Pyramid Head is so good, I tried to look up which Silent Hill his theme music is from, and it turns out that it is an original work from BHVR that just sounds and feels like Silent Hill. Marvelous. And his chase music is awesome, too and is just the right mixture of subdued panic and encroaching danger.

Demogorgons menu music is also a favorite. Its otherworldly and scary and you don't feel immediate danger, but also never entirely save.

Lastly, The Twins music is probably a bit underappreciated. Its not earily beautiful or scary or exotic or anything, but its quite fitting. I think it reminds me a bit of Diablo 2 and could have been a town music there without feeling out of place.

I think that if the Demogorgon from the hit show Stranger Things were to ever be added, it would have the best theme.

Of the killer's, I most like Pyramid Head and Trickster's lobby music. Though I have a soft spot for Clown's too, since he released shortly after I originally started playing.

From the events, I really liked the winter event which had the deep chimes (Winter 2018 or 2019 I think?)

Billy is really getting excluded here? I'd say his is definitely the most thematic, I mean the lead instrument literally sounds like a chainsaw.

Pyramid Head, Demo, Oni, and Nemesis. I enjoy listening to these even when im not playing.

Trickster by far.

In fact is the only menu theme I listened in youtube sometimes just for fun, not only ingame.

Definitely Legion and it always will be until they make a second metal theme.

My top 3:

1. Blight
2. Demogorgon
3. Nemesis