My Reasoning on Why Fnaf Belongs In DbD

You may very well be right. My experience with the game was when it was new, and the community around it was awful. (Yes, I know that DBD is a salt mine.)

So, the story as to why everything happens is... interesting, to say the least. I heard people tell it to me, though I had my teeth grit the whole time, long story, but it's not hatred.

It has an interesting premise, but the issue stems from the fact that it's buried and all over the place instead being more laid out.

So, you have to a LOT more searching in order to have a more clearer understanding and it's more obnoxious to go out of your way to learn this info.

I have a significantly easier time understanding RE's lore, Silent Hill's lore, and Evil within, and those games are crazy.

Most of the interesting lore is just buried deep into random events, niche options, and file exploration instead of it being a more laid out path.

If it wasn't such a genuine pain to learn, I think it'd be more welcoming, because right now it's sabotaging it's own lore by putting itself as a Jumpscare game

There's another aspect to this:

Look how... insistent... you and other fnaf fans are about it... Cross your heart, how many would get seriously angry if bhvr would not turn springy into some unbestable godmode killer?

That said, can I ask you a question:

Would you be okay with getting Willy's Wonderland instead of fnaf?

I commend you on a well-presented argument for FNAF's inclusion within the Dead By Daylight universe.

So I admit: I'm not a fan of the FNAF games, as I much prefer psychological horror to jump scares (which I just find funny, rather than scary). However, you are right to say it's not a kiddies game, as there are some darker elements. Also, it would fit Dead By Daylight as would any other horror game, and beyond (I still reckon Carnage from "Spiderman" would fit in well, not to mention characters from other non-horrors).

Absolutely, I would have no problem with its inclusion, were it to be in future. There are franchises I'd prefer over it (e.g.: Alien; The Evil Within; Alan Wake (and its universe, including "Control"); Slumberparty Massacre 2; Terminator; Outlast; X-Files; Batman and The Magnus Archives, to name some), but it's got potential.

Also, there is a potentially interesting power it could have, providing the focus is on FNAF as a whole, and not just SpringTrap:

From what I do remember, FNAF jas the animatronics moving alternatively in some way, so Springtrap would move whilst the others may not, that Fox thing would move whilst others may not, etc.. So as its power, why not have it focus on both having all the animatronics, and the key component to FNAF of surveillance. The player can only control 1 animatronic at a time, but can look through and transport to any of those animatronics at will. Of course, there would be a cooldown or warning for survivors (eyes flashing and electric sparks maybe?), but that power would actually be a new and interesting map-based power to accompany others like Trapper, Hag, Freddy and Demogorgon.

Finally, for anyone who feels it's childish because they're animal costumes, I'd like to remind them the Clown dresses like an elephant, Trapper as some cheesy strongman, and all 4 legion members as a bunny mascot (which the colours still remind me of Teletubbies ... I want Teletubby skins for Legion now! What has become of my life!😭

For Pennywise, there's two directions they could go.

1. Pennywise taken from the end of the Chapter Two movie. It's on the verge of death, and makes a deal with the Entity as a last-ditch grasp at survival. This would explain why it doesn't just kill everybody and overthrow the Entity, because the Entity probably bound it to itself - or whatever justification you could imagine. This would be better for a full chapter.

2. Pennywise taken during its long sleep between the two films. This would be more of a PH-style service to the Entity - instead of being captured by the Entity, Pennywise would participate in trials as of its own free will, like a vacation of sorts. It would also be unique in that it would be the sole killer in the roster who can leave the Entity's realm at any time - it's just there to get a slice of the Entity's great emotion feast. This would be better for a paragraph.

I'd prefer the second one, honestly. I think a full IT chapter would be hard to implement due to the problem of a survivor and designing a sewer map, and this backstory does more justice to Pennywise.

option 3:

they are the same species and pennywise is there cause he's wooing the entity

At this point ignore him- he's a troll that feeds off FNAF hate. The more you talk to him the more he'll keep going, but if you ignore him it's like not watering a flower- it'll wither away and you won't have to worry about it anymore.