Tyde's New tier list

Here’s a slug vid =D

https://youtu.be/mQr6JPh3D10

@Mc_Harty said:

@Cardgrey said:
Here’s a slug vid =D

What does that have to do with his list?

About as much as your post there o.o

I think people get worked up over a list made in his point of view. Forgetting we all have bias and make mistakes.
Cut the guy a break. He’s only human like me and you.

@michaelmyers87 said:

lol you just regurgitated what I said with different words

Ah but that begs the question then, who said it better? Taking bets, now place your bets here folks. 😁

@michaelmyers87 said:
powerbats said:

@michaelmyers87 said:

lol you just regurgitated what I said with different words

Ah but that begs the question then, who said it better? Taking bets, now place your bets here folpowerbats said:

@michaelmyers87 said:

lol you just regurgitated what I said with different words

Ah but that begs the question then, who said it better? Taking bets, now place your bets here folks. 😁

I think I just learned the definition of a strawman argument from watching a YouTube video. And that Led me back here. Pretty much what I was saying is that dude was making a strawman argument

Oh I understood that, I was just being sarcastic and facetious with my response. Hence the cheesy grin.

Such a long thread and yet nobody's bothered to ask the question that is of most importance:

Who put that enormous stick up this Youtubers bum?

@Sn0wJob said:
Literally nobody agrees with Tyde outside of his fanbase.

Hag mains came in to his twitch channel to defend the position that hag was not low tier and Tyde just would not debate them.
He chose instead to get frustrated, shutting them down with logical fallacies and/or bans(possible timeouts). The also joined his server and tried to make the same appeal, to no avail.
Prominent hag playing community members and TydeTime have a long standing grudge, the reasons of which are numerous but I think it's of value to point that out when showing off that his list has a clear bias in some areas.

I'm not going to pick apart his list because I don't really feel like it, and I think people should play killers before passing judgement on them personally.
Tier lists shouldn't be held as some sort of gospel, people need to think for themselves.

He strikes me as the type of player who can't recognize when something is good even if it doesn't fit his playstyle.

I have played this game for almost 3.000 hours, and I have dedicated on every killer a good amount of time because I like to play with all of them and have different variety so I don't get bored when I play killer. Usually I do killer rotation and try to use different addons. So, if I had to make an objective killer tier list it would be like this:

S-tier
1.) Nurse (hands down, I think anyone can argue about this).

A-tier
2.) Spirit (with basic knowledge of how survivors move you can finish chases really quick. She's underrated by many people but when the community in general put more gameplay time on her you will see the real beast she is at full potential. Unlike the Nurse, she can't go through walls or pallets and her power has a cooldown, but she's a really strong and solid A tier killer).
3.) Hillbilly (I feel Hillbilly is on the same level at Spirit but the reason why I place him under the Spirit it's mainly because when I play against good SWF groups Hillbilly can have a really hard time being looped, on the other hand, if you master the Spirit she can do better than him against them, believe it or not. Nonetheless, he still has a great map control and a one-shot power that can cut chases really quick).
4.) Hag (different play style than other killers, just go placing random traps in the middle of nowhere without any pallet or window near, you will get constant free hits. However, unlike Spirit and Hillbilly, she needs time to "build" her power and I know by my own experience she can have a really hard time against good SWF groups. Also, if survivors are smart they will look where you have placed traps and when you down a survivor and start carrying him/her to a hook, they will just blow you traps since you can't avoid it).

B-tier
5.) Huntress (her ranged power is really nice and can help you with loops and windows. She can also do well against SWF groups. The main problem she has and the reason why I place her under Spirit, Hillbilly and Hag is because of her lack of map control and because she's very map dependent).
6.) The Shape/Myers (his low terror radius combined with monitor and abuse can make him a really good killer. Sure, he can be looped, but if you learn to approach to survivors with your evil within at 99% you can pop it and avoid the chase. If you're getting looped you can just get more evil within and drop the chase when you're at 99%. He can even punish groups of SWF).

C-tier
7.) Clown (he's a killer whose power can be used for survivors to use pallets faster and make loops last shorter, so you can clean up the map of pallets quicker than other killers. However, you don't have any way to snowball with him, and that's what make Clown and the killers under him in this list worse than the first six killers of the list. He can also have a bad time against SWF groups, like any other killer down him on this list).
8.) Doctor (I place him on this position because if you master him and learn how to use his power at the exact moment you can perfectly deny window vaults and pallets drops leading you to free hits. However, he would be way down on the list if he couldn't do this. Also it's important to mention the fact that he can start chases really fast thanks to finding survivors due to madness 1).

D-tier
9.) Pig (she's pretty bad but her power can at least help her extend the game "if you're lucky with RNG". That can help you deal softly with gen rush and clean the map of pallets quicker so survivors have less stuff to work with late game).
10.) Wraith (he definately goes up on the list with his recent buff, and he has a decent map control with his speed while cloaked. As a stealthy killer you can approach survivors and bobyblock windows or pallets near survivors avoiding them to use them and getting free hits. However, he's still vulnerable to pallet loops, he can still be gen rushed due to the lack of pressure he can apply and can be soft countered by good SWF groups).
11.) Trapper (if survivors have a brain they will check obvious spots where you can place traps, and even if you place random traps in non-obvious spots you need to be lucky that survivors walk by those spots. Again, if you go against a good SWF group his power is completely nullified. To be fair, he can be a strong killer with his best addons).
12.) Leatherface (yeah, he has a one-shot power, but if survivors have a brain and are good at the game they will always tend to look where are pallets to loop, what windows they can use, so they can nullify his power and complete loop him. And if you good against a good SWF group they can make the match a complete troll fiesta to poor Bubba. He's hands down the best killer to guard the basement or to secure a kill, but honestly, I don't feel that's the way the game should be played and it's a really boring play style).

F-tier
13.) Freddy (I think many of us agree with this. You have to put people to sleep before you can hit them, time for survivors to reach pallets or windows. Complete loopable killer to which his power can't do nothing to assist him in chases. You can't secure a hook, they can unhook in your face, they can heal in your face and wake up with a skill check... yeah, he needs a rework, probably I will try to make a proposal to give him what I consider a good and balanced buff).

Obviously each one of us has a different view of the tier list and it can be really subjective depending on the person and also the tier list can vary depending on the addons used and the map they are playing in.

Beside this, my total respect to the list and work TydeTyme has put on elaborating his list.