I agree with the bottom half of your list quite a lot. I love the fact Freddy has his own tier lol. The one I disagree with most personally is Spirit. Without Iron Will I think she's insanely boring to face.
Honestly I wish Freddy burnt in the boiler room and didn't come back to haunt everyone...also I run Iron Will, so if I face a Spirit who doesn't use Stridor I'm usually fine.
I agree mostly, except for pig and clown. They should move up. Your bottom three are also my bottom three and I would add leatherface to that. I agree with your top 8 too and would add pig.
I think this is why I gave up on playing survivor. Aside from Huntress the top 5 have all but disappeared, hell most of those in the top 3 tiers barely appear anymore. Now it's all Spirit, Doc, Freddy, Deathslinger, Hillbilly, Legion, Ghostface. I can put up with a mix of fun and not so fun killers but the bottom 3 just put me off playing the game completely and sadly they seem to be some of the most common killers.
I’m actually surprised that Legion isn’t at the bottom of all these lists.
Good to have another Hillbilly hater on the forums. To be honest I think he would be ok after some nerfs. Its not his mechanics that make him awful like legion and ghostface who imo need major work. Billy just needs to give survivors more room to breathe. Hes gonna be worse than ever on the new maps. New thompsons house lets him sprint all over but theres little in the way of defence.
I don't hate Hillbilly, but I dislike how he has high mobility, destruction and an INSTANT DOWN base kit and in one button press.
What I hate is how people use his chainsaw as a primary weapon and tell me that he's a skillful character for it. And claim him to be the "centre of balance" for the game, when it's clearly Huntress. Unless the Devs mean emblems, but community means kills. I also hate when people say that his chainsaw is easy to dodge when I say that I'm a) on Xbox and b) that they chainsaw me from less than a meter away, only to get told to not be out of position.
A permanent tier 1 Myers is a lot of fun to play against. Aside from Freddy, Pig is probably the worst for me. Ghostface and Doctor are on the bottom too, because I see them in just about every trial.
Huntress would be under “enjoyable” if it wasn’t for dedicated servers.
Ghostface would be under “average” if his reveal mechanic wasn’t busted.
Clown and Legion are not strong in the slightest but they are a snoozefest. Clown is just worse Freddy and Legion is basically playing tag and you are playing mending simulator.
I don’t enjoy a good portion of the roster of killers and I ALWAYS run into Deathslinger, Freddy, Billy, Doc, and Legion so I haven’t played survivor very frequently or even DBD as much as I used to :/
Completely agree on Pig, Hag, and Leatherface. If the player wants to then they can make one survivor’s game brutal. They can still easily lose the game but they are great at ensuring kills by scummy tactics.
Wraith CAN do that but not as well as the other three.
I run spinechill, and half of the time I run right into him and I leave myself laughing, plus most ghostfaces I play are nice and give a free win if one or two people dc.
First of all most at rank 1 just spam their portals (not all but some). Most also run add ons that slow down action speed in the dream world with dying light and thanataphobia.
Wow its amazing seeing how different people's perspectives are. I would put fresh as average or one tier less just. I hate leather face though bottom 100% for me
Clown may not be fun to against because of his power, but I like going against him because of his aesthetics.
Aesthetically, Clown has the best cosmetics because he really dehumanises the positive perception of what a clown is supposed to be and truly creates a terrifying monster that has clearly lost all hope in humanity. The lore even states that the killers are monsters and no longer human. The Clown does not sugar-coat how terrifying he is. I guess the same can be said for some of the other killers.
(I went a bit philosophical there) that's why I like going against him.
Personally I'd drop spirit down to below Freddy. I have a vendetta against that killer and hate facing her with a burning passion. If she runs stridor then good luck.
I also don't really like myers because of some experiences I had as a new player facing him that's just stuck with me.
Pig and doc though I'd move up to "Enjoyable games". Pig can be stealthy and the tension of an active RBT gets me going and I love it, and something about doc knowing where you are and so putting you on a time crunch making the game more tense is just something I absolutely love.
Aside from that, I agree mostly. Interesting take.
Only disagree with the Huntress. I don't know why or how, but I never seem to win against her bar the rare lucky episode. She's creepy, she throws hatches, she sings... She can gtf 😂
I agree with the bottom half of your list quite a lot. I love the fact Freddy has his own tier lol. The one I disagree with most personally is Spirit. Without Iron Will I think she's insanely boring to face.
Honestly I wish Freddy burnt in the boiler room and didn't come back to haunt everyone...also I run Iron Will, so if I face a Spirit who doesn't use Stridor I'm usually fine.
I agree mostly, except for pig and clown. They should move up. Your bottom three are also my bottom three and I would add leatherface to that. I agree with your top 8 too and would add pig.
I think this is why I gave up on playing survivor. Aside from Huntress the top 5 have all but disappeared, hell most of those in the top 3 tiers barely appear anymore. Now it's all Spirit, Doc, Freddy, Deathslinger, Hillbilly, Legion, Ghostface. I can put up with a mix of fun and not so fun killers but the bottom 3 just put me off playing the game completely and sadly they seem to be some of the most common killers.
We have much, much different views...
Would drop Legion and Doctor down one. Healing/Screaming simulator isn’t fun, especially if the rest of your team don’t know how to play against them.
For me some matches are good and some are bad with them.
Interesting take on a tier list! It's amazing how different opinions are. Fun is subjective so it is expected though.
Also poor Freddy! 😁
I actually enjoy Freddy games, but i can understand why many don't.
I hate Myers btw.
It seems as though everyone has vastly different opinions on who is fun and who isn't.
How can a killer like GF whose entire mechanic is frustrating as hell be enjoyable? This entireiyt doesnt make much sense.
Probably because opinions differ.
Ghost Face is my fav because none of the other killers have made me scream. His sneaky arse scares me sometimes. Myers has come close.
My perk tier list but based on how good the drawings are.
Youre a goddamn genius. Best killer tierlist I ever laid eyes on
Spirit, Deathslinger and Nurse the the most disgusting Killers to play against in Red Ranks. Most people would agree with that
Obviously this guy doesn't play high ranks.
Hillbilly? Fun?
Nurse and Spirit?
Pig low?
What rank and platform are you on, because this is wildly different to what I'd be putting down.
Survivors say I play a real fun Bubba! Not that i'm too good at being a killer
I wholeheartedly agree. Freddy is an absolute snoozefest. He's so brainless to play.
These two are closer to my preferences. I love facing Myers, Huntress, Clown etc. Really don't enjoy the likes of Freddy, Legion, and Ghostface.
I’m actually surprised that Legion isn’t at the bottom of all these lists.
Good to have another Hillbilly hater on the forums. To be honest I think he would be ok after some nerfs. Its not his mechanics that make him awful like legion and ghostface who imo need major work. Billy just needs to give survivors more room to breathe. Hes gonna be worse than ever on the new maps. New thompsons house lets him sprint all over but theres little in the way of defence.
D:
Ghost Face is actually the only good killer. Idk why lists are needed guys
What do you think is the reason why many people hate versing Fredd?
I went with the OP's format in terms of tiers. But I wouldn't classify the lower tiers so much boring as less enjoyable. Anyway that is my list.
I don't hate Hillbilly, but I dislike how he has high mobility, destruction and an INSTANT DOWN base kit and in one button press.
What I hate is how people use his chainsaw as a primary weapon and tell me that he's a skillful character for it. And claim him to be the "centre of balance" for the game, when it's clearly Huntress. Unless the Devs mean emblems, but community means kills. I also hate when people say that his chainsaw is easy to dodge when I say that I'm a) on Xbox and b) that they chainsaw me from less than a meter away, only to get told to not be out of position.
A permanent tier 1 Myers is a lot of fun to play against. Aside from Freddy, Pig is probably the worst for me. Ghostface and Doctor are on the bottom too, because I see them in just about every trial.
Fun and engaging challenge: Oni, Demo, an okay Nurse
Standard M1 Killer: M1 Hags, Bubba, Wraith, the average Billy, Myers,
Standard M1 Killer with an extra layer of annoying gimmicks: Pig, Trapper, Clown, Legion, Faceghost, Doctor, Plague
Frustrating: Huntress, Deathslinger, Spirit, a good Billy
I want to DC: Spirit, Freddy, a good Nurse, a good Hag
You don't deserve to play the video game: Oni with Scalped Topknot
Weirdly I really enjoy playing against Oni.
Huntress would be under “enjoyable” if it wasn’t for dedicated servers.
Ghostface would be under “average” if his reveal mechanic wasn’t busted.
Clown and Legion are not strong in the slightest but they are a snoozefest. Clown is just worse Freddy and Legion is basically playing tag and you are playing mending simulator.
I don’t enjoy a good portion of the roster of killers and I ALWAYS run into Deathslinger, Freddy, Billy, Doc, and Legion so I haven’t played survivor very frequently or even DBD as much as I used to :/
Of course this is purely my opinion, as we all can see everyone have different opinions ( Deathslinger can also go to scary ones )
This is my tierlist, for some reason they didn't had billy but he is on the really fun to play against
Here is mine.
Completely agree on Pig, Hag, and Leatherface. If the player wants to then they can make one survivor’s game brutal. They can still easily lose the game but they are great at ensuring kills by scummy tactics.
Wraith CAN do that but not as well as the other three.
I run spinechill, and half of the time I run right into him and I leave myself laughing, plus most ghostfaces I play are nice and give a free win if one or two people dc.
Never knew there was a rank higher than 1...
Rank 1 on Xbox, I like challenging games where I have to make jukes.
I hate playing against legion, doctor and spirit. Legion and spirit in particular.
Currently rank 6, highest has been 3 due to time constraints.
I'm also on Xbox. Maybe we should team up some time.
First of all most at rank 1 just spam their portals (not all but some). Most also run add ons that slow down action speed in the dream world with dying light and thanataphobia.
Wow its amazing seeing how different people's perspectives are. I would put fresh as average or one tier less just. I hate leather face though bottom 100% for me
I agree with OP's tier list except for Clown.
Clown may not be fun to against because of his power, but I like going against him because of his aesthetics.
Aesthetically, Clown has the best cosmetics because he really dehumanises the positive perception of what a clown is supposed to be and truly creates a terrifying monster that has clearly lost all hope in humanity. The lore even states that the killers are monsters and no longer human. The Clown does not sugar-coat how terrifying he is. I guess the same can be said for some of the other killers.
(I went a bit philosophical there) that's why I like going against him.
Remove Spirit.
Glad to see everyone likes demo games.
He really is the best boi, but not enough people play him.
Personally I'd drop spirit down to below Freddy. I have a vendetta against that killer and hate facing her with a burning passion. If she runs stridor then good luck.
I also don't really like myers because of some experiences I had as a new player facing him that's just stuck with me.
Pig and doc though I'd move up to "Enjoyable games". Pig can be stealthy and the tension of an active RBT gets me going and I love it, and something about doc knowing where you are and so putting you on a time crunch making the game more tense is just something I absolutely love.
Aside from that, I agree mostly. Interesting take.
Only disagree with the Huntress. I don't know why or how, but I never seem to win against her bar the rare lucky episode. She's creepy, she throws hatches, she sings... She can gtf 😂
Unpopular opinion, but I actually love going against Doc and Freddy. Myers will always be the most fun for me tho, especially if he's a jumpscare boi.
You’re a very lucky person. The ones I see slug for the 4k even if others dc.
I definitely mostly agree but for me I find spirit is the worst to play against. I'm good at looping any other killer but spirit messes me up bad