Marth experiment

It kinda feels like you just made this thread to call Marth a fatass and throw shade @ OP

That only works when they properly seperate the user base.

Take the games such as overwatch, LOL, cs:go etc they don't put newbies in with the best players.

Dbd on the other hand does and resets it each month so it may be 101 in those above but not in this game.

So what I am reading here OP is your asking people for proof when yet you have none yourself. Sounds like to me to me your probably a new player to the game. During these experiements we had it open to people that were notable and wanted to snipe us. Some names for example

Scottjund - Played us during our perkless experiment but refused to play us with perks.

King Dime - One of the OG billies back in the day comparable to Zubat. Played us I think 3 times and he tried to throw EVERYTHING at us each time and couldn't muster the strength.

Multiple Nurses with omega, multi blink etc. This was the killer that gave us the most trouble. Why because it is the nurse nothing else needed there. One of them being Blinkybill. We also faced the Swiftlegend during the anniversary tournament and i think it as a 4 man or 3 man escape.

We faced other billies RyanPez, Griff other notable killers in the community.

The issue with this game is what makes these killers great is NOT that they 4k every game. It is the fact that they can take advantage and punish mistakes of survivors hard and many others that are like you that trash talked the experiment and they stepped up and failed. Here is the thing I don't mention these names to bash but to show that even great killers struggle against survivors with how this game is if there even semi competent. Let me break it down for you.

The object of this game for survivors is to finish 5 generators to power doors. A killer can only chase 1 survivor at a time. A good survivor can easily be chased for 1 min + if they are actually good. So by the time the first hook happens the other 3 survivors are split and are completing or have completed 3 gens. Survivors death timer on hook is 120 seconds. 60 sec per phase. There are a bunch of theories of don't chase the good survivor know when to break off etc the thing is if you facing a good team. That plan doesn't work at all. Now add all of the 2nd chance perks the developers have given survivors to help them along for when the make mistakes. I know because they carried they hell out of us during these experiments. These 2nd chance perks are designed for casuals but rip the game a part at high skill game play.

Edit---

We ran 3 different Experiments, 100 games of no perks or Items but with comms; 100 games of perks and items with No comms. These 2 experiments all we cared about was getting out ASAP and leaving a man behind was fine

Then the 3rd experiment. Comms, Perks and Items. The catch was we actually had to try to save our team mates... Out of 100 games. We only had 25 deaths. This means a killer AVG 1 kill every 4 games against us... We didn't use insta heals or BNP during the making of this experiment.

That name sounds very familiar, my memory due to my health is really bad as of late but I think we did run into him several times. We have competed in many tournaments vs many notable killers. Most of the killers I named above KNEW exactly what was coming and threw kitchen sinks at us and only Scott was able to get 2 of us during our no perk / item experiment, but even with us having nothing. He was stuggling to keep up with the pressure. Just in the end we made a careless mistake and didn't have the perks to protect that mistake. The thing is I am a bad survivor at this game in terms of the chase. I know the basics and the mechanics but my execution is horrible. As many of the survivors I consider strong can pick my survivor apart on what I do wrong. I set out to prove that the objective for survivor is very easily done if survivors CHOOSE to do so and with everything survivors have killers clock is against them before the game even loads

@marth88gaming My issue isn't with your test but how it's being done, you can't take 4 players each with 4-8k hours played and say it's valid against random killers. Against the top tier talent it's much more valid.

Since you'll run into as you even stated in the Macmillan Estate run against that Huntress it was a baby killer. You had quite a few of those matches where the person was obviously doing a daily on a killer they didn't know how to play.

To do a true test you'd need more controls and perhaps take in 4 people with the baseline average hours played of the playerbase. So for example you take 4 people with 600 hours played.

Those 4 people play 100 games with the same rules you followed perkless and addonless and gen rush only. Then take say 4 with 1k hours etc and repeat the process and from there you'd have a much better data set.

But again given the pipping system is still too easy a lot of killer will just get hosed since even now the skill level of some is boosted. Perhaps doing a kyf type thing would work better once dedicated servers come out.

Then you have the simple fact that your chances of facing an actual depip type squad in normal non experimental gameplay is slim. The mythical swat teams as they're called are few and far between.