Is this fair?

Now it's opposite for me. I'm at rank 11. I'd say I'm rank 9 skill. (Been there before)

I have been with rank 19,20,17 people almost every match. Either my teammates are not doing anything and the killer is destroying them, or me and my teammates are great and we have a sucky killer. Oh oh but now when I'm killer? I'm rank 12. I am with rank 4,7,19 and 20 almost every match. It's crazy.

No, but also means nothing. But why you use noed, you're playing doc, there's a lot of good perks with him

Let me play devils advocate real quick. Ranks 9-10 are on the edge of purple ranks. I'm not saying the system is perfect, I completely agree it's messed up sometimes. But think about this. How would you get better if you don't play people better than you? If you're constantly playing people you can stomp, you'll never advance your skill set. Maybe look at any mistakes you made that match that survivors capitalized on, and work on fixing those so they don't happen again?

Now I don't think you should be playing against all red ranks, but I do think that if you're closing in on the next ranks, then you should have to play with one rank higher survivors. I.e. if you're rank 9 you should have to play against purple ranks. Cause if you want to rank up you should have to earn it.

I think it should be more like a spectrum. If you are rank 10, you play against mostly green ranks and occasionally purple ranks. But if you're rank 9 trying to get to purple ranks you have to play against purple rank survivors. Then once you're rank 8 you play against green and purple. Rank 7 only purple. Rank 6 purple with some red. Rank 5 only against red. This should transition you well into higher ranks as long as you actively try to learn and get better.

I have played with rank 15-20 survivors as a red rank, and no I don't think that's fair. And I also don't think that you should always be paired with people 2-3 ranks above you. But then again, I never said they should. I said if you're playing to get better and if you're ranking up that you should have to play against people a rank above you, Because that advances your skill and makes it to where you earn your spot. Overall you'll still be playing against people on your level because you increased your skill set. This wouldn't apply to people who don't want to increase their skills or get better because they'll never make it past yellow ranks. I've also mentioned in other posts, not this one mind you, that a normal unranked mode should be introduced for more casual players. You could also offer multiple ranked modes, 1 for solo and one for SFW groups. And killers can choose which one to partake in. Introduce then cosmetic rewards for different rankings and BOOM! Everyone's happy.