I would ######### my entire bodyweight if I ever met Clown (and I say that being a Clown main lol). In game tho I think Oni is the scariest when on his power, as in like I always go "######### ######### #########!!!" whenever I'm trying to reach a point in a loop and I just can't tell for sure if I'm safe or not.

For me, it's either Myers or Oni. Both nailed the character design in opposite ways - Oni is this massive, hulking figure that's all barely restrained fury, where Myers is the motionless shape in the distance that you don't see until it's too late. It's odd, but it's their walk cycles that really do it for me. They don't run - they just walk towards you, with very different types of menace in their gait.

Appearance-wise, og Doc used to freak me out. Oni as an honourable mention for his intimidation factor.

Story-wise, Ghostface, though Doc again as an honourable mention

Power-wise, there isn’t really any killer that full-on ‘scares’ me, beyond Jumpscare Myers, obviously.

Any stealth killer on an inside map without spinechill

Onryo and Jumpscare Myers. Wish there would be more horror in this game.

Myers. It's mostly the anticipation; once I know it's him, I am waiting for the jumpscare to come, even if it never does. If the killer player is any good, it will, though.

A good SM Myers is the closest thing to legit horror this game has.

There's nothing quite like loading into a map and then hearing a Nurse blink.