Visit the Kill Switch Master List for more information on these and other current known issues: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/kb/articles/299-kill-switch-master-list
We encourage you to be as honest as possible in letting us know how you feel about the game. The information and answers provided are anonymous, not shared with any third-party, and will not be used for purposes other than survey analysis.
Access the survey HERE!
who would win a 1v1 fight? nurse or spirit?
welcome to #2 of my new series called who would win in a 1v1 fight for the dbd killers. next we have nurse vs spirit. their powers included. make sure to put in who you think would win in the comments!
Comments
-
Idk how anyone can not say Spirit. What she did to those three guys in her lore cutscene should be enough to make a decision.
2 -
Spirit, hands down.
1 -
Power wise I have no idea, but Rin is already cut everywhere and literally dead so one would think she cannot lose a fight.
What can a knife or a saw do against flying already cut limbs really.
So I'm gonna say Spirit wins!
7 -
Nurse absolutely.
I can see her now, straight up strangling some chopped up blue lady twink in the style of the Simpsons.
2 -
Depends on if one of them out mind games the other. Otherwise, they spend the whole match phase walking/blinking through each other.
2 -
Pre-death - Spirit. She knows karate or smth.
0 -
Spirit easily wins just by standing still.
The nurse will never know whether she's phasing or not >:)
6 -
Nurse.
Just blink inside her and mortal kombat brutality explosion her.
5 -
Epic 2000 IQ mind game
5 -
Hell yeah 🖐
1 -
Definitely Spirit. She's brutal with the katana. The problem with Nurse is that she can't blink without going into her fatigue stun and I feel like that window of opportunity is all Spirit would need to ambush Nurse. Additionally I feel like phasing > blinking in a 1v1 since blinking results in a massive vulnerable state whereas phasing does not.
I feel like Nurse just isn't suited to 1v1 against any kind of monster on equal fighting terms as her because going into a self stun after blinking ONCE is like a death sentence
1 -
Def Spirit. The Nurse telegraphs her Blinks, and that's all the info Rin would need to know to start phasing out of the way before mounting a counter. Plus, even if the Nurse landed a hit, all she's doing is attacking the husk of a dead girl already slashed to bits.
0 -
Nurse spirit is bound to the physical world so as soon as she finds out what her power is she just has to go through a wall wait for her to exit it blink grab slash and kill her not to mention nurse floats so she wont move grass
0 -
I don't k kw, I guess it depends on the extent of Nurses powers. She can somehow break pallets and walls with Spencer's Last Breath, so what's preventing her from doing that to Rin? We know what Spirit can and can't do, she's just a phase walker. So maybe Nurse, if Sally could actually catch Rin.
0 -
Rin is an adept swordswoman and uses a katana.
Sally is just a crazy nurse that choked someone to death and awkwardly swings a saw.
Rin takes this one easily.
2 -
Can the nurse use telekinesis and that's how she floats?
I think it leans nurse since nurse can fly and im assuming she's not going to be as slow as in the game and she wouldn't just hover. So flight + unbound teleportation would lead to some really tricky attacks. Spirit can phase in and out of reality but she has no easy way of hitting the nurse. It reallys depends on how much plot armour you want to give spirit with crazy Samurai skills but I think nurse has the upperhand. Add in telekinesis and nurse would definitely win.
1 -
If the Nurse had telekinesis why would she have to hunt a Survivor down the hard way to hit them with a rusty saw?
2 -
Dbd nerfs the killers for gameplay. Shouldn't nurse be one of the fastest killers since she literally just floats around? And she should be able to fly up to the second floor, above pallet drops and through windows
1 -
Spirit would probably know how to get out of the Nurse's grasp, and a katana is WAY more effective than a bonesaw, damn thing will go through you like nothing. Nurse would rely on choking while the Spirit is stronger body-wise.
0 -
I think it would be a tie.
They are both bassicly ghost right? Can they even be beaten?
I would say they would start fighting realise it's not going anywhere after 5 minutes and then go out and eat pancakes together
0 -
Did you even watch Spirit's lore?, she destroyed those three guys with a sword. Some skinny legged screecher isn't going to beat a master of the blade on a 1v1.
0 -
Yeah, can';t really do a pros and con ordeal on this because no matter what spirit is gonna small poor Sally.
0 -
Every o e forgetting that nurse has the force. She can just chuck spirit around or stab her with her own katana
1 -
Depends, if it's my teammates doing that 1v1 Spirit wins, if it's an actual good player, Nurse 100%
0
![[Deleted User]](https://forums.bhvr.com/applications/dashboard/design/images/defaulticon.png)
