do different killers need different requirements?

IOIOO

First match with pig, 6 hooks with 0 kills, brutal killer

Second match with blight, EIGHT HOOKS 1 KILL and entity displeased

so is this a bug or what?

There should be a result of "entity amused" to be honest

MeltingPenguins

Did you rank up between the matches? from rank 16 on you'll get 'entity displeased', before that you'll always get 'brutal'

IOIOO

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2404983#Comment_2404983

rank1, 1.5k hours

th3

Each killer has different quirks. You get a certain amount of chase interaction points based on the killer. Killers like plague for example or one shot killers will normally get a lower chaser score compared to normal m1 killers.

Lycidas

There isn't much difference in terms of emblems between the first and the second match you described, so whether you pipped or not depends on the other emblems

You said in the first match you had 6 hooks and 0 kills: that means that you got either Bronze or nothing in Devout (you got Bronze if you hooked all 4 survivors at least once), and probably Silver in Malicious (this depends on how many times you hit the survivors, but you probably landed at least 10 hits in order to hook the survivors 6 times)

In the second match instead, you got 8 hooks and 1 kill: you get Bronze in Devout (even assuming you hooked all 4 survivors), because in order to get higher than Bronze you need to either kill at least 2 survivors or have a total hook count equal or higher than 9, and you still probably get Silver in Malicious because usually you need more hooks to get Gold

So yeah, more or less the same points emblem-wise, you need to look at the Gatekeeper and the Chaser emblems, maybe the gens were being completed much faster during the Blight match? Might be a result of the Pig's traps that were slowing down survivors

GannTM

Blight might suffer in the chaser emblem because he can end chases so fast.