Suggestion - Boil over working on missed basic attacks

Agreed actually 20% is a bit extreme maybe even 10% might be punishing enough without being too punishing. I mean Boil over is such a wierd perk to balance for. Would you also agree that boil in both current and my version is over stated atm and maybe the obscure hook auras is a bit unnecessary? I would also like to know more about the "Maybe even on top of the dropping effect they’re retaining at a lower value" if you have the time as well.

Thank you for the feedback.

Firstly, Boil over wouldn't add the extra wiggle time unless the killer misses.

Secondly, you'll still get shown the Boil over icon giving you plenty of warning that missing an attack will punish you greater meaning you should be more considerate when you want to go for a hit.

Thirdly,"And now you want free wriggle if they miss, on top of attack cooldown that already exists?" Yes if you bring a perk that gives the killer a warning that this perk exists I want the killer to be punished for having the poor judgment to swing without thinking (or lack knowledge of when to hit a survivor when carrying another)

Forthly, I don't know about broken. As much as current boil over is a pain I would only describe that as contextually broken only being effective on maps that have areas that give the killer no choice but to drop down and give the extra wiggle progress. On any other map Current boil over is an annoyance. What's the point? If the current version of the perk really gives you more of an ultimatum more than a choice really can't be considered broken how can my version which gives more choice rather than ulitimatum be broken.

Fifthly, "Your idea would mean the Killer either has to be body blocked, risk missing, or be slowed on on the hit." That sounds like what body blocking hook is My boil over just enhances it. A swf that body blocks with or without boil over (be it mine or the current version) will still be annoying and effective if done right and your scenario is in the game now if you miss too much you'll drop the survivor and if you let the survivors body block you boil over or no you'll still drop the survivor this concept would not be anything new in dbd if my concept ever came to light (it won't but still i can dream)

Finally, "The Survivor already gets extra time to wriggle because the Killer has attack cooldown on misses" already accounted for in my post but i will agree that 20% is pretty nutty and might discourage killer from swing when they really should maybe 10% would be better. on another note I actually think that boil over is over stated in it's current form and even for my form so perhaps taking away the "Obscures the Auras of all Hook from the Killer's Aura-reading abilities within 16 metres." should actually be taken away too.

With all that said I do appreciate the honest feedback and would like to see an equally honest response if you have the time.

Thank you for the feedback.