Secret Offerings (They aren't a SECRET anymore)

Agreed. Simple fix that would make a big difference . . until the first mori maybe lol. Really, I think secret offerings should be an unknown secret!

All this would do is make people DC when the first guy gets mori'd instead of at the start of the trial. I don't see the point in completely hiding the offering, sometimes it's good to know that killer DOES NOT have a mori.

What they need to do is add more secret offerings so you don't know what was offered. Only secret offerings for killer are mori's and shroud, and only secret offerings for surv are shrouds. So when you see them it's a pretty good guess what it is. If there were more secret offerings you wouldn't be able to guess it as easily.

Delfador said:

@Nickenzie said:
PinkEricka said:

They should add more new offering in. I’m so tired of seeing the same ones tbh.

@PinkEricka
Secret Offerings: (Ultra Rare: Survivor)

Iridescent Quality Parts:
-Generators will spawn as far as possible from each other.
-Secret

Memorial Flowers:
-The hatch will spawn into the trial faster than normal (AKA you don't need to do as many generators to spawn in the hatch).
-Secret

Secret Offerings: (Ultra Rare: Killer)

Withered Flowers:
-The hatch will not spawn into the trial.
-Secret

Lost Toolbox:
-Generators will spawn closer together than normal.
-Secret

If you add withered flowers, you will welcome free hostage scenarios especially with your new suggestion.

Basically, I will look for the hatch that didn't spawn in the entire match God knows how much.

BigBubs said:

Will only benefit killers since survivor's secret offerings are not even useful.
Until they make some new secret offerings for survivors, or change some of the current ones into secret, I'm against this idea.

@Nickenzie said:
Doc_W__HOLLIDAY said:

thesuicidefox said:

All this would do is make people DC when the first guy gets mori'd instead of at the start of the trial. I don't see the point in completely hiding the offering, sometimes it's good to know that killer DOES NOT have a mori.

What they need to do is add more secret offerings so you don't know what was offered. Only secret offerings for killer are mori's and shroud, and only secret offerings for surv are shrouds. So when you see them it's a pretty good guess what it is. If there were more secret offerings you wouldn't be able to guess it as easily.

People would still DC as soon as they seen the secret offering. 

This here basically, I would rather have survivors DC later than sooner and if a lot of offerings were secrets, they will still DC when the survivor first is mori'd anyways. Therefore, it's still the same case to be honest @thesuicidefox.

A DC is a DC, it really doesn't matter when it happens. The only time it doesn't matter is if the guy is on last hook or something because they are already dead at the point (though it can deny a killer BBQ aura or HL tokens for example so in some cases it can still be detrimental to the game).

Besides the fact I almost never see someone DC when killer offers a mori, all you do by making secret offerings completely hidden is screwing over honest players. If you don't DC then you would want to know killer MIGHT have a mori. That is very important information as it changes surv tactics. They will be more immersed after a hook (ie. less gen rushing) and play more scared in a chase (ie. they could waste pallets or sandbag another surv to stay alive). It would be seriously stupid if you all of sudden get mori'd, with absolutely no warning, because you have no way to counter play.

Just think about how stupid it is to get DS'ed by a non-obsession, that's basically the same thing but for killers now. And no, I'm not saying non-obsession DS is okay by any means, in fact I've said many times elsewhere that only the obsession should be able to even use DS for this exact reason.

It's cheesey design, period.

You want to stop players from DC'ing because of a secret offering? PUNISH DC'S HARDER! That makes way more sense, since people will DC for literally anything nowadays.

@Nickenzie said:
thesuicidefox said:

@Nickenzie said:

Doc_W__HOLLIDAY said:

thesuicidefox said:

All this would do is make people DC when the first guy gets mori'd instead of at the start of the trial. I don't see the point in completely hiding the offering, sometimes it's good to know that killer DOES NOT have a mori.

What they need to do is add more secret offerings so you don't know what was offered. Only secret offerings for killer are mori's and shroud, and only secret offerings for surv are shrouds. So when you see them it's a pretty good guess what it is. If there were more secret offerings you wouldn't be able to guess it as easily.



People would still DC as soon as they seen the secret offering. 

This here basically, I would rather have survivors DC later than sooner and if a lot of offerings were secrets, they will still DC when the survivor first is mori'd anyways. Therefore, it's still the same case to be honest @thesuicidefox.

A DC is a DC, it really doesn't matter when it happens. The only time it doesn't matter is if the guy is on last hook or something because they are already dead at the point (though it can deny a killer BBQ aura or HL tokens for example so in some cases it can still be detrimental to the game).

Besides the fact I almost never see someone DC when killer offers a mori, all you do by making secret offerings completely hidden is screwing over honest players. If you don't DC then you would want to know killer MIGHT have a mori. That is very important information as it changes surv tactics. They will be more immersed after a hook (ie. less gen rushing) and play more scared in a chase (ie. they could waste pallets or sandbag another surv to stay alive). It would be seriously stupid if you all of sudden get mori'd, with absolutely no warning, because you have no way to counter play.

Just think about how stupid it is to get DS'ed by a non-obsession, that's basically the same thing but for killers now. And no, I'm not saying non-obsession DS is okay by any means, in fact I've said many times elsewhere that only the obsession should be able to even use DS for this exact reason.

It's cheesey design, period.

You want to stop players from DC'ing because of a secret offering? PUNISH DC'S HARDER! That makes way more sense, since people will DC for literally anything nowadays.

@thesuicidefox
Honestly speaking, the purpose of this thread is make secret offerings better since they aren't a secret anymore. However, since DCs will be more of a problem then they do need to punish DC'ing harder. Furthermore, If survivors wanna be a sore loser and DC over a mori then they can suit themselves because they will get banned eventually. I been annoyed by moris before but I never EVER DC'd because I been mori'd, it's just unsportsmanlike and I'm not that type of player.

They aren't secret because there isn't enough secret options to make it any sort of guessing game. Killer has 4 secret options (excluding splinters). 3 of them are mori, and 1 is a shroud. Survivors have 3, all shrouds. Where is the guessing game? There is none. Make more secret offerings for each side, that would make secret offerings better because now you are trying to figure out what was offered.

@NMCKE offering to give the ruin effect for 2 minutes.