Billy vs Spirit. Who's better?

Tomorrow I might make a thread where I ask everyone who they find easier to verse between these 2, if I will remember about it. But right now, survivors mains who I know call Spirit harder to verse.

Billy's only real asset his his map pressure and Instadown. Any mediocre survivor can make a Billy miss his chainsaw. Your curving aspect sadly works as well as Huntress in a straight line. Again any mediocre Survivor can dodge it. Baiting a Billy is not hard or even challenging. You dont need statistics to see the fact more people DC against a Spirit then a Billy. If you really play both sides then you knew this already and either are hoping your argument will change people's minds.

Problem is without Perks and Addons Spirit is superior. She has a higher skill cealing then Billy will ever have. Leaning on the fact that Billy has 115 ms and a instadown wont give you much room.

With Perks and Addons she can be superior to Billy as well. She can have a build that can easily take a survivor down within seconds. Not Billy's instadown speed well at least without perks.

Problem for Billy is he is simple and straight forward in his design which leaves a lot of room for counterplay. Yes a good Billy will shine and do amazing, but a good Spirit will outdo a Billy. You keep mentioning her power cool down, but funny thing is. I have been playing her since release and I dont run power duration or recovery and have never had a problem with her power and downing someone.

The simple thing is Spirit has a higher skill cealing then Billy. Yes Billy is well rounded and can do the job, but a good Spirit will keep learning new tricks and new strategies to improve due to her vastly higher skill cealing. You act like looping a Spirit is a common and easy thing yet almost everyone in this thread disagrees. Billy is easier to loop and deal with then a Spirit anyday. You could honestly flesh out all the Tips and Tricks for each of these two killers. Billy's if he is lucky will be a full page and a half. Spirit will have a full blown essay and still be missing stuff.

TLDR: Billy's Skill Cealing is Quicker to reach then Spirits Skill Cealing. Billy can Carry you where's Spirit is only good as the person playing her.

A mediocre hillbilly is as good as any other m1 killer, but with high mobility. A great hillbilly on the other hand is a different story. He is the one baiting mistakes, not the other way around.

A lot of people DC against spirit because she has little to no counter play while hillbilly is fair. People DCed against old legion more than spirit and nurse combined but still that does not mean he is stronger. 

Spirit is better than hillbilly in chase potential while hillbilly excels in every other aspect. He is also not helpless in a chase, even against the best survivors. The only way to stay safe is by dropping pallets like a potato. He has the potential to creat dead zones very quickly meaning that he is more dangerous as the time passes. 

Whether spirit or hillbilly is better, the difference between them is not significant if you look at the whole picture and not only chase potential.

Billy, spirit have more counterplays, she is slower, easier to counterplay.

Lol what crack pipe are u smoking lol no way in hell is clown a better anti loop killer lol just drop the pallet early and there u beat the clown

lol billy is anything but map-dependent lol I fact I’d say billy good in Haddonfield field becuase if the survivors are running through the little white wall that’s a guaranteed instadown huntress is map dependent

Lol hag sucks against survivors friends they would just snap her traps and gen rush her into her oblivion billy is hands down better than hag even after his nerf

most likely Spirit she got more thread on her then any killer.

lol huntress is map dependent billy is not