Does Brutal Strength need a buff?

Meme
Meme Member Posts: 275

I mean I use it occasionally, but I feel like 20% isn't that much all things considered. The addition of the effect applying to kicking generators is a nice QOL change, but it still feels a little underwhelming. There really isn't a reason to use Brutal Strength when we have enduring, which Is another perk that helps deal with pallets. Maybe increase the percent to 25% will make it a little bit more appealing, but that is just me.

Comments

  • edgarpoop
    edgarpoop Member Posts: 8,748

    Definitely needs a buff. Brutal Strength isn't worth taking because there are too many pallets on the maps. It's next to impossible to clear out enough pallets to make a difference in the match. Gens will be done and not enough hooks will have been accumulated by the time a significant amount of pallets have been broken with Brutal Strength. No amount of time saved on breaking them with Brutal Strength will equal the time saved from a short stun+ instant break that leads to a hit via Enduring/Spirit Fury.

  • Ghoste
    Ghoste Member Posts: 2,135

    Agreed. A simple 5-10% speed buff should be enough to make it feel impactful but not overwhelming.

  • Horus
    Horus Member Posts: 850

    Make it 50%

  • edgarpoop
    edgarpoop Member Posts: 8,748

    I actually did an experiment last night with Brutal Strength and Fire Up. Survivors still have time to reach the next pallet or window on most maps with Brutal Strength+5 stacks of Fire Up. It's really pointless.

  • Marcus
    Marcus Member Posts: 2,047

    Yeah, there is no reason to run Brutal Strength when Enduring + Spirit Fury. And now that they fixed Enduring, the pallet stun duration is really shirt with it.

  • Ghostingmyteammates
    Ghostingmyteammates Member Posts: 216

    if they make it 20/25/30 on Brutal Strenght, it would make the perk an actual choice.


    (besides that, tier 1 and 2 BS are useless and the nerf "compensation" it got when you guys buffed the base on breaking pallets was no compensation at all)

  • Theluckyboi
    Theluckyboi Member Posts: 1,113

    I like it but it was way, way better before

  • brokedownpalace
    brokedownpalace Member Posts: 8,823

    It should make gens regress faster when kicked.

  • ArecBalrin
    ArecBalrin Member Posts: 636

    Brutal Strength should activate the ability to kick survivors on the floor, resetting their recovery progress. The animation will be hilarious.

    I want this. I need this.

  • BlueFang
    BlueFang Member Posts: 1,379
    edited July 2019

    I need this too, I never slug but I would run it just to stomp on some insta-heal survivor lol


    I mean just add a timer so it would be a tactical perk and it would be totally fine and surprisingly original for DBD. Please @Peanits


    Also sorry for the mention

  • Andreyu44
    Andreyu44 Member Posts: 1,527

    Its perfectly fine ,Imo.

  • Saitamfed
    Saitamfed Member Posts: 1,626

    I thought so many times.

    30/40/50 and it can come with a small speed buff after that.

  • Awakey
    Awakey Member Posts: 3,145

    Here's my idea:

    Brutal Strength:

    You break pallets and generators 40/45/50% faster. Generators you kick regress at normal/150%/200% speed.

  • NMCKE
    NMCKE Member Posts: 8,242

    Normal regression is 0.25c/s every second. Therefore, it will take 320 seconds for an 80 second (or 80 charges) generator to regress back to 0 seconds (or 0 charges).


    So, a 200% increase in regression will increase 0.25c/s to 0.75c/s. Therefore, it will take 106.67 seconds for an 80 second (or 80 charges) generator to regress back to 0 seconds (or 0 charges).


    I think that might be a little to good, maybe the values should be 50%/75%/100%?

  • Awakey
    Awakey Member Posts: 3,145

    @NMCKE

    I mean the total regression will be 150/200%, as in after the additional percent. I should've said 0/50/100% quicker regression.

  • Angelicus23
    Angelicus23 Member Posts: 2,551

    Yeah let's buff it and use it with fire up plus the wraith and his light speed addons

  • NMCKE
    NMCKE Member Posts: 8,242

    Oh, sorry, then that's perfect, that will by a direct number cut like the developers did with Enduring 2 sec => 1 sec. 320 seconds => 160 seconds, which isn't bad at all! :)

  • thedevalex
    thedevalex Member Posts: 283

    Brutal strength definitely needs a buff.

  • Meme
    Meme Member Posts: 275
  • Mister_Holdout
    Mister_Holdout Member Posts: 3,144

    I think a better solution would be to rework the maps that need it.

  • Laakeri
    Laakeri Member Posts: 835

    Power of BS comes when you break the pallet from side that zones survivor. If you chase mindlessly then the effect feels pretty mininal.

  • thisrandomguy
    thisrandomguy Member Posts: 142

    Actually old brutal strength was faster than it is now. Back then pallets took more time to kick but brutal strength 3 would reduce the time to 1.8 seconds from 3 seconds. Now that pallet kicks are faster (2.6 seconds from 3 seconds)

    Brutal strength made a 1.2 second difference


    brutal strength's numbers were reduced from 20/30/40 to 10/15/20 because of faster base pallet breaking (now 2.6 seconds)

    Using the numbers, brutal strength 3 now makes pallets 2.08 seconds to kick. Basically it was nerfed.

    Brutal strength now makes a .52 second difference. Which is .5 seconds slower than old brutal. to fix this you would basically have to buff brutal strength's numbers by 11% making brutal strength 3 31% which is close enough to match 1.8 seconds

  • Just_Playing
    Just_Playing Member Posts: 156

    My brutal strengh idea would be:


    -you destroy pallets and generators 20/25/30% faster.

    -if you kick a generator it regression is increased by 50/75/100%

  • Horus
    Horus Member Posts: 850

    Yes it does

  • Nick
    Nick Member Posts: 1,286

    Just bump it up to 35%