Which killer is the most underrated in your opinion

There are lots of killers that are underrated.

1: Oni. He has a fantastic kit, a fantastic story, and a well integrated aesthetic.

2: Billy. Most people let his rework blind them to how good he still is, and with the addition of his tome entries, he's become very sympathetic. Poor guy.

3: Pig. A lot of players avoid using this killer because her power is almost worthless without purple addons (you know the ones) and her Iridescents are garbo, but she's still decently strong.

In terms of add ons you can tell say it's the worst

Nemesis. His late game is monstrous and early on, he really isn't THAT bad. He is very fast to tier up and denies a lot of pallets and loops relatively easy, or at least without the drawbacks of other killers who can do the same. And the information he provides keeps the game on the rails most of the time even for someone like me who is horrible at tracking survivors. He is literally just a ranged killer without the movement penalty. That alone makes him quite strong in my opinion.

It doesn't matter what hands you put Billy in. You're not going to be able to land a chainsaw hit on a good survivor unless they're literally out in the open, or they make a series of massive mistakes. Not only can you not curve most of the reworked map tiles due to wonky collision and much more corners and turns than there were before, but the rev time of moving slowly and charging is more than enough to turn two corners or get to a pallet or window, in which case you've just overheated a good portion and gotten nothing for it.

Billy is much like Myers. He was good in DBD's early state, but as the game has progressed, he's gotten weaker and weaker. Any above average survivor can loop a Billy for minutes on end regardless of the Billy's skill due to the limitations of his chainsaw, which is not something that constitutes a good killer. When was the last time you saw a Billy win, genuinely?

Billy may be fun to go against, but he is no longer good against somewhat decent survivors. At that point he is just an M1 killer with limited mobility and the occasional instadown if they're caught out in the open. His chainsaw does not work at most loops against any good survivor UNLESS it's a rare curveable loop, you have Engravings, and the survivor doesn't have the presence of mind to go around a corner.

Legion.

I find it absolutely shocking how many of my teammates go down because they don't mend, or how many throw pallets when he's in frenzy, or how many spend the entire game self-caring and never even looking in the direction of a gen. I kill myself as fast as I can against Legions now.

I feel a bit sad i can't say Wraith anymore.

I second this tbh, Even with turn rate addons you'll rarely connect with a chainsaw unless they make a mistake or you're literally on top of them in open space. I play both Blight and Billy and it amazes me that Billy can't get some of the Blight treatment when it comes to turn rate and flicks. Can easily hit a lethal rush, Struggle immensely getting 1 or 2 chainsaw downs. Still trying Billy's challenge's to hit 8 chainsaws and hit 2 survivor's within 30 seconds, not possible in my opinion. Better off using the chainsaw purely for mobility and pallet removal and focus on M1's.

I'm gonna base my list purely on how often I see them versus how good I think they are, but...

1. Oni. Great Killer, not quite sure why I never see him any more.
2. Plague. I know a lot of people dislike playing her and she has a weird issue with the emblem system, but she is a fantastic Killer and I think she has some of the best add-ons in the game.
3. Twins. I'm happy I don't see them very often. Very clunky to play, but powerful and they really do have a lot going for them in their kit.

Idk, I think it's hard to find a truly underrated Killer these days. The Killers that are considered 'Bad' are generally considered so for one very good reason or another. (Or multiple.)

I know people are gonna disagree, but hear me out.

Trickster

Great killer that I’ve played a lot and is my second main (Nemi forever). All of his ad-ons are good (except for the Rusty Blades). You can down people quickly with your blades and don’t have to aim all that well because of how many he has. People say Trickster is a ######### version of huntress. What they always forget is that Main Event exists, it WILL down somebody because of how quick and op it is due to the new buff.

Bubba is a killer i really hate going against if he's good and not just memeing. The only real counterplay is genrushing, because as soon as all the pallets are gone he will snowball like crazy, more like most other killers.

Lately played against some good Tricksters, i think he is fairly strong now. Nemesis is also not that bad in the right hands. People slowly start to learn and master killers, that's why i'm usually against fast buffs. I think some killers got overbuffed lately. Some people play 3 games and then expect to know every aspect of the power and when to use it, and if they don't dominate every team after 3 games the killer is weak.

I'd say Clown, Twins and Plague.

Clown - People underestimate him, especially at certain loops like Cow tree. He's good on pretty much all maps except for huge open one's like Red Forest, RPCD is perfect for both bottle's effects.

Plague - Her add-ons are great, especially the Iridescent Puke aura add-on.

Twins - Being in potentially two places at once is too good, good iridescent add-ons.

Very well said but i would say that unlike Myers who was always a pretty basic killer, Billy became outdated the moment he got over nerfed while Bubba got a big buff and Blight released shortly after.

Blight is arguably even better than old Billy, but if his add-ons didn't got completely destroyed, he would still be kinda viable in good hands unlike now where it's just sad watching the 5 people that still main him play. You can really tell they're being held back by his garbage nerfs.

Considering they're one of my mains and I do fairly well with them even in high ranks (without much effort, mind you), Legion. I know full well they're far from top tier, but to call them the worst shows a lack of even trying. They are a solidly mid-tier Killer if played right. They just need some add-on adjustments and they'd be golden.

Other than Legion, Myers comes to mind. He's outdated and it shows, but he still has one of the best snowball potentials in the game.

People on these forums always place Twins way too low on tier lists. They're the 4th best killer and nobody else is close

Plague.