Who is the best killer on console, Spirit or Billy?

Spirit + beads & Nurse's Call 😀

I’d say Spirit but it is a hard choice.

Depends on a lot of factors honestly. Really both are really good while Billy is easier to play from the get go both Killers have skills you can learn. Mastering any killer will easily let you stay at rank 1 despite what people want to say about tier systems of killers.

Billy has some cool tricks you can learn like curving which is fun. His simplicity is his true strength. Both killers have extremely good potential though.

Spirit has mindgames galore if you master her I feel her potential outshines Billy in the long run, but usually every update they break sounds in some way so she can easily be reduced to mid tier.

Overall both killers stand top tier on console and you pick the one you enjoy.

It's billy

Against average survivors (~90% of player base): billy

Against very good survivors (~10%): spirit

Other words rank 15-5 billy, 4-1 spirit

@TooKoolFoU You can do good on small maps as Billy IF you’re good. IF you can control the chainsaw. IF your frames don’t drop. He isn’t as good on Lery’s because he isn’t able to zip across the map as quickly as he would a map like Rotten Fields. Lery’s really isn’t good for any killer except Myers. I find the map to be hella boring.

If you get a map like Lery’s, when is Billy ever gonna be able to use his chainsaw? He will just get looped with the 50 windows in the map. You can’t deny that Billy is a little map dependent. He can’t reliably use his chainsaw on certain maps. Even if you’re good you’ll struggle. I can play Huntress on Coldwind or any killer on Haddonfield and 4K but it doesn’t mean the match wasn’t a struggle and a complete snoozefest.

Billy isn’t as good on certain maps. That’s just a fact. You can still win on the map but it won’t be as easy as it would for some killers.

Good survivors vs good Billy on Lery’s...more than likely will be a survivor win.

Wait, I'm confused 😂

I'd say spirit cause his power doesn't need any perks to counter. A spirit with prayer beads is going to cause you problems if you don't have spine chill.

Nurse is still the strongest killer if played correctly, the only big downside is that you need good fps to play her at full potential i'll post one of my gameplay when the conditions are optmal as i have hundred of hours with her on console. So if you talk about consistentcy i'd say Spirit at red ranks, but instasaw, enduring + sprit fury billy are also op.. There is also The hag, countered by flashlight, but you simply need to run franklin..i'd say against really good Survivors the most consistent are Spirit first, Hag second, Billy third.

@Poweas the fps now still suck, only 1 game out of 4 the fps are really good, but still nowhere near 60, only in kyf we maybe reach that, so i'm excited to see if they improve the game in the next patch, she would become a lot easier(i also played her when the fps sucked so bad so)

Here's some gameplay btw

@Poweas i'd like it, especially with the higher sensitivity.. but still fps are the only reason i don't play nurse as much as before, i don't use omegablinks anymore, they are far too op, that's why i run ruin and play with no add ons..we'll see tomorrow if they improved the game

@Poweas yeah understood, but something op is what we need esepcially against tryhard swf running all the crutches

@lunaticlifter @Poweas Nurse needs absolutely nothing to completely destroy survivors. She can go in without add-ons and perks and still kill everyone. She is just super good at ending chases quickly. If you’re good at Nurse then you need nothing.

Nurse is the ONLY killer than needs nothing against a good group. No other killer can do that, not Spirit, not Hag, not Billy. It doesn’t matter how good the survivors are, if the Nurse is really good she will always win.

With the other top tier killers like Spirit, Hag, and Billy you still don’t need OP add-ons. At the VERY most you’d need green add-ons. I don’t even use add-ons with Hag unless I’m doing a specific build.

I personally can’t play Nurse because I’m bad at her. The only time I did somewhat decent was when I was running the two long blink range add-ons.

@MegMain98 i agree, but imho you guys tend to understimate really good swf, not the altruistic one, not the toxic one, not them... the people that knoe how to play the game, know how to hide, know how to loop.. i met some god swf, they did 5 gens in 4 minutes, while i was downing people like flies(omegablink nurse)... i got 3 k but only thanks to a mori, no ruin.. trust me they are rare, but i balance my thoughts around those players

@lunaticlifter I’m talking about solely The Nurse. It really doesn’t matter if you know how to loop, Nurse cannot be looped.

If they bring in four commodious toolboxes with charge add-ons and ONLY did generators and brought in meta perks like Mettle of Man, Balanced Landing, Adrenaline, etc...they can win against any other killer. Nurse simply does not care. She blinks, hits a survivors, goes into a short stun and can down the survivor in 10 seconds flat. She has MASSIVE map control, the best chase potential, can never be looped, and a power that isn’t on a recharge.

When you can end a chase in under 20 seconds and fly across the map to another survivor and do that over and over again they can never win. Looping is not an option, the only way to win is stealth and four Blendettes makes for a very boring game.

@megmain98 that's what i meant, there also was a blendette in this team, she knew how to hide, but also the others knew how to stealth... but eventually(i met them also as legion) they also know how to loop.. for me a god swf are genrusher who know hot to play and cooperate against different killer, even a nurse can lose to that, talking about this specific case i won in the endgame, but only thanks to a mori.. i got demolished the game later as legion(it's ok though). Also if you don't think omegablink are op, you never played her. They should go to

@MegMain98 i agree sometimes we should just enjoy the game, but you know it's not funny to lose, when your opponent win just by crutches or because you don't have time to do nothing even if you play good, it's frustrating.. anyway you're talking right proxy camping is also a strategy espcially with hag.. then again Omegablinks are more powerful for someone who has a little of experience with her, while extra blinks are more powerful for someone who is still learning her..

@lunaticlifter The only survivor perk that is annoying to me is Mettle of Man, which is massively getting nerfed (as it should). I can’t complain about DS because I shouldn’t have been tunneling and I run Adrenaline so I’d be a hypocrite. I play to have fun until I run into a sweaty SWF group. I could win every single match with OP add-ons and a mori if I wanted to and overpower all of them but I choose not to. It’s no point in playing like them. Although sometimes I will just to let off some steam on a group that I've previously played against.

Hag is the best killer at camping because she doesn’t even have to be at the hook in order to come back in two seconds. She is basically made to patrol the hook, it’s why Make Your Choice is godly on her.

If I had to choose between The Spirit and The Hillbilly. I actually had a lot more fun being The Hillbilly. His chainsaw can be a real game changer. He is much easier to learn in comparison. To be fair, The Spirit with a great set up can easily destroy a group of survivors.

Imo spirit. Billy can be fun, but spirit just feels strong to play. Especially with a good build like prayerbeads, ruin, and surveillance. She just has a ton of map preassure and information. Not to mention great for gen grabs and stopping loops from going on too long.