Which 3 killers need reworks the most?

@Yui_TheBeauty @VioletCrimes @RenRen

TRICKSTER

Rework Showstopper:

• Make the Laceration Meter fill with 7 blades.
• Increase blade capacity to 45 blades.
• Increase Laceration Decay delay to 30s. This allows for better juggling of survivors, which helps with map pressure.
• Change the blade capacity at which throwing movement speed reaches 3.68m/s to 20 blades.
• Make Main Event an Active Ability that can be held onto.
• Allow Trickster to exit the throwing state during Main Event, without cancelling Main Event.
• Increase Main Event duration to 20s.
• Increase Main Event activation charges to 35 blades.

Buff his map pressure:

• Increase base movement speed to 4.6m/s.
• Give a 5% Haste effect when below 10 blades.
• Like with Huntress, better locker spacing would help.

Rework add-ons:

• Change Diamond Cufflinks to reveal Survivors for a stackable 2s for each knife they are hit with.
• Change Iridescent Photo Card to only expose survivors whose Laceration Meters are 1 Blade Hit away from the maximum.
• Buff Death Throes Compilation to also reduce Laceration Meter capacity to 6 blades.

@psionic @xenotimebong

PLAGUE

Buff her power a bit:

• Increase Purge charging movement speed to 3.8m/s. Debuff related add-ons accordingly.
• Show the infection meters to the Plague.
• Allow survivors on the hook or in the Dying State to be fully infected by the Plague.
• Make the starting corrupted Pool of Devotion spawn in the center of the map.

Rework some add-ons:

• Change Olibanum Incense to increase Vile Purge charging rate by 33%.
• Buff the Corrupt Purge duration add-ons to 10, 20, and 30%.
• Buff Worship Tablet to increase Vile Purge charging rate by 33%, and increase the movement speed bonus when holding Corrupt Purge to 0.4m/s as well.
• Change Severed Toe to add 1 Pool of Devotion and increase Vile Purge effectiveness by 25%.
• Remove the movement speed debuff from Iridescent Seal and only reduce Corrupt Purge duration by 10s.

@xenotimebong

SPIRIT

• Make her appear intermittently (thus able to see survivors and vice versa) while phasing, with a short phasing sound. This should occur for 0.3s every 1.5s. The Husk should stay at the original location. This allows for more strategizing and counterplay on both sides
• Make her phasing noise heard by survivors within the Husk's Terror Radius. There's no reason she should be able to mind-game a survivor just by standing still.
• Remove passive phasing. It requires absolutely no skill to use and it messes with survivors when her Red Stain disappears.
• Change the passive phasing add-ons to reduce successful attack cooldown by 10 and 20% for attacks during the post-Phase walk period.
• Debuff Mother-Daughter Ring to a 30% increase in movement speed.
• Fix duration add-ons so recharge rate isn't buffed as well

Both. Whoever needs changes most.

Some people struggle with her physics, and she sucks on console. Very underrated tho

@TheGannMan @Shroompy @OldHunterLight @Sonzaishinai

MYERS

Buff Tier 1:

• Reduce stalking required to reach Tier 2 to 4 Stalk Points.

Buff Tier 2:

• Increase Breaking and Damaging speeds by 10%.
• Decrease Pallet stun duration by 10%.

Buff Tier 3:

• Increase Breaking and Damaging speeds by 20%.
• Increase lunge duration by 10%.
• Decrease Pallet stun duration by 20%.
• Decrease attack cooldown by 10%.
• Make Tier 3 an Active Ability so it cannot be accidentally activated.

Simplify the range-based Stalk rate and make the meter updates more accurate:

• 2-8m: 0.8 Stalk Points per second.
• 8-16m: 0.65 Stalk Points per second.
• 16-24m: 0.5 Stalk Points per second.
• 24-32m: 0.35 Stalk Points per second.
• 32-40m: 0.2 Stalk Points per second.
• With these new rates, make sure the meter is updating accurately while Stalking instead of correcting it afterwards.

Cap the Tombstone Piece at 1 kill, and make it increase stalking required to reach Tier III by another 15% the first time.

Good list. All reworks are already posted here

Spirit and Trickster are posted, Freddy coming up

@psionic @Sonzaishinai @OldHunterLight

PIG

Buff the Ambush attack:

• Increase Ambush duration to 2.5s. This makes it more useful at larger loops.
• Allow movement in any direction at full speed while Ambushing. This allows for more moonwalking, which creates more mind-gaming potential.

Buff her stealth ability:

• Make the movement speed 3.8m/s while crouching.
• Make stealth transition time 0.75s. The Terror Radius should still fade out over 5s. This will help with Ambushing as well. Debuff Combat Straps to 0.15s to go with this.
• Delay the unsheathing sound until she has finished exiting stealth, as it destroys her ability to sneak up on survivors.

Rework the Traps:

• Make Traps activate as soon as they are placed, unless the Exit Gates are powered, in which case they should remain inactive. This prevents survivors from repairing generators with Traps on and makes them more useful in the late-game.
• Allow the last survivor to escape through the Exit Gates with an active trap if all generators are not completed. Do not pause their timer. This gives them a fair chance to escape should Hatch get closed.
• Make trap RNG similar to Trapper's: 10%, 20%, 50%, then 100% removal odds. This reduces the likelihood of getting Traps off early but increases the likelihood of it happening before the fourth Box, which will make them more consistent.
• Make the Trap-Kill strategy fairer and require more skill:
  • Increase Trap timers by 15s, and buff Tampered Timer by 10s. This will debuff the Trap kill builds, and also give more time when Tampered Timer is not in play.
  • Allow Pig to see Trap timers. This allows for more strategic play around Traps.
  • Pause Trap timers if Pig is within 6m of a Jigsaw Box for more than 4s while not in chase or carrying a survivor. This will prevent Pig from camping or blocking a survivor’s last Box.

Rework some add-ons:

• Buff the Bag of Gears to a 20% increase in searching time.
• Change the Gears add-ons to a 50% and 100% increase in Trap setting speed.
• Change Utility Blades to reduce successful Ambush cooldown by 20%.
• Status effect add-ons should be applied to an Ambush hit instead of to Traps. This will reward players who use the Ambush well, and no longer encourages tunneling. The Blindness add-on should last 60s, the Exhaustion add-on 15s, and the Mangled add-on until healed.
• Replace Skill Check add-ons with a set of add-ons to increase crouched movement speed by 0.15m/s, 0.30m/s, and 0.45m/s.
• Replace add-ons granting an extra Box with a set of add-ons to increase Ambush speed and duration by 0.15s and 0.3m/s, and 0.3s and 0.6m/s. Make the former an Uncommon add-on.
• Make Last Will a Rare add-on.
• Change the reduced Ambush charging time on Video Tape to a stealth transition time decrease of 0.15s, and the cooldown decrease for missed Ambushes to a 10% decrease in cooldown for successful Ambushes.
• Change Shattered Syringe to 10% and apply it to successful Ambushes instead of misses.
• Change Amanda’s Letter to show survivors’ Auras within 16m when crouching. Remove all debuffs from this add-on.
• Change Amanda's Secret to show survivors' Auras within 12m when crouching and increase missed Ambush cooldown by 15%. Wraith has an add-on to do this while moving significantly faster, so there’s no reason for Pig’s version to be so much weaker or rarer, and this also gets rid of an add-on that encourages tunnelling.
• Change Rules Set No. 2 to start the trial with an active Trap on the Obsession which does not subtract from the original 4 Traps, and reduce Trap removal odds to 8, 16, 40, and 100%.

It would be pretty cool and far more realistic if the lion roar was changed to Amanda herself snarling, like the various versions you can hear in this video.

@Altarf @Sonzaishinai

FREDDY

Make him more fun:

• Make Dream Pallets base-kit alongside Snares, and add a 15% Hindered effect in their Area of Effect for the same duration after leaving it as Snares.
  • Allow players to switch between them with a button (perhaps tapping the Power button?).
  • Make Snares replace Snares and Pallets replace Pallets.
• Increase Dream Projection recovery time to 60s after teleporting. This will ensure players have to use this ability more strategically.
• Change the cooldown reduction given to Dream Projection by sleeping survivors to 10%.
• Gain a stack-able 5% action speed bonus to Breaking, Damaging, Dropping, Opening, Picking Up, and Vaulting for each sleeping survivor.

Give a couple more buffs:

• Make being woken up by another survivor up take 10s × the number of times the sleeping survivor has woken up.
• Increase the base number of Dream Tokens to 10. Setting movement speed is already debuffed, and this allows for more set-up.

Rework his add-ons:

• Change Garden Rake and Prototype Claws to reduce successful attack cooldown by 7 and 15% when hitting a survivor who is Hindered by a Dream Snare or Pallet.
• Change Paint Thinner to reveal survivors' Auras for 6s after interacting with Dream Snares or Pallets.
• Buff Nancy's Sketch to 2.5%.
• Buff Nancy's Masterpiece to 5%, and swap rarities with Pill Bottle.
• Change the Rope and Swing Chains add-ons to add 2, 3, and 4 Dream Tokens. Change Classroom Photo to reveal survivors’ Auras within 12m of any generator being targeted by Dream Projection.
• Change the Block add-ons to the following:
  • Inflict Blindness for 60s when interacting with Dream Snares and Pallets.
  • Inflict Mangled until healed (even if healthy, in which case it should affect them when they become injured) when interacting with Dream Snares and Pallets.
  • Add 4% Hindered to the Dream Snares and Pallets.
  • Add 8% Hindered to the Dream Snares and Pallets.
• Change Red Paint Brush to make Dream Pallets appear to awake survivors from farther than 12m away, and start the trial with 4 Dream Pallets automatically placed throughout the map which do not count against the Dream Tokens.
• Change Black Box to start the trial with all survivors asleep, and reduce sleep immunity and sleep timers by 25%.

Check out the Freddy rework I posted here and let me know what you think

All 3 are posted here, lmk what you think!

I'll post my answer there to make things easier. In the meantime, lmk what you think of mine :)