Solution for genrush
-At first, all remote generators are blocked by the entity from the center of the map for 45 seconds
-With each generator repair, the generator's repair speed decreases by 25% if one survivor is working, and the cooperative's repair speed increases by 8%.
1 generator repaired = 25% slower repairing generators on your own
2 generator repaired = 50% slower repairing generators on your own
3 generator repaired = 75% slower repairing generators on your own
4 generator repaired = 100% slower repairing generators on your own
This is only if there are at least 3 survivors alive
Comments
-
So you want to make 3-gens even more obnoxious to break by making it nigh-impossible to solo-repair one of the last gens?
The game already gets harder the less gens are left (and less Survivors are alive) and you want to make splitting up on gens not viable, the only way to deal with a tight 3-gen?
You mained Dull Merchant before her rework right? Followed the teachings of Cm9i?
Blocking most gens at the beginning will just turn the first minute into locker/hiding simulator (Corrupt would need to be reworked as well). While not an uncommon idea, it would just make the first 45 seconds boring.
The massively reduced gen speed will absolutely destroy variety in Survivor builds, all we'd see are full gen builds or 3 gen perks and Distortion to deal with endgame gens (as even now, 3 Survivors or less can rarely deal with a tight 3-gen without splitting up).
Dull Merchant just got reworked to be slightly less obnoxious during 3-gens (although she still is) and a few Killers can still hold a nasty 3-gen to get kills through attrition, if 3 Survivors are left then as long as one is in chase then the others are basically forced to group up with gen perks/toolboxes and hope the 3rd can run the Killer for the whole gen and that the Killer doesn't have Discordance and simply drops chase as soon as it triggers. And that's assuming the Killer has no gen regression/slowdown perks.
There's a reason the gen-kick meta was vaporized (although they went a tad too far when they nuked almost every gen regression perks, some of them were fine or just needed a small nerf/rework), games would last 35+ minutes on the regular and tight 3-gens could often lead to 1-hour games, and that was before the Prove Thyself and BNP nerf.
Even the "only works when at least 3 are alive" is nonsensical since there's basically no way to duo/solo a tight 3-gen now unless the Killer allows it or gets massively overconfident. The cursed match between Eternal and Cm9i proved it: even a god-tier 4-man SWF on comms can have serious issues with 3-gens depending on perks/Killer (Knight can achieve similar results but has to use a few more brain cells than old Dull Merchant).
Furthermore, this would just widen the gap between SWF and SoloQ since SoloQ can't coordinate repairs (and with solo-repair being basically useless during last gen people would just be running like headless chickens and hope to find a teammate).
I understand that getting gen-rushed can be annoying, but at the end of the day things were made better recently (nerfs to Prove Thyself & BNP, nerfs to healing indirectly slow gens due to needing more time to heal especially after MFT gets nerfed soon etc.) and most of the time the Survivors weren't doing gens with malicious intent, they just did their objective uninterrupted and had lucky spawns.
Are things completely fair? Not really but as long as outliers like Nurse, Dull Merchant, Knight and Blight exists (Killers that can hold disgusting 3-gens easily) then there's a limit to how much gen speed can be nerfed without making the game unplayable for SoloQ/newcomers.
If Survivors don't wanna play the game/new players don't stick around then there's not gonna be any game to play for anyone since there's no way to fully play offline if the servers close. It's the whole reason why basekit Unbreakable/finisher Mori was scrapped: everybody realized it would have just killed the game for Killers and made SWF almost invulnerable (there's literally a video on YT called "Abusing basekit Unbreakable on PTB for one hour" or something like that) and nearly the entire playerbase united to call out how the idea would be poison for the game.
17 -
currently the system you describe is opposite to what dev have. there is a big problem in your idea.
All survivors are encouraged to 99% all gens because you avoid -% repair speed by not completing generators. Assuming nobody completes any generators and your co-op action change from -15% to +8%.
you get following values for repair speed. 1 survivor = 100%, 2 survivors = 108%(216%), 3 survivors = 116%(348%) .
3 survivors co-op a 90 second generator would co-op generator in 25.86 seconds. 90/3.48 is roughly 25 seconds. you could 99 all 7 gens in like 4 minutes of gameplay.
My other comment is that these repair bonuses might as just pause entire game for killer. this idea does not work.
4 -
Most solo queue teams can't manage five gens as it is now. The base values of the gens shouldn't change, as that just makes the matches worse for ALL survivors. Punishing all survivors, including the majority of survivors who are casual, solo queue players is a bad idea. The game already struggles with retaining new players, this would just make it worse.
If you want to weaken gen progression then you should target the things that are much more common in higher level SWF. That being perks like Built to Last or Scavenger combined with optimal toolboxes. That would weaken stronger survivors without kicking every survivor in the teeth.
4 -
These rates are very low. Should be changed like this.
-At first, all generators are blocked by the entity from the center of the map for 45 seconds
-With each generator repair, the generator's repair speed decreases by 50% if one survivor is working, and the cooperative's repair speed increases by 4%.
1 generator repaired = 50% slower repairing generators on your own
2 generator repaired = 100% slower repairing generators on your own
3 generator repaired = 150% slower repairing generators on your own
4 generator repaired = 200% slower repairing generators on your own
This is only if there are at least 2 survivors alive
It's much fairer now
0 -
This would be a 3 gen nightmare. Also the game naturally slows down a lot by the time there are fewer gens left. Since the natural pressure cycle of killer works out this way. If anything these speeds should be in reverse (its why so many suggest basekit corrupt as certain spawns etc can make you lose a few too many gens at the start with little most killers can do).
3 -
I think the way to solve genrushing should be focused on buffing killer's gen slowdown perks that are now useless. Like Hex: Ruin and CoB&OC.
0 -
Well, instead of the penalty increasing the more you repair the generator, we reverse it and the penalty becomes less the more you repair the generators
-0 Generator repaired = 100% slower repairing generators on your own
-1 Generator repaired = penalty reduced to 75%
-2 Generator repaired = penalty reduced to 50%
-3 Generator repaired = penalty reduced to 25%
-4 Generator repaired = penalty reduced to 0%
We must stimulate cooperation, and this is the basic idea in the game, which is that survivors cooperate and help each other
-Cooperative generator repair increases by 8%
-If one generator is repaired, the cooperative’s repair speed will be reduced to 4%
0 -
Wow, you love any Nerf survivor
0 -
I'm a killer main and I do not condone this idea. The problem with gens has nothing to do with the base game. The only problem with gen speeds is the perks on both sides that speed up or slow down gens. Gens are boring. I prefer chase on both sides. I would look for a complete gutting of both sides perks at the same time and more chase oriented perks instead.
4 -
how about buffing killers chase ability so they can pressure gens and down survivors better instead? making gen speeds obnoxiously slow is a band-aid fix that doesn't address the actual issue and just makes survivor gameplay even more of an m1 simulator, which is horrible for game health. the only person your suggestion benefits is a killer player who solely cares about winning. the game will not be more fun to anyone else except that kind of person if this happens (it won't, i'm pretty sure even BHVR realizes your suggestion is overkill, but we're playing devil's advocate here, I guess). making the game more stale is like, the last thing anyone wants or needs right now. we're all just clamoring for the new teaser and hope the gameplay it brings will make matches fun.
1 -
I see that no one objects to the idea of “blocking generators far from the middle of the map for 45 seconds.”
0 -
A nebulous and arbitrary distance says nothing. On, say, Midwitch this would either block nothing or everything, depending on what 'far' means.
Forcing survivors to sit afk for 45 seconds is a pretty massive crutch for killers, especially when there's no snowball prevention like is built into CI.
3 -
play at least 1k hours as a killer and then read this ridiculous post again. There is not anymore such thing as genrushing, however there are new killers who commit to 2 min chases.
3 -
stimulate cooperation would just increase the gap between solo q and swfs, the need less cooperation required from survivors, not more, just the healing nerf make the solo q experience so much worse, now that survivors running to heal, or be healed instead of going to a boon.
also, more genrushing games are more of consequences, of survivors spawning all around the map, rather than purposely gen runshing, standarize the spawns, would be enough, maybe make it so the exit gates always start in opposites sides of the map, with the killer spawing in one, and the survivors in another, making it that even if survivors spawn far away from the killer, the killer always know the sawn location, it would also buff lethal pursuer and corrupt intervention
0 -
I don’t remember nicknames, but a couple of times a year a similar topic comes up and a ton of text starts.
This is a pure maniac player, don’t waste time on him, it’s immediately clear that he came to whine
0 -
Gens are too slow already give survivors 2nd objective which is more interactive and then gens speed can be made faster. Working together should be encouraged. Objective speed should be balanced how many survivors are still alive. Currently 4vs1 is too survivor sided but 3vs1 is too killer sided.
1 -
I recommend creating your own clearly oriented conversation topic, no one will read it here, it’s a dead topic
0
