Why is haddonfeild still a thing

"a rng window spawns on top floor and the window does not have a balcony to the side so basically the strategy is to camp the window until the killer goes about 4/5th of staircase up than you just vault the window."

Except that its not really a loop. It's a safe escape at best. But I am guessing you mean the one where the window is opposite to the staircase? That's actually a free hit unless survivors have Balanced Landing.

"garage loop which you tend to predrop the safe pallet on corner, make 2 turns for killer to attain bloodlust 1-2 than you just drop the garage pallet and hard camp pallet."

Ah yes, but this one, you need to actually go for the opposite side of the car, where the wall is small, then all you have to do is show your red light to cause the survivor to vault and quickly turn to get a hit before they can vault back. If you get stuck on one way, you can quickly go back on their second vault to get a hit inside. There is plenty you can do there. A smart survivor would drop the pallet and leave the area, not camp it, because they know killers can get a hit there.

"Its infinity, even at bloodlust 3, you need to break it."

Even ignoring the previous statement and assuming it does need breaking. That doesnt mean that it's an infinite though, like you said, you can break it. If YOU as a killer can do something to reduce looptime, its not an infinite. Some pallets need to be broken, those are what we call safe pallets, but the loop itself isnt that safe untill after the pallet is dropped, survivors still can be hit as long as that pallet isnt dropped. Some pallets wont need to be broken, those are unsafe pallets. Then there are some pallets that are already part of a really strong loop and you want them to be dropped as early on as possible, like Shack pallet. Those pallet, we refer to as god pallets. Are they infinites? No.

"survivors historically always had busted loops on most maps so you just need to get used to it."

I mean, you do realize that it needs to be possible for all 4 survivors to escape, right? If all loops were weak, survivors have no chance on a 4 man escape. Survivors deserve the chance on a 4 man escape as much as killers deserve the chance on an early 4k.

I don't think you can shoot over fences, but I might be wrong. If I'm NOT wrong, however, the map is definitely not even remotely decent for him.

"The loop i am describing is 3:00. I don't know what to really say. its just one those 5 gen chase maps for survivor if you understand how each of the loops connects to one another. he used the pallets in the inverse order."

Yes, and that only sucks if all the survivors are at equal skill. Being able to connect loops near perfectly is tough, especially if the survivor is not already in a chase. What Bubba should have done was leave the chase. As Tru3 himself loves to say "its a 1v4, not a 1v1". That goes both ways. Ignoring 3 survivors, means those survivors will do gens. The killer should have realized Tru3 was injured and not close to a generator, while other survivors were working on gens. He could leave Tru3 and bully someone else instead, yet he didnt.

Being a killer isnt about mindlessly chasing 1 survivor untill they are down, its about micromanaging. Survivors dont have to really deal with micromanaging, instead survivors have to bruteforce their objective.

Again, I agree with Haddonfield needing a change, especially the house of pain, but in 99% of the claims that it needs a full rework, I get footage of killers just having a tunnelvision on a 1v1 and forgetting its a 1v4.

Bubba got a relatively strong pallet, but that pallet is no different from the double car pallets on Autohaven, no different from a T wall with a breakable window. That area is now unsafe, its time to bully other survivors and trick them into going to an unsafe area. Haddonfield isnt as terrible as killermains tend to cry about. It's very powerful and it has its issues, it really punishes killers mistakes while barely punishing survivor mistakes. But I have to repeat again, there are maps that barely punish killer mistakes and heavily punish survivor mistakes aswell. All it means is that a killer has less room for mistakes. Which sucks, sure, but its only 1 out of 2 maps that forces killers to think more about their actions.

Which kinda is an argument of "git gud" I guess, but the same can be said towards survivors who complain about Hawkins.

Because, unless its 1 survivor vs 1 killer, there are still other survivors available. You never, ever, want to chase the strongest survivor first. Nor do you want to ever keep chasing a survivor when gens start flying. These games happen as rarely as 5 gen 4k's happen, and have just as much reason to exist in the game. If 4 survivors die with 5 gens left, survivors screwed up massively. If 0 survivors are hooked with 5 gens done, the killer screwed up massively. Regardless of maps, perks, items or addons being used.

"Speak for yourself, in my opinion, it is basic survivor skill to be able to connect one loop to another. especially safe loops."

Note how I said PERFECTLY. Connecting loops together normally isnt really that strong. Connecting them perfectly is extremely strong.

"but Haddonfield has many floors, many back alley ways and is quite deceptively large from one side to another"

It's only 2 floors, they are essentially reversed basements. But instead of only 1 way out and many ways in, it has 1 way in and many ways out. So instead of going for the 1 way out at a basement to get easy hits, you go in the 1 way in and leave that way to ensure no one gets back up(and anyone who does gets a hit). Let alone that Haddonfield has 2-3 one man gens, the best any other map has is 2 if you're lucky(coldwind farm, actually). The alleyways arent that rough. You know what does need changing massively in Haddonfield? Pallets next to a generator on the backside, because that's big enough to be an infinite on a 115% killer. Fences that are longer than 16 meters AND fences that are longer than 14 meters that have a corner(you know which ones, they are absolutely disgusting), which is either where it needs to be broken apart, or add a breakable wall(assuming all other things are adressed too). The generators on the middle road absolutely must be reduced to 2 man gens as prove thyself on haddonfield makes them pop in 25 seconds, while the swing sets need to be broken up(seriously, what playground has swingsets so close to each other?). Those are by far the biggest obstacles that require almost no effort for survivors yet consume a ton of time. Which, honestly, is what truly makes Haddonfield a horror. 2 gens that can pop too fast, and 6 locations that only have 1 pallet but can be solo looped for 40 seconds for a single hit. Once you remove 2 fast gens, and 6 insane loops(house of pain included as 1 location obviously), Haddonfield would be so, SO much easier to manage.

Haddonfield giving survivors more control isnt bad, just as certain maps giving killers a bit much control isnt bad either. The problem is certain specific points being powerful enough to last 1 entire normal loop, for the price of 1 pallet and 1 hit.