Do you agree with Otz's Problematic Perks List?

Partially agree. I disliked when they changed NWO for instance for basically guaranteeing a death in the 1v1. Stuff like insidious and knockout will never be healthy in my mind. Boil over can never work with problematic map design. And power struggle makes way to many lose-lose scenarios. Some stuff like the off the record thing. I dont mind it keeps the other effects even with endurance gone. And some disadvantages he wanted to give would be a little to intricate.

I think it's a pretty agreeable list, I can see why he'd have these opinions. Many of these parks are okay by themselves but facilitate really unhealthy plays when paired with other perks or killer powers or even just SWFs. And some of these perks are not okay at all in any context.

Usually agree but this video have a few things that seems weird to me.

Pantimento as problematic? Yeah 30% its strong dont get me wrong, for that survivors need to destroy a totem, you go light it but survivors KNOW where that totem is because it was broken a few moments ago.

Face de darkness? I can understand that pig can use that in a mean way but no way that perk its problematic.

All hexes when broken will have a loud noise notification for survivors to see. Very rarely do you actually have to worry about survivors cleansing dulls for pentimento.

To be frank, watching the entire thing would have taken more effort than I wanted to dedicate, not to mention reflecting on even just the bits I have heard.

So let me only pick my favorite: Rapid Brutality, the perk that barely sees play besides a few low-tier m1 killers like Doctor or Clown -BUT- it may going to be a problem in the future. If it gets buffed. Or if a high-tier m1 killer releases. M-kay. Let's envision hypothetical problems, and complain preemptively! How much more far-sighted that is than complaining about problems we currently have! Let's also nerf No Mither in case suddenly Twins become hip and meta!

It makes me feel OTZ realized that he's popular enough that whatever he says will bring views and revenue, so he just talks whatever. I seriously don't even want to hear what he has to say about Shattered Hope. I'd rather like to remember him as the wise fellow who I got to know when I was a baby-killer.

I'm not knowledgeable enough to comment on all of those perks, but Knockout I agree with for sure. Only ever seen Killers slug but never hook when using this perk. Can end a match very quickly.

Adrenaline is also potentially kinda horrible to play against. I once saw 4 Adrenalines pop at once while playing as Legion. If I saw this in every game, I'd run NOED and I hate NOED. Just spirit crushing, really.

I would maybe add a few to that list:

Dark Devotion, maybe? Don't get me wrong, it's very funny to use (I love using it on my spooky killers like Sadako) but it's pure evil against a Solo Q team. Pretty uncommon too, so it's almost always going to confuse Survivors who face it (stopping them from unhooking, picking up slugs, etc).

Sloppy Butcher is pretty nasty and demoralising to see. Virtually guarantees no heals ever and turns any basic attack Killer into a one hit Killer like Bubba for the rest of the game.

I also think Lethal Pursuer is kinda unhealthy for the game, too. Speeds the game up way too much and when I suspect the Killer has it, I fully expect to earn 5-10k BP max. Usually means the Killer wants to end the game as quickly as possible. Maybe any perk that speeds the game up too much is problematic, to be honest.

He says that because Boons aren't run anymore since Circle of Healing's nerf that it's a completely worthless perk when no one brings Boons (which is now often) so it has little to no reason to exist, and he suggests buffing it to be usable on Dull Totems for one-time aura reads but not synergize with Pentimento.

Here's mine

Edit: I forgot to move deliver to feels bad

The logic just seems unsound for the reasoning.

If I were to broadly paint a brush over the concept of the video, is that the game functions with innate assumptions. Otz's claim (taken to the logical conclusion) is that all perks that change these innate assumptions are bad. That means We'll Make It and Resurgence are bad (by that same logic) because it halves the heal timeframe (Botany as well, but to a lesser extent). That means Enduring/Spirit Fury are bad because you are supposed to reach another major structure loop given a stun, and with Enduring they can't. Similar with Spirit Fury but this de-gods god pallets.

If you go down the list, any perk worth anything changes the innate assumptions. UB allows slugs to pick themselves up, BBQ lets you know where distant Survivors are. All these innate assumptions fall apart with perk, and that is part of the charm of the game. Part of the game (at least to me) is to puzzle out the opposition's perks, and figure out how to outplay/counterplay those perks, while also doing the micro game of chase decisions and macro game of pallet drops and gen pops to outplay your opponent(s).

A second broad brush concept is that perks design should encourage spreading the pressure, not tunneling. Well the problem there is there is no (direct) benefit to spread pressure, and insufficient penalties for targeting someone out early. Since anti-tunnel has been gutted, there is no threat of penalties for tunneling. Since there is no Devour Hook styled mechanic to keep Killers away from hook or BBQ styled spread hook rewards, Killers don't care and hook whoever.

I would address anti-tunnel having teeth by buffing DS a separate way (Killer cannot use power for 5s per remaining gen, and allow for 2 uses), and including the current perk version as basekit. Also anti-tunnel endurance effects no longer cause Deep Wound. This means you could basekit BT into OTR into a Styptic or DH. This would be countered with removing collision on unhooked Survivors until they do a CA. That way a Killer can 'shoulder check' a potential bodyblocker, and if they phase through, the Killer can ignore them and know they are wasting their time.

To encourage spreading hooks, I would reveal the aura of the lowest hooked Survivor for 5s after a hook, and no forms of aura block work while you are the least hooked Survivor (other than Sole Survivor). In the case of ties, the furthest Survivor is revealed. One caveat though is this new basekit effect would never reveal the last Survivor standing, but other effects still could. The Killer also gets a Devour Hope styled speedboost delayed after hook, but this haste ends early on chase/power use/or getting within 12m of a Survivor. This way normal M1 Killers can crossmap safer, but already mobile Killers don't get anything on top of that.

A final idea is to give the 'Ruin treatment' to all gen slowdown perks (and we could honestly buff Ruin back up to 200%). By that I mean all regression/gen slowdown perks are less effective the fewer Survivors alive there are. This could be as harsh as a dead perk after a kill like current Ruin, or something like half as effective after a kill. Pop would regress 15% current after a kill instead of 30% current from Live, and Deadlock lasts 15s instead of live's 30s. This way you take gen slowdown perks because you want them to function while all 4 Survivors are alive, and it wouldn't be possible to giga-regress gens AND turbo-tunnel someone out at the same time. You could bring all lethality perks and not be perk punished by tunneling people out, but gen regression is reduced. You could also 8 hook safely while maintaining all regression perks, then have a final sprint of killing all the Survivors. I would recommend full effectiveness at 4 Survs, half at 3, and dead perk slots at 2 Survs, but if they wanted to especially encourage spreading the pressure the perk slots could be dead at 3 Survs. Making the perk slot dead at 3 would help further against the proxy camp to prevent all unhooks (or the anti-facecamp Kobe system), but I wouldn't recommend this until(/if) we have an epidemic of this new level of 'facecampers' to necessitate such a change.

Absolutely

Eh, if you're the one who cleansed the totem to begin with, it's only slowing the gens down for as long as it takes to get back over there and cleanse it again.

If you aren't the one who cleansed it, that's great too, it means that totem wasn't stolen from you.

Yes but its reasonable to expect survivors to know general totem placement, against newer survivors sure this is a problem. but then thats a matchmaking problem not a pentimento problem

What do you mean when you put a perk on there twice?

Negativity is what gets click$

I'm not going to subject myself to watching an Otz video, can someone tell me how Plot Twist and Deadlock are bugged? They have seemed fine all instabnces I've seen lately

The fact that this guy wants to see pentimento nerfed (one of the last few hexes on a decent state but needs pre work before that and a build supporting it) makes it kinda of a joke.. even if the player has 10k+ hours. STBFL and NWO is no where near close to usage.

This kind of videos and tier lists are a massive red flag specially coming from a big YT such as his.. dev's could be already on the way to nerf pentimento or hell even coup de grace for all we know after watching a video like this..