CoopaMan

Okay, so I used anonymous mode, and it worked on the first game! After 20+ games it finally worked, thank you to whoever discovered this :)

I have this same issue for killer and survivor. I'm going to try what other people said about having no perks on, and I'll update you on if it works or not. After the game: I went into the game without any perks on (the randomized perks did not apply) But I've heard the second game should work, so I'll try that and update…