isn't true, Pyramid Head is probably the most durable outside of Michael. Though his weapon is actually largely useless in a practical sense. Kazan has actual training with proper weapons. An anime buster sword like PH wields is incredibly wonky and leaves him WIDE open for counterattacks.
Kazan wins 8/10 times. If PH's sword does actually connect, it would likely sever limbs clean off.
1 -
https://www.youtube.com/n2-f45kDuNU
Its unfair for Kazan not Bubba
0 -
You know what, the fact that he probably just doesn’t care about the Entity’s rules totally explains why Pyramid Head can A. Put Survivors in cages to die instead of sacrificial hooks and B. Kill them by his own hand without using an offering. Memento Moris themselves are requests from Killers to the Entity asking if they can kill a Survivor instead of sacrificing them for the Entity to feed on. Pyramid Head on the other hand goes “######### you, diagonal dissection time” when the Survivor is supposed to be dead on hook.
I find the notion that Pyramid Head who is merely a construct of guilt, is untouchable to an eldritch spider god with power over death, time, mind control, and casting those who don’t curry favour enough into an endless, timeless void, rather hilarious.
Edit: “Pyramid Hear” lmao
0
