Amanda's add-ons

Volfawott

Ok I'm going to get there biggest fish out of the way first then move on to the lower add-ons.

Ultra rares

Amanda's Letter: 

First things first remove the negative effects from this because 12m is not worth it or if you want to keep the negative effects could you at least increase the aura reading to 18m or something.
Losing essentially half your power and and having to use crouch which makes you move slower than nurse is kind of annoying especially if all you get out it is 12 m. 
( Don't get me wrong I love Amanda's letter but for an ultra rare addons it's very map dependent with very little benefits compared to its cons)   

Rule set no 2

Beating a dead horse of this one so make it part of the base kit.

Rework it to actually change up the rules of the bear traps.
For example each time a generator completed whilst an active trap is in play the time of the active traps is reduced by 15 seconds.
This will for survivors to not pop generators when someone has an active trap on and it can be usually countered by 99 gens
( If a trap is not active when a generator is complete it will just activate like normal any other generators completed will reduce the time)

Very rare
I just really have a problem with one add-on and it's category

Amanda's secret

Rework it
In my opinion it is currently worst add on in the entire game.

The information that gives you is pretty pointless you want to spend your time hounding people with bear traps.

It completely removes any patrol capabilities and all the benefits it gives only come into effect once somebody has already removed their trap meaning likelihood is you just going to tunnel them down again and probably slap another trap on to them rinse and repeat

Well I could see a problem with being able to monitor people who are trying to take off their bear traps so I can't exactly think of a rework but in its current state it's practically shooting yourself in the foot

Random add-on nitpicks
This is just some points about things you could change about her other add-ons that don't really need their own section.

Workshop grease and razor wire: Make these affect the size of the skillcheck rather than the frequency of skill checks.

Interlocking razors: Also makes skill checks appear in a similar fashion to madness making them harder to hit.

Jigsaw sketch: you gain an extra bear trap along with the extra jigsaw box.

TAG

Amanda's Letter seems good to me.

I'm not sure how I feel about Rules Set No. 2.  By itself, it seems like it would be a worse Tampered Timer, and with Tampered Timer, it could be too strong.  Either the gens come to a screeching halt for too long because doing them would probably sentence the RBT victim to death, or they don't and the Survivor is basically dead (if the Pig decides to harrass the RBT person), especially with the current RSN2 hypothetically being base kit.

My personal idea for Amanda's Secret is basically just to make it the Amanda equivalent of Freddy's Black Box add-on (Obsession starts with an RBT).

I am probably biased, but I personally don't like the Skill Check add-ons and think they should all be scrapped.  I GUESS your ideas are better than what we currently have.

I personally don't think Jigsaw's Sketch needs to be buffed at all, but if you were to try and modify it like that, I would add a downside to it.  Perhaps I'd cut the timer on Annotated Plan in half and give it to Sketch, so both Sketch and Annotated Plan would add 15 seconds to the clock, and using both together would still result in 30 seconds to the clock but with 6 boxes and an extra RBT.

Volfawott

TAG said:

Amanda's Letter seems good to me.

I'm not sure how I feel about Rules Set No. 2.  By itself, it seems like it would be a worse Tampered Timer, and with Tampered Timer, it could be too strong.  Either the gens come to a screeching halt for too long because doing them would probably sentence the RBT victim to death, or they don't and the Survivor is basically dead (if the Pig decides to harrass the RBT person), especially with the current RSN2 hypothetically being base kit.

My personal idea for Amanda's Secret is basically just to make it the Amanda equivalent of Freddy's Black Box add-on (Obsession starts with an RBT).

I am probably biased, but I personally don't like the Skill Check add-ons and think they should all be scrapped.  I GUESS your ideas are better than what we currently have.

I personally don't think Jigsaw's Sketch needs to be buffed at all, but if you were to try and modify it like that, I would add a downside to it.  Perhaps I'd cut the timer on Annotated Plan in half and give it to Sketch, so both Sketch and Annotated Plan would add 15 seconds to the clock, and using both together would still result in 30 seconds to the clock but with 6 boxes and an extra RBT.

I like the Amanda style black box idea.
It help save the whole pressure of getting a trap on somebody before a generator pops.

I think spreading the time penalty between the sketch and the annotated planes would make the annotated plans seem a lot less of a useless waste of blood points so I'm down for it.

Thanks for the feedback didn't actually expect anyone to really respond to him

TAG

@Aari_Piggy66 said:
TAG said:

Amanda's Letter seems good to me.

I'm not sure how I feel about Rules Set No. 2.  By itself, it seems like it would be a worse Tampered Timer, and with Tampered Timer, it could be too strong.  Either the gens come to a screeching halt for too long because doing them would probably sentence the RBT victim to death, or they don't and the Survivor is basically dead (if the Pig decides to harrass the RBT person), especially with the current RSN2 hypothetically being base kit.

My personal idea for Amanda's Secret is basically just to make it the Amanda equivalent of Freddy's Black Box add-on (Obsession starts with an RBT).

I am probably biased, but I personally don't like the Skill Check add-ons and think they should all be scrapped.  I GUESS your ideas are better than what we currently have.

I personally don't think Jigsaw's Sketch needs to be buffed at all, but if you were to try and modify it like that, I would add a downside to it.  Perhaps I'd cut the timer on Annotated Plan in half and give it to Sketch, so both Sketch and Annotated Plan would add 15 seconds to the clock, and using both together would still result in 30 seconds to the clock but with 6 boxes and an extra RBT.

I like the Amanda style black box idea.
It help save the whole pressure of getting a trap on somebody before a generator pops.

I think spreading the time penalty between the sketch and the annotated planes would make the annotated plans seem a lot less of a useless waste of blood points so I'm down for it.

Thanks for the feedback didn't actually expect anyone to really respond to him

I guess my thoughts on the Jigsaw Box add-on stem from the idea that I think Sketch is fine as-is and Annotated Plan, while usable, can probably be safely buffed. The way I see it, adding an extra box is enough of an upside that I am okay playing with Annotated Plan even though it adds 30 seconds to the clock. Occasionally I even get RBT kills off the Annotated Plan. That being said, I don't think 30 seconds is necessary for a Rare add-on. With that in mind, my preferred idea would be to have three Jigsaw Box add-ons that each add an extra Jigsaw Box: one at Uncommon that adds 30 seconds to the RBT, one at Rare that adds only 15 seconds, and one at Very Rare that doesn't add any time to the clock (part of this stemmed from my desire to scrap the three Skill Check add-ons completely).