We have temporarily disabled Baermar Uraz's Ugly Sweater Cosmetic (all queues) due to issues affecting gameplay.

Visit the Kill Switch Master List for more information on this and other current known issues: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/kb/articles/299-kill-switch-master-list

Taste the Rainbow! Just Admit You Turned MMR Back On

Moundshroud
Moundshroud Member Posts: 4,458
edited January 2021 in General Discussions

Ok, you guys know I love your game right? I love the Moderators; they are champs. I hate that I have to say this, but please just come clean and admit the MMR is back on. I think it has been on for almost two weeks, a week at least. Why do I say this? Most of my matches, if they are not a SWF that all joined together, are all the colors of the rainbow. It is Rank diversity run wild. At least tell them what I already know, so they can mentally prepare for the wild west of Dead by Daylight.

Case in point, I just played a Spooky Myers on the Pale Rose (Swamp Map). When I go into a large map with Spooky, I have to go full tilt, 110% because anything less means I'll be looped round the moon and back by any Survivor who has cut his/her teeth. The match was over in like three minutes. I was moving so fast, I had three dying in the basement and was hunting down the fourth before I realized that I wasn't going to earn any Pips. I was like, "Oh my God... these are REAL Potatoes. Why in the hell are they in a match with me?"

It suffices to say that I felt bad. If any of you (you were all Console) just got out of that match with me, please accept my heartfelt sympathies. This isn't working. This is JUST LIKE LAST time you turned the damn thing on. I'm all for better matchmaking. If MMR worked, I'd be thrilled. I want to be fighting opponents in my weight class. Now I have no way of knowing other than trying to judge it on the fly. If I hold back to "see" what kind of opponents I have, I handicap myself badly against good Survivors. If I go full tilt and they aren't, I massacre them. This is not a sustainable situation.

I'm going to submit the same suggestion I do whenever this comes up. You will never be able to get perfect matchmaking. There are too many variables. The best you can do is try to match people with ballpark hours in the game. Not everyone gets good at the same rate, but at least they can't say they didn't have the same opportunity to get good. Do you see my point? I feel dirty, and I need a shower. I'm not looking to to make mashed potatoes. Let those spuds grow into proper Survivors. Or at least give us some way to know. Can you give me something in the HUD that gives me an idea, so I know who to cut loose on and who to give a little leeway?

Comments

  • If they did they better turn that **** back off somehow they made it worse.

  • JimPickens666
    JimPickens666 Member Posts: 326

    Survivor has a much lower skill cap than killer and all survivors are the same while all killers are different and harder to play. I don't know how to balance it but its def not hours especially because there's a good handful of people who have like 5000 hours and counting and obviously mostly survivors mains. They would have virtually no killers in their pool, i mean really the same can be said about any skill level which is why im still occasionally matched with rank 20 killers who probably quit after the game we play because my random teammates 100% of the time will bully them because they have small brains and dont associate their behavior with the 10 minutes they will wait for the next match.

    At this point just make killers NPCs tbh

  • SocialDistomancy
    SocialDistomancy Member Posts: 1,319

    I was doing that tonight so I might have been one of those guys.

  • Dwight_Fairfield
    Dwight_Fairfield Member Posts: 7,122

    Yep been getting rainbow ranks all evening. Both with team mates and killers.

  • Toblerone007
    Toblerone007 Member Posts: 598

    That is not true at all. Killer you might have to manage 4 enemies, however, the micromanagement of survivor is a much harder art than killer considering skill cap in mind. Pulling off a fast-vault instead of a medium. Running efficiently to good structures. Luring killers to a false sense of security in unsafe structures to then line up a fast vault on a window. Playing reactively on unsafe pallets (especially with dedicated hits). Running tiles as tightly as possible and learning the spots where there is invisible collision. Learning to fake drop pallets correctly and fake windows correctly (the timing has to be impeccable). Not saying killer is easy by any means but saying survivor is a lower skill cap is definitely wrong. Your inputs have to be as clean and accurate as speedrunners on dark souls. As soon as you make a mistake you're likely dead.

  • halfmanhalfape
    halfmanhalfape Member Posts: 153

    I have been getting teammates of varying skill levels. I haven’t seen such big potatoes for awhile. I thought it was the reset.

  • jester20k
    jester20k Member Posts: 827

    Yeah I've been getting two yellows with me and my mate (red ranks). Killers ranks from 1-13. Problem is, the noob survivors get destroyed fast and we lose because its a 2 vs 1, or we whip.the killers ass even with two potatoes. This game is so wierd

  • Antrapace
    Antrapace Member Posts: 253

    Past 2 weeks my matches on both survivor and killer have been a shambles, even the streamers I watch suffer with the rainbow ranks / paid actors when they are killer. I doubt they will own up to secretly putting it on, I just wish their new system would be a little more effective.

    If it doesn’t work this time round, I think it’s fair to say that the majority of the community would like it if you didn’t try and reinvent the wheel and just go with the tried and tested ELO system or something of that nature.

  • KayTwoAyy
    KayTwoAyy Member Posts: 1,701

    I posted this back in December:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/214829/matchmaking-woes#latest

    Since 4.4.0 release, my matchmaking experiences have taken a dramatic turn for the worst. Not much has changed for me in the past few weeks, except the killers are now closer to my rank. ...the survivors, however, all have their heads so far up their ass that it would be an insult to suggest Skill-Based Matchmaking was live.


    I wait for real skill-based matchmaking with bated breath.

    My friend and I just looped a legion for 12+ minutes while our two teamates (12 ranks behind us) crouched side by side in the corner of the map. My patience for wildly incompetent teammates is running extremely thin.

    Nvidia Highlight of the moment I found out what they've been doing all game: https://streamable.com/61rb1e

  • Woot1234
    Woot1234 Member Posts: 139
    edited January 2021

    I had half the heart to make a similar post to this one. My suspicion is Bhvr is running experiments to collect data, although that may be giving a small company like Bhvr too much credit.

    A well designed matchmaking process could be handled via a statistical model*, with potentially hundreds of inputs - player tenure and performance, historical perk or killer selection, SWF vs non SWF... there's a lot of variables. Even if Bhvr isn't modeling this as a true statistical model, you still need data to get to a formula.

    Which means Bhvr needs data, LOTS of data. It isn't enough to just use the data Bhvr naturally gets via the current matchmaking process, as the dataset will be biased and not robust. To get the data you need, you have to experiment. And Bhvr owns the matchmaking process so it is (theoretically) easy to run any experiments they need.

    Of course, all of the above may be complete bogus, but believing the matches are this way for a reason make them more tolerable when the matchmaking is way off.

    *If bhvr's goal is 2 kills per game, then any number of generalized linear models could work, where the model is trying to predict the probability of a killer getting two kills based on the inputs. GLMs would be a great first step, ML model would be more powerufl.

  • I had longer queues for certain killers. Only way that happens is with MMR.

  • Equus
    Equus Member Posts: 324

    I'm also wondering what's up. I've had multiple games with 2 brown ranks and the third being green or yellow while I'm red rank. I'm getting really annoyed by this since I either carry the entire team and get left behind on first hook or escape alone. They either do gens and hide or only hide while I'm taking aggro like 3/4 of the match. The killers also tend to be green ranked with the odd purple.

  • Aneurysm
    Aneurysm Member Posts: 5,270

    It's definitely on from the games I've been having but they might just be testing it. Maybe that's why there's extra bp, so they get more players rn + more data?

    Or they're just not going to say whenever they activate it now so they don't have to be embarrassed again when they have to turn it back off, with classic bhvr transparency.

  • Aven_Fallen
    Aven_Fallen Member Posts: 16,471

    It was Rainbow-Matchmaking for a while now. I doubt that MMR is turned on, it does not feel like it.

  • Pulsar
    Pulsar Member Posts: 21,037
    edited January 2021

    It has been for a bit, but I feel like it's gotten worse just in the last few days.

    I went from having two or three Green Ranks in my Red Rank Killer lobbies to having all White Ranks and I have no explanation as to why.

    Before, I could explain it away as a SWF, even if they denied it, but now I cannot do that.

    Either the matchmaker is really broken this time or something is up.

    And honestly, it isn't fair to those players at all. They should NOT be getting matched with me.

  • Mooks
    Mooks Member Posts: 14,855

    Matchmaking never really worked as rank based but yeah, since PTB activation I also noticed bigger differences.

    it also showed me that there in fact are enough survs in my killer rank out there. Still get red tank survivors as a r13 killer but brown rank survivors as a r2 survivor...

    disregarding the few matches with obvious complete new survivors, the matches were great though, so if it is MMR it does its job at least most of the time for me. And we all know there can’t ever be a perfect matchmaking system in a game like this.

  • Xyvielia
    Xyvielia Member Posts: 2,418

    Wether or not MMR is currently on (and I do believe it’s been tested under the radar a few times now), these mismatched games weren’t ever this consistently bad.

    I have dozens of these every day; here’s the most recent via a cancelled match 5min ago:

    This Solo match was going nowhere.

    I know these players, and those are their usual ranks, so I know they’re back where they were after reset.

    I also know this killer well, (too well) as I’ve been matched with him 19 times in the past 30 matches (how does that even happen??) many of which were consecutive (4 in a row!?) He’s a all-time tunneler who loves switching to Forever Freddy after he faces a team who gets the better of him.

    I’m thankful he backed out of this one

  • Mooks
    Mooks Member Posts: 14,855

    That sounds like there are not enough players in your area though.

    do you have crossplay turned off perhaps?

  • Aven_Fallen
    Aven_Fallen Member Posts: 16,471
    edited January 2021

    I mean, here are a few games where I took Screenshots, the last one is after Rank Reset:

    (Chat censored in the first screenshot because the Killer was not really happy with the game...)

    The thing what happened before the Rank Reset was that whenever a Console-player was on either side, the Matchmaking seems weird. Currently this is the same, but sometimes I also get matches like the last one. I knew from the start that something was odd because the Neas went down while the Nurse wasnt even blinking.

    Something is not working correctly, this is right. But I doubt that it is MMR, when it would have been MMR, the Nurse would have been more experienced, but she is clearly starting to play Nurse. And with the Plague-game, the Survivors were not really good enough, they went down quickly, however, I am not a good Plague-player, but if I get matched with people on my Skill Level, it should have been a more close game than it was.

    Currently, as Killer, I get Red Ranks. Even when playing the Twins (in my first games with them, currently prestiging them), I get the usual Matchmaking. As Survivor, it is kinda odd, like yesterday I had a Claudette in my Team who had 20 hours of playtime.

    EDIT: IF MMR is really on (like I said, I doubt it), then they should disable it, because it is not working, lol.

  • Xyvielia
    Xyvielia Member Posts: 2,418

    Yeah, Crossplay is off.

    I waited 5min after that canceled match (screenshot) to search for another match, so I wouldn’t be in his lobby, and I got him again! The same guy! It’s seriously starting to drive me crazy, tbh

    There’s got to be more killers in the area playing on a weekend morning.

    I’m going to have to turn on crossplay just so I can play against a different killer for a change, smh

  • KayTwoAyy
    KayTwoAyy Member Posts: 1,701

    Its likely worse now because of rank reset. Even when matchmaking was more consistent, I knew to expect more yellow and green ranks in my game when rank reset me to purple.

  • Moundshroud
    Moundshroud Member Posts: 4,458
    edited January 2021

    You have never fibbed to me so I'll accept that answer, but then something is is broken and going severely wrong. When I make the joke, "taste the rainbow," I'm not kidding. For the longest time I only pulled Red/Purple Rank Survivors. I've been fighting at that level consistently since the end of September. Two weeks ago, that changed. Now I fight a rainbow selection every single match. That means something is broken, something important.

  • edgarpoop
    edgarpoop Member Posts: 8,528

    Something is up. Like OP said, rainbow ranks almost every match. Me at 2500+ hrs getting survivors with less than 100 who have genuinely never encountered the killer I'm using. It looks like MMR and smells like MMR, plus it would be the uttermost peak BHVR to have pulled the first iteration only to change absolutely nothing and roll it back out 6 months later.

  • EpicBigBrain
    EpicBigBrain Member Posts: 177

    either mmr is bad or the ranking system is just itself because I felt like playing blight (who I only play in kyf) and each time I got put in sweaty lobbies (rank 3 killer btw.) If mmr is doing its job, its doing a horrible one

  • Slashstreetboy
    Slashstreetboy Member Posts: 1,811

    Are there any matchmaking requirements in place at all? These screenshots and my personal experience suggest that the only matchmaking requirement right now is being in qeue at the same time, completely disregarding rank, time played etc.

  • lucid4444
    lucid4444 Member Posts: 682

    Is that better or worse? I don't know lol


    @Moundshroud

    I'm going to submit the same suggestion I do whenever this comes up. You will never be able to get perfect matchmaking. There are too many variables. The best you can do is try to match people with ballpark hours in the game. Not everyone gets good at the same rate, but at least they can't say they didn't have the same opportunity to get good.

    Sums it up perfectly. It's baffling that they don't see this

  • tenoresax
    tenoresax Member Posts: 797
    edited January 2021

    I started learning Nurse just yesterday and have played her almost exclusively since then and can say (almost) without a doubt that MMR definitely is not on.

    Courtesy of the fact that I have seen only reds, purples and a sprinkle of greens since I started Nurse.

  • Bwsted
    Bwsted Member Posts: 3,452

    You keep getting the same players because you have crossplay switched off, which means that you'll only be matched against other players on your platform who've switched it off as well.

  • Moxie
    Moxie Member Posts: 806

    If you think it is bad now...

    Boy o boy. @Remindme in 3 weeks.

  • Xyvielia
    Xyvielia Member Posts: 2,418

    yeah, I’m seriously jus gonna have to turn it on so I can avoid getting the lobby of that one guy I keep getting

    ...I’m telling you though, if I turn on crossplay and get matched with that same dude again, sth crazy is going on! lol

  • i remember when badham kept showing up and one of the devs on stream said it's in our heads....then they confirmed there was a badham map selection bug

    The game is so borked its entirely possible mmr switched on by itself

  • Vetrathene
    Vetrathene Member Posts: 1,425

    They probably turned it on by accident, or changed some value somewhere in the code that was somehow tied to matchmaking values. Or you know, they are just cramming whoever they can into matches because there are not enough killers.

  • xenotimebong
    xenotimebong Member Posts: 2,803

    I believe them that it’s not MMR. Matchmaking times are just horrible currently so the matchmaking is more lenient, meaning you get weird rainbow lobbies. People complain about queue times but this is the logical result - people get thrown into mismatched games to keep their queue times from getting too long.

  • WretchedElk
    WretchedElk Member Posts: 311

    I’m a rank 18 survivor and I found myself in a game with a rank 8 killer, so fun game.