Massive List of Killer Perk Changes

Hex: Lullaby

This seems fair, but with this change would we get tokens from letting people make free saves or would the tokens still be on hooks?

Blood Warden

I only say 30 because at 15 I don't think it would be good enough that anyone would actually run it. I know I wouldn't.

We can test the 30 on PTB tho.

Hex: The Third Seal

Woah, disable ALL of the survivor perks while it's up? That might be too strong lol

If we added the hiding of duration on items to everything else that might just be enough, I like that.

Mad Grit

The problem is if we made that change were basically just running Iron Grasp in a sense. They start to be overlapping in doing almost the same thing.

Corrupt Intervention

Now THIS I like. I'll update my original post.

Remember Me

Well my original change was 8 seconds per obsession hit with a max of 32 seconds added. That may seem like a lot added, but remember it has a high requirement of getting lots of hits on the obsession which might not even happen and it's a completely dead perk all game. So you're running a 3 perk game to get a boost at end game.

NOED 

That's understandable. More of an issue for how it will affect low ranks.

Unrelenting 

I like that. Would it still also have the effect of ignoring hit blocker effects like BT or MoM?

Hex: Lullaby

Sounds good to me, I'll update my post

Hex: The Third Seal

Yeah I think the little extra addition of the item hiding was just the right amount more it would need. Will update my post.

Mad Grit

I feel like one would just overshadow the other. It's w/e though

Unrelenting 

Seems good, post updated.

Some perks entire ideas were altered after community feedback

You missed this part of the new perk.

"Now that we have the EGC this should block the exit gate switches instead of the gate itself."

So the EGC kill would never actually happen.

Also, that situation in the video is HIGHLY situational and is VERY rarely happening. The majority of the matches the perk won't even end up activating or it will simply be waited out while they just hide with its current iteration.

Coulrophobia

That would be completely and utterly broken.

Thanatophobia

That's basically the changes I was making.

Fire Up -

I could see including hooks for tokens.

Predator

That would be completely broken as well.

Stridor

That would be a nice change. Although I'd rather have the breathing be louder than adding footsteps since it would equate to the same thing but still fit the perk thematically.

Shadowborn

I like the idea.

Beast of Prey

That might be too much

Mad Grit

Protection hits aren't realistically happening that much to begin with and even if it did block them you are losing an entire perk slot for it. Applying Deep Wounds would be trash. Deep Wounds in its current iteration is a meaningless effect. No one would use this perk if that was its change.

Firstly, it's not necroing as it's only a post from like a day ago.

Secondly, it is allowed and not against the forums Terms of Service.

It's a thread with significant changes the game needs.

Ah my mistake bumping is after all. In light of that all "bump" posts were removed and no further "bumps" will be made.

Now my discussion is entirely in line with community guidelines per this post.

You can kindly move on now.

You literally came in here to complain about the "bumps" on my post...i mean common..really? That's quite petty and is why it would be annoying to most anyone.

"if I actually cared I would of reported the post"

You called attention to a forum moderator to come look at my post by @ ing him..that''s basically reporting my discussion and your being coy about that.

"And before you say "but why did you put peanits in your post" because I just want his thoughts on it, I wasn't trying to get you warned for it."

To say this is being disingenuous. You quoted the forums guidelines so you knew very clearly what is and isn't against Terms of Service, so to say you "just wanted his thoughts on it" is a complete cop out. You know exactly what you were doing. There was no "thoughts" to give. It's quite black and white.

I accept the apology and it's alright.

Well to be honest alot of what you've written has been in broken English. I didn't say that because I didn't want to be offensive. There have been many structural and grammatical errors which made it hard to understand what you were saying.

I understand your point on the perk though and I think it's a good idea.

If it was better more people would run it, they don't. There's a reason for this. The time it lasts is pretty irrelevant so even if they increased it to 3 minutes it would still be bad because the time it lasts isn't the issue. The time it lasts doesn't matter because good survivors will simply do nothing and wait it out. It essentially just keeps you in a waiting lobby for another 2 minutes before the game can actually start.

"I mean if they are waiting it out that means they are not doing anything that allows you ample time to find someone"

This isn't the case. Against good survivors you aren't finding anyone if they aren't trying to do gens.

"force the survivors to waste time"

The time they waste here is irrelevant because the killer isn't gaining anything out of the time because he isn't finding anyone.

Yes you can find someone and make use of that time against potato survivors but I'm referencing if you're going against good survivors that know what they're doing. Finding survivors that are trying to do an objective is much easier than finding survivors not doing objectives that are just creeping around the outside of the map.

Well technically isn't that the exact same thing? The perk can't even activate until the gates have been opened and the EGC has started, so its current 60 second timer and "until 40/50/60 seconds have elapsed within the collapse timer" are "almost" the same thing. The only difference being that its time would negate the slow down from a hooked or downed survivor.

That still wouldn't really prevent them from just hiding and that still leaves a lot of time on the EGC for it not to really matter much.