We have temporarily disabled The Houndmaster (Bone Chill Event queue) and Baermar Uraz's Ugly Sweater Cosmetic (all queues) due to issues affecting gameplay.

Visit the Kill Switch Master List for more information on these and other current known issues: https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/kb/articles/299-kill-switch-master-list
The Dead by Daylight team would like your feedback in a Player Satisfaction survey.

We encourage you to be as honest as possible in letting us know how you feel about the game. The information and answers provided are anonymous, not shared with any third-party, and will not be used for purposes other than survey analysis.

Access the survey HERE!

Crows above head for being idle

Broosmeister
Broosmeister Member Posts: 281
edited January 2019 in General Discussions
I completely get the purpose of the crows above your head when you're AFK or just sitting in a corner / locker for too long.
But i think the crows shouldn't spawn on your head too soon with too many people alive. Yesterday i played against a camping billy, it was just me and the other survivor. I got close to where he was hooked to block BBQ & Chili since there wasn't really a locker around me. I ended up behind some tires. The Billy just walked in small circles around the hook, i couldn't leave my location or i would be seen. And sure enough, after walking around the tires a couple of times, a crow spawned above my head, i immediately ran, got caught and i was game ended.

This is a situation where crows shouldn't spawn on top of my head. I think it should only spawn on the last survivor within this time. And with more survivors it should take a longer time. The crows really fcked me up that time while i was just playing the game normally.
Post edited by Broosmeister on

Comments

  • Broosmeister
    Broosmeister Member Posts: 281
    I absolutely agree. As long as in you are remaining in the killer's terror radius it shouldn't count as being idle/afk. It happened me once but it could've costed me the game if it wasn't a Trapper (kappa).
    Trapper lives matter 🙁
  • powerbats
    powerbats Member Posts: 7,068

    I've found Diversion works really well on Billy, bubba and Wraith the rest not so much sadly.

  • Slayer
    Slayer Member Posts: 1,148

    Yes it comes too soon i agree

  • Broosmeister
    Broosmeister Member Posts: 281
    I don't have diversion as one of my standard perks, i want to use it a bit more but i'm testing out all kinds of perks. 

    I think the crows shouldn't appear while someone is on the hook. 

    The other guy used deliverance to get himself off the hook, and forgot to go into a locker to hide from bbq & chili. But hey, that's the solo player's life, a team who has no idea what's going on.
  • Nick
    Nick Member Posts: 1,244

    @powerbats said:
    I've found Diversion works really well on Billy, bubba and Wraith the rest not so much sadly.

    Diversion works on any bad player. But it might work on Doc, because he is playing the Explosion simulator

  • Master
    Master Member Posts: 10,200

    I hate survivors that camp together with the killer. In such a case I usually suicide on hook.

  • Rebel_Raven
    Rebel_Raven Member Posts: 1,775
    Sorry if I come off a but much here, but...
    Why the hell are you there that long??!! 

    If the killer is camping that hard, and you can't draw them off, just go do something else! #########'a!
    Break totems. Do gens. If there is a gen in visual of the killer, do that. Break a totem in visual range!

    Further our progress to escape so either my sacrifice isn't in vain, or I don't have to survive any longer than I have to!

    The killer might even know you're there! Why would a killer that hasn't left before, leave all of a sudden?

  • Broosmeister
    Broosmeister Member Posts: 281
    Sorry if I come off a but much here, but...
    Why the hell are you there that long??!! 

    If the killer is camping that hard, and you can't draw them off, just go do something else! #########'a!
    Break totems. Do gens. If there is a gen in visual of the killer, do that. Break a totem in visual range!

    Further our progress to escape so either my sacrifice isn't in vain, or I don't have to survive any longer than I have to!

    The killer might even know you're there! Why would a killer that hasn't left before, leave all of a sudden?

    Jezus Christ, i expected that killers don't camp a guy when there is only 1 other survivor left with 2 gens to go. That's just useless. Even if the guy gets unhooked, there is no way we can get 2 gens done and it's so easy for billy to just go back to the hook and follow the scratchmarks.

    If i left my position, i was out in the open. I literally couldn't leave so i was just hoping for the best.
  • Delfador
    Delfador Member Posts: 2,552

    I agree, in those situations the crows should be nerfed, there are times when I shouldn't get a crow but get one anyway.

    After this, the crows should be buffed. If you are the last survivor remaining alive, after a certain period of time, a crow should appear on top of your head in order to prevent game hostage situations. I don't think it should give sound notifications to the killer but just so that when you are close, you can hear the crow as a killer.

  • This content has been removed.
  • Slayer
    Slayer Member Posts: 1,148
    Master said:

    I hate survivors that camp together with the killer. In such a case I usually suicide on hook.

    I hate survivors that suicide on hook because something didnt go their way . You ended up on hook you dont have right to complain how you suppose to get saved
  • DemonDaddy
    DemonDaddy Member Posts: 4,167
    Can't really agree as it was your choice that lead to being pinned to the spot. Shouldn't matter if it was close to the killer or not, fear of being seen isn't a reason for being able to stay put beyond afk timer.
  • Rebel_Raven
    Rebel_Raven Member Posts: 1,775
    Sorry if I come off a but much here, but...
    Why the hell are you there that long??!! 

    If the killer is camping that hard, and you can't draw them off, just go do something else! #########'a!
    Break totems. Do gens. If there is a gen in visual of the killer, do that. Break a totem in visual range!

    Further our progress to escape so either my sacrifice isn't in vain, or I don't have to survive any longer than I have to!

    The killer might even know you're there! Why would a killer that hasn't left before, leave all of a sudden?

    Jezus Christ, i expected that killers don't camp a guy when there is only 1 other survivor left with 2 gens to go. That's just useless. Even if the guy gets unhooked, there is no way we can get 2 gens done and it's so easy for billy to just go back to the hook and follow the scratchmarks.

    If i left my position, i was out in the open. I literally couldn't leave so i was just hoping for the best.
    If a killer isn't moving for a bit, they probably won't at all until the kill is secured. 
    Billy probably forgot to slug to prevent the hatch play on top of that. 

    Speaking of, you couldn't go for the hatch? I'd want you to go find the hatch if it were me hooked and being secure kill camped.
    If you play stealthy you're going to be hard to find. Killers have terrible eyesight. You might be surprised at what you can get away with.


  • Flipkick661
    Flipkick661 Member Posts: 20

    I litterally had a game go on for twenty minutes after third survivor was killed, and only one gen and all totems were done. No crows. I looked everywhere, listened for the caws, patrolled the gens that remained untouched, there was no sign of the last survivor. After twenty minutes, one of the spectating survivors started messaging me, telling me that the last player had been hiding in the same locker the whole time, and bragging to the survivor group in chat that he'd get me to rage quit and get a loss. In the end he told me which locker to look in, and I secured the final kill.

    I don't know if AFK crows are bugged on PS4, but I have had several situations like this, and I can only remember a single time where I spotted some crows circling in the distance, helping me find the last survivor.

    Long story short, I'd like to see the crows working properly, before seeing a nerf.

  • RoKrueger
    RoKrueger Member Posts: 1,371
    I completely get the purpose of the crows above your head when you're AFK or just sitting in a corner / locker for too long.
    But i think the crows shouldn't spawn on your head too soon with too many people alive. Yesterday i played against a camping billy, it was just me and the other survivor. I got close to where he was hooked to block BBQ & Chili since there wasn't really a locker around me. I ended up behind some tires. The Billy just walked in small circles around the hook, i couldn't leave my location or i would be seen. And sure enough, after walking around the tires a couple of times, a crow spawned above my head, i immediately ran, got caught and i was game ended.

    This is a situation where crows shouldn't spawn on top of my head. I think it should only spawn on the last survivor within this time. And with more survivors it should take a longer time. The crows really fcked me up that time while i was just playing the game normally.
    You should have left and do gens. Don't blame the poor birds for your mistakes
  • RoKrueger
    RoKrueger Member Posts: 1,371
    Slayer said:
    Master said:

    I hate survivors that camp together with the killer. In such a case I usually suicide on hook.

    I hate survivors that suicide on hook because something didnt go their way . You ended up on hook you dont have right to complain how you suppose to get saved
    I love it when they do that. Makes the rest of the match a lot easier when I play as killer. It hurts the rest of the survivors morale too
  • LCGaster
    LCGaster Member Posts: 3,154

    I think they should make it so that crows don't spawn when you are close to the killer/inside the terror radius.
    Or at least they should appear slower, much slower

  • ClogWench
    ClogWench Member Posts: 2,582
    Sounds like a very specific situation that could have been avoided.
  • Broosmeister
    Broosmeister Member Posts: 281
    ClogWench said:
    Sounds like a very specific situation that could have been avoided.
    It doesn't need to be specific. What if you sit in a corner around a generator you were working on and you get one of those killers who patrol that gen so heavily that you can't leave your spot.

    What if you do a locker juke and the killer keeps circling the area around the locker you're in?

    It's just unlogical for the crows to spawn so quickly and without being the last survivor too 
  • MegaWaffle
    MegaWaffle Member Posts: 4,172

    @NurseMainBTW said:
    I absolutely agree. As long as in you are remaining in the killer's terror radius it shouldn't count as being idle/afk. It happened me once but it could've costed me the game if it wasn't a Trapper (kappa).

    The problem with using the TR is that not all killers have the same radius (plus perks alter range). This would still cause inconsistent idle times and not completely fix the problem.

    The situation the OP mentioned (I agree it sucks) is a rare occurrence and can easily be avoided by positioning yourself better. I know the OP said they were trying to avoid the detection of BBQ but you can use gen auras, lockers, or simply get within radius (its much larger than you realize). It sounds like the OP made a poor choice in hiding where he/she did and although it would be nice for the game to realize he/she wasn't actually AFK I don't feel this is a fix the team needs to be focusing right now. Heaven knows they have a lot more to fix first...

  • Broosmeister
    Broosmeister Member Posts: 281

    @NurseMainBTW said:
    I absolutely agree. As long as in you are remaining in the killer's terror radius it shouldn't count as being idle/afk. It happened me once but it could've costed me the game if it wasn't a Trapper (kappa).

    The problem with using the TR is that not all killers have the same radius (plus perks alter range). This would still cause inconsistent idle times and not completely fix the problem.

    The situation the OP mentioned (I agree it sucks) is a rare occurrence and can easily be avoided by positioning yourself better. I know the OP said they were trying to avoid the detection of BBQ but you can use gen auras, lockers, or simply get within radius (its much larger than you realize). It sounds like the OP made a poor choice in hiding where he/she did and although it would be nice for the game to realize he/she wasn't actually AFK I don't feel this is a fix the team needs to be focusing right now. Heaven knows they have a lot more to fix first...

    It's true that it's my mistake to hide where i was hiding. But it shouldn't be a fatal mistake. And because of the crows it was.
  • KiraElijah
    KiraElijah Member Posts: 1,187

    I think it should stay how it is, you put yourself there. Should’ve tried to find an opening xD

  • Broosmeister
    Broosmeister Member Posts: 281

    I think it should stay how it is, you put yourself there. Should’ve tried to find an opening xD

    How is it fair that a killer who is not even trying to look for a survivor to find a survivor because of some stupid crows while someone is hooked?
  • Dreamnomad
    Dreamnomad Member Posts: 3,965

    I have to disagree. There is no situation where you get a crow over your head that you didn't deserve it. There is no "solution" to the problem because there is no problem. Any so called solution you come up with would make the game worse.

    Even in the scenario described by the OP, there were other options available. For instance you could have hidden in a locker to hide your aura from BBQ. Or you could have positioned yourself better while being close enough not to trigger BBQ. The range from the hook is pretty lenient really.

  • lasombra1979
    lasombra1979 Member Posts: 1,142

    @Broosmeister said:
    KiraElijah said:

    I think it should stay how it is, you put yourself there. Should’ve tried to find an opening xD

    How is it fair that a killer who is not even trying to look for a survivor to find a survivor because of some stupid crows while someone is hooked?

    It takes 60 seconds for the first crow to appear. If you cannot find a way out before that, I see no issue with the spawn.

  • Volfawott
    Volfawott Member Posts: 3,893
    Honestly as douchey as it sounds it just seems like it was incredibly bad positioning on your part.

    I don't think you should get leniency because you positioned yourself in a spot where you couldn't move because of The Killers Patrol
  • Artemis_LH
    Artemis_LH Member Posts: 113

    I really dont mind idle crows...until I have to take a pee break. I just duck into a locker, and when I get back there's ALWAYS idle crows. I am usually only gone for about 30-40 seconds. It's ridiculous.

    Doesn't help that I have a medical condition which caused frequent urination....

    *le sigh*

  • Boss
    Boss Member Posts: 13,616

    Holy thread revival!

  • ClogWench
    ClogWench Member Posts: 2,582