SolarFoxVB

Now I'm just thinking about Bubba and the Hag sitting in the swamp and playing a card game. Then Bubba has a tantrum when he loses. Like always. Then the Hag just facepalms.

I know it's more of an easter egg to have Alex in the name Alex's Toolbox, but I was hoping that, since the name was used, that Alex could be an unused or maybe even used character. I'd just like to hear more about Alex in the game.

Poor Adam. He should get more for being a trained pebble thrower. He's got 2 pretty okay perks, but that pebble though. MMMM. I love throwing pebbles at killers as they stare at me. (Not dissing Adam, I just think his perks are a little on the meh side)

Maybe you could give the survivor using it some bonus at the start of the game, like action or movement speed

I'm confused about one part. At half power, do basic attacks burn AND injure survivors or just burn them?

There is only one way to live

I agree wholeheartedly. What you said about a save from a chainsaw did remind me of a swf save a friend of mine did. It was the end of the game with all but one of the gens done. I was being chainsaw camped by a Bubba and everyone else was still alive. My friend, who was working on the last gen with a random, decided to…

This is a very interesting power. Of course, the survivor that the Puppeteer is chasing will always know where the killer is during the chase, but a survivor not knowing where he or she is going is very detrimental. I'm still not sure how I feel about not being able to see where one is going, but I have to admit that it is…

"Say hello to my medium-sized friend!"

How about Smite? I only started playing it recently because of the new crossover with RWBY, and I started rewatching that series because of it. Fantastic show.

@smallfry05 That is the only reason Legion is low tier. TOTALLY not because people don't like the way his ability works.

Oni is such a Chad

Nevermind. Just a big dummy. I found it.

These are some pretty nice ideas. I only have 2 bits of criticism for you. The only problem I can see is that Echolocation would be used less in higher tiers due to survivors' skills at locating the killer. I know myself that I can usually distinguish what area the killer is in, so I would probably not use it. However, I…

I like the idea. You obviously put a lot of hard work and thought into this. Though I'm quite sure this won't make it into the game (and I'm sure you are too by the (Joke) part of the title), I think we could use a killer that can change to different people/forms from an intractable object in the same game. Now for some…

Great job coming up with all of this! it sounds very thought out and organized and fairly balanced. I was going to mention a critique I thought of while looking at the percent for bloodlust-gain speed paired with Gaias Wreath, but after looking back at how long it takes to get bloodlust, the bloodlust move speed bonuses,…

@Karaage In my time that I've played DbD, I've found that I only ever keep 2 perks on every build and I have to search for SOMETHING for the other 2. This would fill up that something perfectly if I only wanted to deal with chases (The 2 perks are Adrenaline and Self-Care. I've gotten used to not using exhaustion perks). I…

Just found out today that Left Behind was changed. I probably shouldn't make posts about changing perks while I've been grounded for long enough for an update or two

Welp, I should probably not post on stuff when I'm grounded then. Completely in the dark on perk changes

Also, just thought this. This would make a great cover-up perk for Bill's Left Behind, because it's basically useless now. Gen speed when last alive? Just close the hatch.

Maybe you could reduce how much speed you lose and the amount of blood, but only be able to carry somebody when you are healthy. If injured, you have to drag them, which would be loud, slower, and leave the same amount of blood as crawling.

From my perspective, I believe Gambler's luck is far too overpowered. All you need to have a 100% chance of a great skill check is 3 people with Up the Ante 3 and Gambler's Luck 2, because 3 Up the Ante 3's is 36% luck, which, multiplied by 2 then added to the 30%, leads to the 100% chance. There would need to be a cap or…

I actually really like this perk idea, though I would not recommend it on higher-level matches. It is very easy to notice once one has 2 tokens, because of the effects that it gives being more unique. This balances the totem fairly well, allowing for decent use of it on either side.

I think that maybe instead of stalking, there should be a way to refill the bombs, such as going to a highlighted box on the map. Also, I have a question about the different colored skill checks. If you just let them pass, does nothing happen, or is it a failed skill check no matter what you do? I believe that there should…

These sound pretty good to me, but the movement speed increase for Determined Warrior sounds a little too strong. Maybe 2/3.5/5?

I just had a neat idea. The arm should not be able to point to survivors you have already hooked before, and the second arm could come out after all the survivors have been hooked once. There could be some buff to take the place of the 2 hook increase.

True, I just don't think that he would be out of chases very often when he has the first arm out.

Also, about the perks, shouldn't they be mostly geared towards the killer they were made for? It seems like Fear of the Void would be a bit counteracted by the first arm.

Yay! I did a thing!

I really like what you were going for with this killer, but I'm a little turned off by the arm that points to the nearest survivor. From my point of view, it seems a little broken for it to lead you to survivors AND upgrade later on. Maybe you could have the arm evolve into the second arm when the second one would usually…

I think that the bloodlust speed would be okay if the effect were something other than an instadown, like maybe a hindered effect with a small timer. Cool art by the way.

I'd change the "FACT:I made this..." spot a spoiler warning and be sure to say that it is a Dying Light spoiler. I've already completed the games, but other readers may have not.

I like this idea, but it would require a lot of thought and make balancing more difficult

AWESOME

This is interesting, but it cannot be used well or even at all until good A.I. is developed for the game. I really like this idea though, so if good A.I. actually does show up, I'd like to see this.

I think that the killer should probably be able to move at 50-75% his normal movement using the ability without he ultra rare add-on. Otherwise, the survivors could just run and hide around a tree or something. Also, horse power's speed bonus is too big. Even with both of the speed perks in the game, the killer can only…

The man, the myth, the legend: Mochael Myors

From my own experience, you just need to know how to play Freddy right to beat the high ranks. I made it to rank 1 using Freddy when I got the hang of him, so I think the only thing stopping people is the skill needed to use Freddy. I'm not saying that Freddy is incredibly hard to use like the nurse, but I would not say…

This looks really nice! I don't know much about Resident Evil, but I at least know Chris and Jill, so this would be amazing to have!

My poor Freddy is getting talked about behind his back. This is a sad day for Freddy mains everywhere. (Although I am good at Freddy, he has not surpassed my Michael Myers main, and is therefore not worthy of my profile picture)

Just wondering, what was the inspiration to use Dark Sense and Devour Hope?

I am actually considering that. I just know what I should do to avoid being backstabbed or how to chase someone effectively after said backstab.

Maybe the survivor could fall off of the hook at the end of each stage, pulling the hook down with them, therefore sabotaging the hook as well.

I think that the perk Professor's Knowledge would actually work better as a new add-on for the map that lets you see the auras of survivors within the map's radius. This is mainly because the perk is specific to one item. This could be said about saboteur, but that perk can be used without a toolbox as well.

Amazeballs

I feel like Decisive Strike is fine as it is, since the killer rarely leaves the decisive user alone after they used the perk. This Decisive update is just ensuring that the Decisive user will not escape from the killer.

By god, it's beautiful. I think I'm gonna cry...

Then I'd say that I have to agree with alivebydeadlight with how situational it is. Only Kindred, Alert, Dark Sense, the killer key stone, and Rancor will allow this to work (it already happens with Object of Obsession, so I felt it was meaningless to mention), so that's 4 of the 107 perks in the game, and only 1 add-on. I…

Okay, Raccoon implemented the word "Experiment" in the title for a reason: He was testing how viable camping was. Sure, he got his own results, but he can't just say he got a 4k, can he? He's got to give evidence. The way that I feel about camping is that, although it is a viable strategy, it ruins the fun of the game for…

From what I have seen of the comments of @Raccoon I think I can tell that they were doing this as an actual experiment. Raccoon's main intent was not that of being toxic and posting reactions, but using a different-than-usual playstyle and posting the results of the game. The reason it was a good thing for the thread to be…