We have temporarily disabled The Houndmaster (Bone Chill Event queue) and Baermar Uraz's Ugly Sweater Cosmetic (all queues) due to issues affecting gameplay.

Visit the Kill Switch Master List for more information on these and other current known issues: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/kb/articles/299-kill-switch-master-list
The Dead by Daylight team would like your feedback in a Player Satisfaction survey.

We encourage you to be as honest as possible in letting us know how you feel about the game. The information and answers provided are anonymous, not shared with any third-party, and will not be used for purposes other than survey analysis.

Access the survey HERE!

Is it the nurse or the speed of which gens can be done that's OP?

gamerscrybecauseofme
gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
in General Discussions
Rank 1. This is now 3 for 3 with nurses, where everyone survived. There isn't any other killer at this rank I can say that about. Again, I am not the greatest survivor either. I will take note that another game was done in under 5 minutes, this needs to change!!

https://youtu.be/FDXJMqZ9rEc

Comments

  • Delfador
    Delfador Member Posts: 2,552

    Dude, the nurse couldn't get her first hit before 2.25, what do you expect? Some nurses literally end the game before that mark with slugging.

    I might be wrong but she couldn't get 1 hook in 4 min match, and the total number of hits she got was 2 if I am not mistaken.

    Even though I believe that the gens are done pretty quickly, this video is not proof for anything. At this rate, even if we give her 40 min match, she still won't be able to get a kill.

  • PhantomMask20763
    PhantomMask20763 Member Posts: 5,176
    The Nurse player just wasnt very good. You're team did their job well and you guys escaped because the Nurse just wasnt very good. She just needs more practice that's all (and maybe an optimization patch too). You're team just did well. I bet if it was any other killer (especially since its console and Nurse is really hard on console) they would have gotten 1 or 2 kills. 
  • gamerscrybecauseofme
    gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
    At this rate, even if we give her 40 min match, she still won't be able to get a kill.

    Lol that tickled me! But this is typical of nurses that I come across. The reasons I post these, are becauseI constantly hear how nurse is OP, but I have seen no evidence of it beyond a skilled player using her. OP is not equal to great play, OP is something that has clear advantage without disadvantage (B&C for example) 

    I am also doing what I can to help discourage other players from hearing the nurses scream, then DC. This has happened a few times before I joined the forum (not that it was an issue when they did) 

    When I am here and survivors complain about nurse being OP, I try to remember a time when the nurse had ever given me trouble (after learning how to play of course) The only thing I can agree about the nurse, is survivors have to play differently against her, then other killers. For me, survivors that can't survive v nurse, are survivors that rely too much on line of sight blockers, looping and pallets.

    I think it proves that gens can be done astoundingly quickly. Any good survivor can loop a killer around the whole map in the time it takes to finish generators, something about gens needs to change. 
  • gamerscrybecauseofme
    gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
    PhantomMask20763 said:
    The Nurse player just wasnt very good. You're team did their job well and you guys escaped because the Nurse just wasnt very good. She just needs more practice that's all (and maybe an optimization patch too). You're team just did well. I bet if it was any other killer (especially since its console and Nurse is really hard on console) they would have gotten 1 or 2 kills. 
    I still wait for the day that I can post the video of a nurse that bothers me or gets the 4k that happens in most other matches against killers.
  • powerbats
    powerbats Member Posts: 7,068

    @gamerscrybecauseofme said:
    PhantomMask20763 said:

    The Nurse player just wasnt very good. You're team did their job well and you guys escaped because the Nurse just wasnt very good. She just needs more practice that's all (and maybe an optimization patch too). You're team just did well. I bet if it was any other killer (especially since its console and Nurse is really hard on console) they would have gotten 1 or 2 kills. 

    I still wait for the day that I can post the video of a nurse that bothers me or gets the 4k that happens in most other matches against killers.

    The solution is come to the dark side and play pc, you'll get scared and go back to console pretty quickly although there's some potato Nurses on pc as well. But generally Nurses at red ranks will get a hook within the 1st 30 seconds or so.

    Now if you really want to get scared back to console play against an Omega blink nurse and or one that knows how to play her and you'll be lucky to have the match last more than 2 minutes.

  • gamerscrybecauseofme
    gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
    powerbats said:

    @gamerscrybecauseofme said:
    PhantomMask20763 said:

    The Nurse player just wasnt very good. You're team did their job well and you guys escaped because the Nurse just wasnt very good. She just needs more practice that's all (and maybe an optimization patch too). You're team just did well. I bet if it was any other killer (especially since its console and Nurse is really hard on console) they would have gotten 1 or 2 kills. 

    I still wait for the day that I can post the video of a nurse that bothers me or gets the 4k that happens in most other matches against killers.

    The solution is come to the dark side and play pc, you'll get scared and go back to console pretty quickly although there's some potato Nurses on pc as well. But generally Nurses at red ranks will get a hook within the 1st 30 seconds or so.

    Now if you really want to get scared back to console play against an Omega blink nurse and or one that knows how to play her and you'll be lucky to have the match last more than 2 minutes.

    Maybe pc survivors are just worse players than I am? As much as I would love to see these Uber nurses and show them up too, I don't think it's worth the £2000 investment into a decent pc. Thanks for the idea though.

    Also, if Uber nurses are a thing over in the land of pc gaming, post vids (:
  • starkiller1286
    starkiller1286 Member Posts: 890
    Nurse really isn't Op when a player first starts playing her they sick eggs and are almost a guaranteed 4 man escape. I am ok with her but still over/undershirt and whiff. She's a character where you get out what you put in and muscle memory. Although 4 to 5 blink nurse is op but very rare
  • gamerscrybecauseofme
    gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
    starkiller1286 said:
    Nurse really isn't Op when a player first starts playing her they sick eggs and are almost a guaranteed 4 man escape. I am ok with her but still over/undershirt and whiff. She's a character where you get out what you put in and muscle memory. Although 4 to 5 blink nurse is op but very rare
    So like all the other killers, when running the rare perks and add ons, she is OP
  • Master
    Master Member Posts: 10,200

    @gamerscrybecauseofme said:
    Rank 1. This is now 3 for 3 with nurses, where everyone survived. There isn't any other killer at this rank I can say that about. Again, I am not the greatest survivor either. I will take note that another game was done in under 5 minutes, this needs to change!!

    Well its nurse on console.... on PC its a different story.

    But yeah gentime needs to be adressed

  • Paddy4583
    Paddy4583 Member Posts: 864
    Rank 21 nurse confirmed!
  • Okapi
    Okapi Member Posts: 839
    edited January 2019

    Both nurse and gen times are OP and need to be addressed.

  • DarkWo1f997
    DarkWo1f997 Member Posts: 1,532
    edited January 2019
    These two are completely unrelated. Nurse was created as counterplay to “pit crew” survivors. She’s effective, not overpowered because of it. 
  • weirdkid5
    weirdkid5 Member Posts: 2,144
    I've been saying Nurse isn't OP even when she had 3 blinks.

    Survivors are literally just a bunch of children
  • gamerscrybecauseofme
    gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
    Okapi said:

    Both nurse and gen times are OP and need to be addressed.

    I am still trying to see any evidence or experience this.
  • gamerscrybecauseofme
    gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
    Master said:

    @gamerscrybecauseofme said:
    Rank 1. This is now 3 for 3 with nurses, where everyone survived. There isn't any other killer at this rank I can say that about. Again, I am not the greatest survivor either. I will take note that another game was done in under 5 minutes, this needs to change!!

    Well its nurse on console.... on PC its a different story.

    But yeah gentime needs to be adressed

    How or why is it different? Are pc survivors just that terrible
  • starkiller1286
    starkiller1286 Member Posts: 890
    gamerscrybecauseofme said:
    starkiller1286 said:
    Nurse really isn't Op when a player first starts playing her they sick eggs and are almost a guaranteed 4 man escape. I am ok with her but still over/undershirt and whiff. She's a character where you get out what you put in and muscle memory. Although 4 to 5 blink nurse is op but very rare
    So like all the other killers, when running the rare perks and add ons, she is OP
    Her rare add-ons remove a blink or throw off her timing the only add-ons that are a straight buff are the +1 blink and reduced fatigue 
  • scorpio
    scorpio Member Posts: 364
    edited January 2019

    @gamerscrybecauseofme said:
    powerbats said:

    @gamerscrybecauseofme said:

    PhantomMask20763 said:

    The Nurse player just wasnt very good. You're team did their job well and you guys escaped because the Nurse just wasnt very good. She just needs more practice that's all (and maybe an optimization patch too). You're team just did well. I bet if it was any other killer (especially since its console and Nurse is really hard on console) they would have gotten 1 or 2 kills. 

    I still wait for the day that I can post the video of a nurse that bothers me or gets the 4k that happens in most other matches against killers.

    The solution is come to the dark side and play pc, you'll get scared and go back to console pretty quickly although there's some potato Nurses on pc as well. But generally Nurses at red ranks will get a hook within the 1st 30 seconds or so.

    Now if you really want to get scared back to console play against an Omega blink nurse and or one that knows how to play her and you'll be lucky to have the match last more than 2 minutes.

    Maybe pc survivors are just worse players than I am? As much as I would love to see these Uber nurses and show them up too, I don't think it's worth the £2000 investment into a decent pc. Thanks for the idea though.

    Also, if Uber nurses are a thing over in the land of pc gaming, post vids (:

    PC survivors are WAY better than console survivors. PC Nurses are also WAY better than console Nurses.

    If you want a video, here is a good one that shows two matches -- the same killer player against the same team twice -- first time with Wraith and second time with Nurse. Really all you have to do is search for Nurse games on YouTube and you'll find a ton.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hbWENAvVuM0

  • gamerscrybecauseofme
    gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
    scorpio said:

    @gamerscrybecauseofme said:
    powerbats said:

    @gamerscrybecauseofme said:

    PhantomMask20763 said:

    The Nurse player just wasnt very good. You're team did their job well and you guys escaped because the Nurse just wasnt very good. She just needs more practice that's all (and maybe an optimization patch too). You're team just did well. I bet if it was any other killer (especially since its console and Nurse is really hard on console) they would have gotten 1 or 2 kills. 

    I still wait for the day that I can post the video of a nurse that bothers me or gets the 4k that happens in most other matches against killers.

    The solution is come to the dark side and play pc, you'll get scared and go back to console pretty quickly although there's some potato Nurses on pc as well. But generally Nurses at red ranks will get a hook within the 1st 30 seconds or so.

    Now if you really want to get scared back to console play against an Omega blink nurse and or one that knows how to play her and you'll be lucky to have the match last more than 2 minutes.

    Maybe pc survivors are just worse players than I am? As much as I would love to see these Uber nurses and show them up too, I don't think it's worth the £2000 investment into a decent pc. Thanks for the idea though.

    Also, if Uber nurses are a thing over in the land of pc gaming, post vids (:

    PC survivors are WAY better than console survivors. PC Nurses are also WAY better than console Nurses.

    If you want a video, here is a good one that shows two matches -- the same killer player against the same team twice -- first time with Wraith and second time with Nurse. Really all you have to do is search for Nurse games on YouTube and you'll find a ton.

    image

    Yeah, those survivors were relying on Line of sight blockers, not really good in my book lol. I didn't see much in the way of good movement from them either.

    This video does not prove the nurse is OP, some dude with revenge in his mind, pulled out his favourite killer to deal with some survivors that made him pay for his rather sloppy play as the wraith. It's not the match was under 5 mins, either of them, do this also doesn't count as proof of survivors being better than console survivors.

    As for searching YouTube for nurse videos, are you serious? Theyre not going to show the games where they get mugged off by survivors lol. Besides, you're the one that insists nurse are OP. This is either because you can't handle the nurse as a survivor or you're just drinking the OP nurse KOOL-AID. You post a video of your experience with the nurse, not some random YouTuber that obviously has sweaty play issues.
  • ad19970
    ad19970 Member Posts: 6,463

    @Okapi said:

    Both nurse and gen times are OP and need to be addressed.

    I highly agree with this.

  • gamerscrybecauseofme
    gamerscrybecauseofme Member Posts: 366
    I definitely agree with the latter
  • Vage
    Vage Member Posts: 10
    Probably you didn’t find the 6k hours nurse full legacy, have fun doing 1 gen when you and your team get rekt.
  • powerbats
    powerbats Member Posts: 7,068

    @Vage said:
    Probably you didn’t find the 6k hours nurse full legacy, have fun doing 1 gen when you and your team get rekt.

    There's 2k hour Nurses that go perkless and addon less and still destroy at red ranks their muscle memory and map knowledge is just that good.

    If they go omega blink Nurse and they're really good with her it's usually gg let em stand in front of a hook for you.

    I ran into one of the really good ones running the new Surveillance and she just destroyed us 2 blinks, reduced fatigue, faster blink.