We have temporarily disabled The Houndmaster (Bone Chill Event queue) and Baermar Uraz's Ugly Sweater Cosmetic (all queues) due to issues affecting gameplay.

Visit the Kill Switch Master List for more information on these and other current known issues: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/kb/articles/299-kill-switch-master-list
The Dead by Daylight team would like your feedback in a Player Satisfaction survey.

We encourage you to be as honest as possible in letting us know how you feel about the game. The information and answers provided are anonymous, not shared with any third-party, and will not be used for purposes other than survey analysis.

Access the survey HERE!

Question About Gesturing on Hook

So when I started playing this game, I was under the impression that if I try to unhook but don't complete the action to create that flappy arm motion - it translates to "killer's right here, don't try to save me." But then I was told it was the opposite? Just want to see how everyone else responds to that while playing solo survivor? (Obviously if I'm in SWF I can just tell my friends over chat "hey just let me die lol" but I don't have that option 90% of the time I'm playing.)

Comments

  • Mandy
    Mandy Administrator, Dev, Community Manager Posts: 23,357

    When the game first started - going for the flappy arms motion did indeed mean that the killer was camping and do gens....staying still on the hook was the sign that it was safe to rescue.

    Over time these got mixed up, now I don't think anyone really pays any attention to whether or not you are waving your arms on the hook.

  • FireHazard
    FireHazard Member Posts: 7,314

    Didn't Kindred come out in 1.1.0?

    But it wasn't as beefy as it is now.

  • Deadeye
    Deadeye Member Posts: 3,627

    There was just recently another thread with this question. I think common sense was that we should focus on using the same "speech" again to iron out one of the solo survivor flaws :)

    Flapping should mean "killer camps", do gens. Doing the unhook like 90% and stop means "help me, other is in chase / noone else coming". Hope we can implement that :)

  • MysticMusician
    MysticMusician Member Posts: 149

    Is that what it means? Sometimes people just spam flap their arms for fun from what I've seen lol

  • Fibijean
    Fibijean Member Posts: 8,342

    Unfortunately, you can if enough people decide it means something different. That's how languages evolve over time. Right now, half the community use a certain gesture to mean one thing, half of them use it to mean the other, and since you don't know which camp your teammates fit into, it's no longer possible to communicate clearly one way or the other unless you agree on a method of communication with those specific people in advance.

  • Deadeye
    Deadeye Member Posts: 3,627

    That's why I hope the latest 2 threads bring us to common sense again.

    @MysticMusician yes, it used to be. And currently sometimes peole just get bored and do the only thing they can do in that situation ^_^'

  • animalmak
    animalmak Member Posts: 399

    Thanks for the answers everyone!

  • whammigobambam
    whammigobambam Member Posts: 1,201

    David is the one true hero of flappy arms magee. David's got the muscle to flex on the killer camping the hook, mostly. Flappy arms will summon a David with his flapping and all will be right in the world

  • Supernaut
    Supernaut Member Posts: 1,532


    Fair enough, but if someone is in my games and is flapping, I won't be coming for the save! :)

  • ZoneDymo
    ZoneDymo Member Posts: 1,946

    If you flap your arms, I assume you are being camped and ill leave you hanging.

  • Brisingr
    Brisingr Member Posts: 104

    Quick Flapping motions mean the killer is camping; long, almost escape-attempt flaps mean that no one has started running for the save yet and the person wants to be unhooked.


    This has proven to be consistent for me in red ranks, at least until the rank reset changes that allowed more unskilled players into red...

  • AngryFluffy
    AngryFluffy Member Posts: 443

    If someone is on the hook and flapping with their arms, I'm not gonna go for the unhook.

    I started playing 2016 and it always meant that the killer is camping and everyone should do gens. And I think it us the only logical translation to this gesture. If someone does that out of boredom and nobody goes for the unhook, jokes on them. I only do it in case nobody unhooks me and I'd hit 2nd state if noone comes right now.

  • Archimedes5000
    Archimedes5000 Member Posts: 1,620

    It should be added to the tutorial and the loading screen hints.

  • Shirokuro
    Shirokuro Member Posts: 182

    Well I don't know about others but personally I do it like this:

    Someone nearby is coming to unhook me, I stay still if it's safe, do the motion if not (either the killer or traps are nearby).

    I also do the arm motion if everyone seems to be doing gens far away to signal that someone should come get me.

    Surprisingly, I think it has worked most of the time.