Survivor Perks vs Killer Perks Conversation / Questions

So... I'm sort of sure I'm not the only person to consider this... but I wondered both what other people thought of the current dynamic as well as making several suggestions on several perks that I generally find aren't working for me or as intended.

I play both killer and survivor, so I see sort of both sides of this conversation (or at least I'd like to), so let me explain.

I think Survivor Perks are significantly weaker than Killer perks, and I think this is a bad design decision. I think that the issue of them being weaker is a band-aid to resolving the problem of skill expression in the game - how to make a perk that impacts the game with more skilled players deriving more value from it - for a majority of the perks.

I can think of some very specific examples.

Boil Over

The wiggle component seems to not be very effective at really any skill level without a lot of input from other players. The not seeing hooks in 10 ft doesn't apply often, because the killer can still just hook you. I think a simple fix / improvement would to make the nearest hook unuseable instead, and maybe increase the efficacy for the first attempt using the token system. You could do two tokens, the first attempt is improved a lot, second attempt less, then third it's useless. The perk becomes more impactful immediately - as the game goes on it becomes less effective.

The complaint I could see with this is that it makes it closer to decisive strike... it doesn't. It still isn't guaranteed, which is how decisive strike works. But it also makes the perk go away... which I think is a better model for survivor perks overall.

My reasoning is simple - all perks serve the purpose of giving survivors more time from being killed, i.e. more time to work generators. Perks that are impactful early mean they give survivors a strong early lead, but then trail off when the killer gets further / closer to the generators being completed. So it creates a natural power curve downward as the game goes on. Additionally, skilled players that don't get hooked as often will STILL get the benefit at the end of the game, just less often because they don't need it.

I think there's a fair amount of similar perks that could use some similar touch ups with similar intent... just in a different direction.

Self-Care

Maybe this has tokens and can only be used X times. It is a strong perk, very highly taken, and takes away skill reflection since you see it so often in games. Taking away from this perk gives more flexibility to improve other perks equally. Which I think should be the design goal.

Anyway, soapbox over, just some ideas my friends and I were talking about and I was curious what the community / developers thought. Hopefully people give some neat input!