who would win in a 1v1 fight? #4 Ghost face or the pig
welcome to #4 of the killer 1v1 series i made! here are the results from the last posts: huntress vs deathslinger-winner:huntress, spirit vs nurse-winner:spirit and oni vs Pyramid head- winner: Pyramid head. make sure to put who you think would win this match up in the comments! EDIT: people are wondering which ghostface it would be and I should have been clearer. i mean the dbd ghost face (danny johnson)
Comments
-
GF since he can tbag faster.
6 -
Ghostface.
but pig is cuter.
0 -
My money is on Amanda.
1 -
Before the end of the 1st round, the doors would lock themselves & all the spectators would be butchered by them both. They'd call it a draw between themselves
1 -
That is true,however pig has the better stun sound.
Would be a close one.
0 -
This is really hard since they're both stealth based killers..
I feel like Ghostface probably has the upper hand in terms of physical strength whereas Pig has the upper hand in dexterity and cunning.
I know Ghostface is a seasoned stalker but Amanda has shown in the movies that she is extremely adept at manipulation, hiding and surprise ambush. Honestly I think both their powers are kind of useless on each other what with Ghostface having to expose by looking for a long time and Reverse Bear Traps only being applicable to someone knocked down and incapacitated it would mostly be a fight between them and their knives I guess lol
It doesn't help that I love both of them either.. I'm going to say Pig though.
Amanda thinks like Jigsaw and she'd never let herself get caught out. Ghostface in most if not all of the movies (If I'm not mistaken) always gets caught in the end and killed so he seems more liable to slip in human error. Idk, when I think of Jigsaw and Amanda I just can't think of either one making fatal mistakes they have everything planned out methodically so I think she'd lead him into a trap if she didn't think she could take him on in a 1v1
So yeah, Pig ftw lol
5 -
Ghost face wins.
0 -
Pig for sure. Have y’all seen how weak Ghost Face is in the movies? Pig is terrifying in her movies though.
1 -
It's funny because both The Pig and Ghostface are really more costumes throughout the series than they are the specific faces behind the mask. Jigsaw passes the Pig identity down to Amanda, and even then the costume itself is donned by others in the series. This is just like Ghostface throughout the Scream series.
So really both are rather "unkillable" as long as the intent behind wearing the costume itself remains.
0 -
Well, Amanda (The Pig) could place a bear trap on GF head and he could do nothing about it. So either only GF dies, or both, due to GF stabbing Amanda
0 -
Honestly, it comes down to prep. Give Amanda some time to devise a plan, she'd come out on top. Throw them both in together, though, GF.
0 -
Ghostface. He has just to boop the snoot,
0 -
Except that the dbd ghost face has no connection to the scream movies.
1 -
Hum they share the silent crouching ability. But in the end i thing it might be Amanda, the way she broke the rules in the movie by making unescapable traps make me think she definitly would cheat aswell in such fight and put a fast timer and no key.
1 -
In a 1v1 honor duel ghostface seems like he would have a edge. His jacket seems to be made a heavier stuff then her clothing so when she goes in with the slashes It might not go thou and hit the skin..But, his knife is a staby tool not a slashy one so, he would be able to go in for the kill on her.
In a 2 DBD style map battle...Ironically, depends on the map...In cornfields and crap like that Ghostface will be able to use his skill to see her outline and go in for the kill...Othermaps If The Pig gets the drop on him "Due to her dash skill" She will finish him off quickly or be able to blitzkrieg him and quickly get out before he can do anything making his way of tracking become useless as she dives in and out..Denying him his stalk while also not caring. He will get a few hits in, but in the end..She is Jigsaw trainee, so that means she is not a total moron and could bait him where he would unable to counter him.
So, It comes down to one thing...Who can teabag the best?
0 -
Ghostface would just make the pig exposed and then tbag walk over to her and then stab her
0 -
I mean, the Ghostie we have in DbD isn't from the Scream movies. He's an original character, a traveling serial killer. Pig was a druggie until John "I despise murderers" Kramer showed her the true way, or whatever. I think the match-up would be pretty even. Ghostie stalked his victims for weeks, so clearly he's at least somewhat clever.
0 -
These two are really similar, but I think Ghostface would come out on top just because he could expose her. Pigs traps won't really do anything in a fight, because they take so long to activate. Pig's ambush is the only thing that could give her the edge in a fight, but compared to Ghostface 1-hit downing someone, it just isn't as strong.
0 -
Maybe you could post the links to the previous threads so we could see the other winners :D
0 -
ok. also note that i didnt know the exact number of responses on these to ddcide the winner. i decide the winner by the popular opinion or who I think would win in 1v1 fight if its really close. or maybe ill count all the responses and see which ones outweigh which. heres the links to the last ones BTW: https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/228366/who-would-win-in-a-1v1-fight-huntress-or-deathslinger#latest and https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/228435/who-would-win-a-1v1-fight-nurse-or-spirit#latest and https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/228544/who-would-win-in-a-1v1-fight-the-oni-or-pyramid-head#latest
0 -
Ghostface. Neither one really seems like they'd trump the other in physical prowess, so it'd come down to the tools they have on-hand. RBTs are useless in a 1v1, and Ghostface can at least throw his knife as a projectile weapon in an emergency whereas Pig cannot do the same because her weapon is something she wears.
1 -
they are different ghostfaces BHVR only bought the mask and made their own story and the ghostface we got ran circles around the cops and maintained a fake identity making him much smarter than movie ghostface
2 -
I think pig would when solely based on the experiences outside of dbd
0 -
Ghostface for sure.
Pig is the least combative killer in the game honestly. Ghostface (im using all versions as a reference) has had actual fights with people whereas pig hasn't at all and strictly sneaks up on people to attack. Pig isn't known to fight in the movies whereas Ghostface in all iterations has had at least some
0 -
Amanda died cuz she was too dumb to realise she was being tested, ghost face literally carriers around evidence due to his confidence and ego not to mention he was never caught/failed
2 -
If it's the lame Ghostfaces from Scream 4 or Billy's mom, then Pig. Otherwise, GHOSTFACE. Hey man, cool topic. Please make more of these.
0 -
yeah ive made 3 other ones, heres the links if ya want to check them out. huntress vs deathslinger:https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/228366/who-would-win-in-a-1v1-fight-huntress-or-deathslinger#latest
nurse vs spirit: https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/228435/who-would-win-a-1v1-fight-nurse-or-spirit#latest
oni vs pyramid head:https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/228544/who-would-win-in-a-1v1-fight-the-oni-or-pyramid-head#latest
1 -
Pig because I ######### hate Ghostface with a burning passion and I want to see his smug ######### face have his teeth knocked in and shoved into one of Amanda's unbeatable traps. I'd take so much satisfaction seeing him strung up in the Angel Trap. I want Pig to win (and to be fair with her elaborate traps she probably could too).
[I am in no way inciting violence against Ghostface players or mains. All of my anger and comments are directed purely to the fictional character).
0 -
how dare you hate ghost face
2 -
Slightly off topic but I just discovered that Amanda is the only licensed female killer...
0 -
i never relised that
0 -
Ghostface easily
0 -
Trust me I have plenty of sufficient reasons to do so.
0 -
I would say Ghostface. Because as far as I know, The Pig seems to have good survival skills due to the Saw games. But I don't know anything about Ghostface except he kills people. Maybe he also has good survival skills. Altho, Ghostface can one hit you. Soooo yea, Ghostface.
0 -
Obviously Pig would win. Ghostface is just a teenager that likes to kill for fun and does not put much tought on what he is going to do. Pig plans what she's going to do 2 steps ahead of her victims. Ofc ghostface would probably win in a 1v1 in a ring but assuming they are fighting with both of them using max of their potential pig would anhiliate him.
0 -
That depends. Would ghostface boop?
0 -
Depends on the situation completely. If it's a straight up face to face fight then Ghostface, but if they have to premeditate everythin Amanda could easily trap Ghostface.
0 -
......
0 -
I have sufficient reasons.
0 -
Lol, fair enough. Funny comment though.
0 -
thank you, i try my best
1
![[Deleted User]](https://forums.bhvr.com/applications/dashboard/design/images/defaulticon.png)
