NOED is really bad game design
I know it. You know it. The devs know it. How about we all just admit it?
Playing in the green ranks and it's literally carrying every single killer there. Guess this is the easy way to balance the game. Killers are struggling? oh well just give them a perk to make up for it.
Now before people cry "ClEaNsE tHe ToTUmZ", how about the devs actually make that viable for single player by giving some notification of when dull totems are destroyed? or after doing 4 am I meant to run around the map searching every nook and cranny just to be sure?
God I hate this game sometimes. NOED and DS, 2 perks that change the entire outcome of the match. Great game design right there.
Comments
-
Bad game design for bad survivors.7
-
@Vietfox said:
Bad game design for bad survivors.yawn
How much does Behaviour pay you to defend all of their decisions?
Bad game design is not giving surviors any clue as to how is cleansing totems are how many are cleansed. Lets just have all 4 survivors running around looking for 5 totems, I'm sure we'll manage to get the gens done too.
9 -
3
2
1
Cleanse totems.7 -
@Eveline said:
3
2
1Cleanse totems.
Is this where I get told to bring small game? allow me to slot it in with the other 15 perks killers tell me to bring.
1 hex that requires 5 totems to be cleansed, and doesn't have a requirement to activate it unlike Devour hope....yeah that's not OP at all.
6 -
Lol I am just saying everyone here will tell you that.1
-
The_Crusader said:
@Vietfox said:
Bad game design for bad survivors.yawn
How much does Behaviour pay you to defend all of their decisions?
Bad game design is not giving surviors any clue as to how is cleansing totems are how many are cleansed. Lets just have all 4 survivors running around looking for 5 totems, I'm sure we'll manage to get the gens done too.
Noed can be negated before it triggers, if survivors refuse to counter it then it's on them.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?6 -
Killers - defend garbage like NOED, camping and tunneling which encourages people to play SWF
Also killers - Cry about SWF and lobby dodge.
11 -
The_Crusader said:
@Eveline said:
3
2
1Cleanse totems.
Is this where I get told to bring small game? allow me to slot it in with the other 15 perks killers tell me to bring.
Build around your needs/strenghts/weaknesses and use the skills to deal with the rest. Don't expect to counter everything with perks.2 -
Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:
@Vietfox said:
Bad game design for bad survivors.yawn
How much does Behaviour pay you to defend all of their decisions?
Bad game design is not giving surviors any clue as to how is cleansing totems are how many are cleansed. Lets just have all 4 survivors running around looking for 5 totems, I'm sure we'll manage to get the gens done too.
Noed can be negated before it triggers, if survivors refuse to counter it then it's on them.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
Pretty much the entire community has been salty about DS and NOED for years now. The entire game can come down to a battle between those 2 perks sometimes it's ridiculous.
Ok I'll do totems and swf then. Oh wait no we cant get a game then because killers lobby dodge knowing their precious totems will be gone!
Is it too much to ######### ask for an indication of how many totems are actually cleansed? So that when im running around looking for them I know if im wasting my time or not?3 -
A survivor-sided opinion?! blasphemy!5
-
I wholeheartedly agree.
5 -
The_Crusader said:Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:
@Vietfox said:
Bad game design for bad survivors.yawn
How much does Behaviour pay you to defend all of their decisions?
Bad game design is not giving surviors any clue as to how is cleansing totems are how many are cleansed. Lets just have all 4 survivors running around looking for 5 totems, I'm sure we'll manage to get the gens done too.
Noed can be negated before it triggers, if survivors refuse to counter it then it's on them.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
Pretty much the entire community has been salty about DS and NOED for years now. The entire game can come down to a battle between those 2 perks sometimes it's ridiculous.
Ok I'll do totems and swf then. Oh wait no we cant get a game then because killers lobby dodge knowing their precious totems will be gone!
Is it too much to [BAD WORD] ask for an indication of how many totems are actually cleansed? So that when im running around looking for them I know if im wasting my time or not?
Just because part of the community complain about something doesnt mean they are right. Actually most of them are people who refuse to adapt and instead want the game to be changed according to their will.3 -
@JanTheMan said:A survivor-sided opinion?! blasphemy!4
-
I personally disagree. NOED is an "endgame" perk. The Endgame perks are supposed to be more powerfull then during the match perks. NOED is quite significant part of endgame builds for killers that don't have one hit abilities like Pig or Freddy so removing it would really hurt already small diversity of builds.
I agree that it can single handely demolish some solo survivor games but it's overall powerlevel isn't that high if survivors play smart. Yes it probably should get some more nerfs but only in a way that won't render that perk useless.We could for example give it some more disadvantages that make it more revelling to survivors that killer has NOED so that they can do totems. Also adding number of not cleased totems to Small game could help too.
0 -
We shouldn't have a tracker on totems. A large benefit of them is survivors searching instead of doing the gens. So as a solo if your not willing to look, deal with it until a gate is open. Its not like killers have a huge window to use this extremely flimsy perk, about a minute at best if they also had remember me.3
-
Vietfox said:Bad game design for bad survivors.3
-
The_Crusader said:
Killers - defend garbage like NOED, camping and tunneling which encourages people to play SWF
Also killers - Cry about SWF and lobby dodge.
1 -
There is one issue tho. Some games are hard that people just try to survive and can't focus on totems at all. Then after all hard work noed pops and people go down instantly. It can be a game changer, turn the tables around, so it can be very powerful especially against fast killers.1
-
HavelmomDaS1 said:Vietfox said:Bad game design for bad survivors.
If I've cleansed 4 totems, do I assume that surely 1 of the othrr 3 survivors has done the last? Or do I keep on looking? Who knows!
Also 1 survivor off gens for a few minutes just to counter 1 perk. Seems balanced...
I'll repeat it again, NOED and DS can affect the entire outcome of a game. 1 perk alone on each sife should not be able to do that.2 -
Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:
@Vietfox said:
Bad game design for bad survivors.yawn
How much does Behaviour pay you to defend all of their decisions?
Bad game design is not giving surviors any clue as to how is cleansing totems are how many are cleansed. Lets just have all 4 survivors running around looking for 5 totems, I'm sure we'll manage to get the gens done too.
Noed can be negated before it triggers, if survivors refuse to counter it then it's on them.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
Pretty much the entire community has been salty about DS and NOED for years now. The entire game can come down to a battle between those 2 perks sometimes it's ridiculous.
Ok I'll do totems and swf then. Oh wait no we cant get a game then because killers lobby dodge knowing their precious totems will be gone!
Is it too much to [BAD WORD] ask for an indication of how many totems are actually cleansed? So that when im running around looking for them I know if im wasting my time or not?
Just because part of the community complain about something doesnt mean they are right. Actually most of them are people who refuse to adapt and instead want the game to be changed according to their will.3 -
Eveline said:There is one issue tho. Some games are hard that people just try to survive and can't focus on totems at all. Then after all hard work noed pops and people go down instantly. It can be a game changer, turn the tables around, so it can be very powerful especially against fast killers.
Yet killers cry survivors need more objectives just because some SWF stomped them.0 -
@HavelmomDaS1 said:@Vietfox said:Bad game design for bad survivors.
I adapt my playstyle and build according to how most players (both killers and survivors) work, and works pretty damn well.
If i can do it anyone else can do it as well, just requires some brain.0 -
HavelmomDaS1 said:The_Crusader said:
Killers - defend garbage like NOED, camping and tunneling which encourages people to play SWF
Also killers - Cry about SWF and lobby dodge.
2 -
When playing survivor, one of my biggest gripes is that I'll cleanse four dull totems, then still get downed by NOED and be the only survivor to die in the match. It sucks how often that happens.
However, the end game in DbD is broken right now. As killer, I've used NOED just to encourage survivors to get off the map at the end of the game. Once an exit gate is open, the only things that really put fear in survivors are NOED, Blood Warden, and Rancor. The perks have to be strong because they're there to counter one of the most powerful things in the game: an open exit gate.
Dull totems are there as a secondary objective to get survivors to do something other than gens, giving killers more time, something they often desperately need in this game. The survivors shouldn't know whether or not a killer has it; the point is to do dull totems regardless just in case. However, for solo survivors like me who cleanse four dull totems and get screwed anyway, it would be nice if there were something to help, like Small Game showing the number of totems left on the map. There have been times when I've done two full trips all over the map looking for the fifth totem, but Small Game never proc'd so I had to assume someone else had cleansed it. I am still curious where that last totem was in those matches.
3 -
@HavelmomDaS1 said:@Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:
@Vietfox said:
Bad game design for bad survivors.yawn
How much does Behaviour pay you to defend all of their decisions?
Bad game design is not giving surviors any clue as to how is cleansing totems are how many are cleansed. Lets just have all 4 survivors running around looking for 5 totems, I'm sure we'll manage to get the gens done too.
Noed can be negated before it triggers, if survivors refuse to counter it then it's on them.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
Pretty much the entire community has been salty about DS and NOED for years now. The entire game can come down to a battle between those 2 perks sometimes it's ridiculous.
Ok I'll do totems and swf then. Oh wait no we cant get a game then because killers lobby dodge knowing their precious totems will be gone!
Is it too much to [BAD WORD] ask for an indication of how many totems are actually cleansed? So that when im running around looking for them I know if im wasting my time or not?
Just because part of the community complain about something doesnt mean they are right. Actually most of them are people who refuse to adapt and instead want the game to be changed according to their will.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
0 -
NOED is fine. Destroy the totems.
1 -
@TragicSolitude
Same here. Do 4, can't see the last, assume that surely the other 3 survivors have managed to do 1 totem between them....but nope.
I feel like I'm banging my head against a brick wall here. Let me explain...
NOED is harsh on solo survivors but it means nothing to 3/4 man SWF.
Want an indication of when a dull totem is cleansed? - killers won't have it.
Want some form of Kindred as a baseline ability? - killers won't have it
Yet they insist SWF is unfair and they want it removed, yet won't allow anything to make solo survivor more enjoyable.
How about you agree to give little quality of life upgrades for solo survivors so that swf crews can hop on solo and feel they aren't at a disadvantage and might play more solo games?
Killer mains just want everything swung in their favour.2 -
Vietfox said:@HavelmomDaS1 said:@Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:
@Vietfox said:
Bad game design for bad survivors.yawn
How much does Behaviour pay you to defend all of their decisions?
Bad game design is not giving surviors any clue as to how is cleansing totems are how many are cleansed. Lets just have all 4 survivors running around looking for 5 totems, I'm sure we'll manage to get the gens done too.
Noed can be negated before it triggers, if survivors refuse to counter it then it's on them.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
Pretty much the entire community has been salty about DS and NOED for years now. The entire game can come down to a battle between those 2 perks sometimes it's ridiculous.
Ok I'll do totems and swf then. Oh wait no we cant get a game then because killers lobby dodge knowing their precious totems will be gone!
Is it too much to [BAD WORD] ask for an indication of how many totems are actually cleansed? So that when im running around looking for them I know if im wasting my time or not?
Just because part of the community complain about something doesnt mean they are right. Actually most of them are people who refuse to adapt and instead want the game to be changed according to their will.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
Great game balance idea. You should apply for a job on the team.1 -
The_Crusader said:Vietfox said:@HavelmomDaS1 said:@Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:
@Vietfox said:
Bad game design for bad survivors.yawn
How much does Behaviour pay you to defend all of their decisions?
Bad game design is not giving surviors any clue as to how is cleansing totems are how many are cleansed. Lets just have all 4 survivors running around looking for 5 totems, I'm sure we'll manage to get the gens done too.
Noed can be negated before it triggers, if survivors refuse to counter it then it's on them.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
Pretty much the entire community has been salty about DS and NOED for years now. The entire game can come down to a battle between those 2 perks sometimes it's ridiculous.
Ok I'll do totems and swf then. Oh wait no we cant get a game then because killers lobby dodge knowing their precious totems will be gone!
Is it too much to [BAD WORD] ask for an indication of how many totems are actually cleansed? So that when im running around looking for them I know if im wasting my time or not?
Just because part of the community complain about something doesnt mean they are right. Actually most of them are people who refuse to adapt and instead want the game to be changed according to their will.
Yeah, sometimes the killer is good at keeping the map pressure and you are forced to do gens instead of totems, so what?
Great game balance idea. You should apply for a job on the team.2 -
Killers - just cleanse totems
Also killers - No solo players can't have an indication of how many have been done by other players
Also also killers - Devs hide totems better please.
*Rolls eyes*3 -
Crusader are you on pc or console and which rank?0
-
You can use a map. Best way for this item. And I think NOED is fine.
2 -
"How about we all just admit it"
How about you don't tell me what to admit, and stop complaining about what people run. Let me break it down for you, back then, NOED used to be a permanent thing, and due to people complaining, it was then nerfed to where it was only active for a certain duration. Like Bloodwarden is now, then it received another update to what it is now. And it is probably the most balanced thing in the game.
NOED can be easily countered by breaking totems, everyone knows this, but everyone is too busy trying to do objectives that they forgot that totems are a secondary objective in the game. When you break all the totems on the map, you don't have to worry about NOED.
This post was simply made because you either
A. Died to NOED
B. One of your friends (that is if you played with any) died to it and you got madEither one of those choices, there is no way you just decided to make this post out of the blue like that.
3 -
The_Crusader said:Killers - just cleanse totems
Also killers - No solo players can't have an indication of how many have been done by other players
Also also killers - Devs hide totems better please.
*Rolls eyes*0 -
Eveline said:Crusader are you on pc or console and which rank?
It sucks.0 -
Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:Killers - just cleanse totems
Also killers - No solo players can't have an indication of how many have been done by other players
Also also killers - Devs hide totems better please.
*Rolls eyes*
@Detective_Jonathan Wow I see why they call you detective now you really figured me out
1 -
The_Crusader said:Eveline said:Crusader are you on pc or console and which rank?1
-
@Vietfox said:
The_Crusader said:
Eveline said:Crusader are you on pc or console and which rank?
I'm stuck in green ranks
^ Problem spotted
This
1 -
Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:Eveline said:Crusader are you on pc or console and which rank?
Guess I deserve to have teammates who dont cleanse totems?
Again, all this rhetoric does is encourage swf play, and then you know how much salt that causes on here.1 -
The_Crusader said:Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:Killers - just cleanse totems
Also killers - No solo players can't have an indication of how many have been done by other players
Also also killers - Devs hide totems better please.
*Rolls eyes*0 -
@The_Crusader said:
Killers - just cleanse totemsAlso killers - No solo players can't have an indication of how many have been done by other players
Also also killers - Devs hide totems better please.
Rolls eyes
I play both survivor and killer equally. I usually don't even use NOED on my killers. NOED is fine.
2 -
Just be patient and try to do everything a little bit. When you get to the red ranks you will face obstacles again but at least people are just ######### not completely braindead lol.1
-
The_Crusader said:@TragicSolitude
Same here. Do 4, can't see the last, assume that surely the other 3 survivors have managed to do 1 totem between them....but nope.
I feel like I'm banging my head against a brick wall here. Let me explain...
NOED is harsh on solo survivors but it means nothing to 3/4 man SWF.
Want an indication of when a dull totem is cleansed? - killers won't have it.
Want some form of Kindred as a baseline ability? - killers won't have it
Yet they insist SWF is unfair and they want it removed, yet won't allow anything to make solo survivor more enjoyable.
How about you agree to give little quality of life upgrades for solo survivors so that swf crews can hop on solo and feel they aren't at a disadvantage and might play more solo games?
Killer mains just want everything swung in their favour.
Yeah exactly, some Killer mains completely lost their mind because of SWF (I don't blame them, it's really stressful) and immediately disagree with everything which buffs solo survivors. But they forget that solos aren't the survivors who are making their games so frustrating. Solos need some special love and it's really time for that. That's just my opinion. Closing the gap is one important and healthy step for future balancing.4 -
The_Crusader said:Vietfox said:The_Crusader said:Eveline said:Crusader are you on pc or console and which rank?
Guess I deserve to have teammates who dont cleanse totems?
Again, all this rhetoric does is encourage swf play, and then you know how much salt that causes on here.0 -
@Eveline I forgot how much green ranks blow. Its harder to pip too ironically because there is less action. At red ranks every game was hectic snd full of unhooks and chases.
@HavelmomDaS1 Glad to see someone gets it. Killers moan about swf but veto any QOL upgrades to solo survivors. They just don't get that they can't have it both ways.
3 -
@Eveline said:
Lavernne said:You can use a map. Best way for this item. And I think NOED is fine.
You can't use anything because killers dodge lobbies.
thats old. In the past, almost every killer has been dodged with just one item in the lobby. But now rare dodges.
0 -
I mean like. It’s honestly the only way to do it. Plus you get a small amount of BPs for it. Whenever I see totems I always try to get rid of a possible NOED because it seems lots of killers seem to be running it a lot.0
-
@The_Crusader said:
@TragicSolitudeSame here. Do 4, can't see the last, assume that surely the other 3 survivors have managed to do 1 totem between them....but nope.
I feel like I'm banging my head against a brick wall here. Let me explain...
NOED is harsh on solo survivors but it means nothing to 3/4 man SWF.
Want an indication of when a dull totem is cleansed? - killers won't have it.
Want some form of Kindred as a baseline ability? - killers won't have it
Yet they insist SWF is unfair and they want it removed, yet won't allow anything to make solo survivor more enjoyable.
How about you agree to give little quality of life upgrades for solo survivors so that swf crews can hop on solo and feel they aren't at a disadvantage and might play more solo games?
Killer mains just want everything swung in their favour.
Some form of Kindred as a baseline ability would be so nice. It's stupid that I can see survivors' auras while I'm hooked, which does me little to no good, but they can't see each others' auras, something that would benefit me (and them) way more than me watching them do gens or crouch around. Showing survivors' auras to each other should be baseline and Kindred should be altered so that each tier just shows the killer's aura within a certain distance of the hook. Right now, Kindred tier 1 is completely useless, anyway, and it makes no sense that it even exists.
Sorry if that's off topic.
But yes, Small Game at least should tell the survivor running it how many hex/dull totems are left on the map. The perk is useful for finding totems and avoiding traps, but it's useless for countering NOED.
1 -
Look here's the thing...
The devs insist survivors are dying, despite killers moaning that the game is too hard. The stats show that the game is actually in the killers favour right now. They're going to buff survivors eventually and I can already sense the salt on these forums when that happens.
However we've all seen those games where they wouldn't be a single kill if it wasn't for NOED. If NOED was removed and the stats swung back in the survivors favour then killers could have these buffs they keep asking for.
It's in the killers best interests to not have so much revolve around this one perk.
1