Camaraderie could become problematic

Necessarily the killer could be no I need a hook and I could still very easily just walk by it go work on a gen that's close to the hook and then save the person later.

In fact the timer suddenly being paused is more likely to make a killer come back to the hook than anything else

Yes, thank you! If I camp and nobody is around, since they are doing gens, the perk doesn't matter and I am dumb for standing around while gens go off like fireworks.

If it's meant as an anti-camp perk, it is very poorly designed.

You guys do realize that in order for Camaraderie to trigger you have to be hooked twice, right? Compared to all of the perks we have now, who is really going to pick a perk they'll use once a game over any of the other perks that will help them avoid getting hooked in the first place?

I don't exactly know, but its 16 for survivor/survivors, even if there is only one survivor near the hook or the entire team, the perk only has a time set for 34sec and not 34+34+34 because of all the survivors... Sorry if I am wrong...

I got a couple ideas for changes to this perk.

1) Change it from 16m to 32m/40m/48m

2) Make it work at any point, not just the struggle phase.

I believe they should only bring in one of these, however if they were to pick the second it should be changed to 24 metres. With either change, it could prevent face camping even better and make it a viable perk even if you aren't going against face campers

if survivors knew to do gens, then yes, the camping killer would be "punished severely".

But if they rush the hook (most survivors do), then the only one who is "punished severely" is the hooked survivor as the killer fights the survivors flocking the hook.

In swf groups, they will take advantage of communication and alternate dipping into the radius to prolong unhook time (which is stated already in this thread)

Again: this is a swf buff and perk that prolongs camping (not punishes ) it

Stop camping.

Which doesn't actually tax facecampers, but taxes the one on the hook, as you already stated

I really only see this as a problem for killers that are camping, or SWF because it's SWF.....And i mean like 4 person SFW. I don't camp though so it doesn't really bother me in the slightest. Only time i'm near the area is if someone decides to either farm their allies or wants to try and run me around the hook someones on like a dummy. I feel bad for the people who have that happen (If they try and farm their teammate i usually down the person who attempted and let the other one off. I'll get them later anyway :P)

Yeah... In a sense its only for the person on the Hook, but if you think about it, it taxes a Face camper wasting time on thirsting for a Kill.

If 4 Survivors stack this in rank 20, the Killer would never win. Which is good, they should take routes outside their comfort zone, and improve upon them.

Camping isn't the end all way to Kill someone or get back at someone you hate, its more satisfying to destroy their team and break their spirits :)

The saying that get's thrown around like crazy that I see both sides flinging at the other really applies to the perk. "Adapt" Walking away is literally a hard counter to the perk. Just don't play overly campy and they basically waste a perk.

it's your job to make the killer mess up. that will never happen if you stay far away for whatever reason. and yes, that is the actual counter to camping. thank you for asking.

i'm not sure what you're asking in your second question, but to answer what i think you are asking, i think the killer can do whatever they want. if they want to run around the window 3 times, go for it. if they want to run bamboozle, that may save them a loop or 2. if they'd rather go find someone not at a safe zone, that's cool too.

if it's me and i'm at that window, i'll use it a lot. i love LTs. i also let the killer kill me at the end most of the time tho. not many people do. if i'm the killer i'll usually go look for a friend. you don't have to "prove" to a survivor that you can catch them..

it's really about whatever they want to do. i'm good with it regardless. hope that answers it for ya & gets it cleared up.

I don’t like gen perks at all. I really think it would be interesting if survivors have to do other objectives then just generators. It will slow down the game, make it more challenging and “fun”. The best example I can give is “The Hallowed Blight” event. Games felt not rushed, it was refreshing for me to do something else other then just gens and get rewarded for it. But that’s my personal opinion. I wish you all a great weekend!!:)

If the Doc was 'good,' he'd have stayed in Treatment mode and just mashed M1 as fast as he could (you can grab people in Treatment) at any Unhook attempts, literally guaranteeing a grab and a second Basement hook.

So yeah, you can dance around someone that is not using a 100% GUARANTEED GRAB in the basement...

Figured you'd recognize all this bad play at 5k hours.

>_>;;

i'm not sure where your joke comes in..

a lot of people assume every killer they load into a match with is the sweatiest of the sweaty.. fact is most killers don't have much of a clue.

were there mistakes made by the killer in the video? yes. the video is intended to show that even ol' zappy tappy is easy enough to best so get in there and get some experience learning how. for your reference, this particular doctor was rank 5, not rank 20.

i assume that most people who legitimately complain about camping are closer to rank 15 than 5, where there would be even more mistakes made. lower rank players who don't save people are cemented in the mindset that is just wrong & boring & there's no helping them..

surprisingly nobody's brought it up, but this can even be done successfully against 1 hit down killers such as hillbilly & leather face, with practice of course, and once you start pulling off clutch saves, the game will change into something completely different and way better than the old hide-and-seek stuff.

if you're a chump with a basement macro vs actually trying to play the game normally, i don't mind riding the hook out with that guy cuz you're a sad sack who apparently needs a hook/pip more than i do..

in reality tho, as much as you are trying to make your point, i have been making clutch saves for years now and the scenario you describe happens in maybe 1 out of 15+ attempts. this is not a reason worth discouraging people from attempting to play the game over.

also notice how i'm avoiding the doctor being behind me as much as possible? i'm trying to force him to swing. if he does hit that button and it isn't a guaranteed pull, no matter what happens i just won. his macro would cause him to swing, hit something, and recover, providing me the time i needed to unhook.

also notice i was very generously rewarded with 2 WGLF stacks, that's right, an additional 50% total score bonus, making it more than worth my time to take a chance and see if i can best him.

you say this doctor was too dumb to play or was intentionally throwing the game or whatever, but to you i say if your point was true, if Doctor was a "no-can-defend" hook guardian, we'd probably see a lot more of him in lower ranks than we do.

just because you like a killer or think you have some super sweet killer kung fu doesn't mean you've been around the block enough to know yet.

i'm not trying to be specific to doctor, only to a killer camping.

if you're "emulating" a "chump with a macro" by just clicking the button all crazy like as if you had a macro, you're still a "chump with a macro".. just saying..

again, none of what you're saying changes the fact that i do this all of the time and i very rarely get pulled off..

the point is it can easily be done, and it works with a very high success rate. never was it ever said that it would work 100% of the time.

yes/no binary question first:

do you realize in the video that the doctor was in treatment mode? lul

what is your goal/glitch here friend?

you are only proving my point. you say, had the doctor just mashed the hell outta m1 in treatment mode, he wins, 100% of the time. i say (for the record) you're 100% wrong.

when i go down there, he's in treatment mode. he attempts to shock me. everyone knows, if he just shocks me, he gets a free hit when i can't unhook. that's why people aren't fans of doctors. instead, for some reason, he switches to punishment mode. to me i don't really care what mode he's in, because the issue in the moment isn't about him, it's about the guy on the hook needing to come down.. i could care less what mode he's in.

i need to make him make a mistake. per your own words / analysis i've already caused him to make a mistake by leaving treatment mode. he attempts to get behind me for the grab, but he can not. my back doesn't turn to him. after a while, he switches back to treatment mode to attempt the zappy-tap, giving me the opportunity to unhook the survivor without even taking damage.

again, rank 5, not brand new. full build you would expect on a doctor in lower ranks, not brand new. he made mistakes, i capitalized on them. that's the name of the game. if i'm somewhere far away rushing objectives trying to "punish" the guy, which do you think effects him as a person more?